| Tue 5/1 @ TBA | Varsity Girls Lacrosse Game | vs. Midwood (Brooklyn, NY)* | | - |
| Tue 5/1 @ TBA | Varsity Boys Volleyball Game | vs. Wagner (Staten Island, NY) | | - |
| Tue 5/1 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Softball Game | @ Port Richmond (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Wed 5/2 @ TBA | Varsity Lacrosse Game | vs. Cardozo (Bayside, NY)* | | - |
| Wed 5/2 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Baseball Game | vs. New Dorp (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Wed 5/2 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Softball Game | @ Port Richmond (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Thu 5/3 @ TBA | Varsity Girls Lacrosse Game | @ Beach Channel (Rockaway Park, NY)* | | - |
| Thu 5/3 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | vs. New Dorp (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Thu 5/3 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Softball Game | @ Port Richmond (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Fri 5/4 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | @ Curtis (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Fri 5/4 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Softball Game | @ Port Richmond (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Fri 5/4 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Lacrosse Game | @ New Dorp (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Sat 5/5 @ 1:30 PM | JV Baseball Game | @ Holy Trinity (Hicksville, NY) | | - |
| Sat 5/5 @ 2:00 PM | JV Baseball Game | @ Holy Trinity (Hicksville, NY) | | - |
| Sat 5/5 @ 4:30 PM | JV Lacrosse Game | @ Monsignor Farrell (Staten Island, NY) | | - |
| Sat 5/5 @ 6:00 PM | Varsity Lacrosse Game | vs. Long Island Lutheran (Brookville, NY) | | - |
| Mon 5/7 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | vs. Curtis (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Mon 5/7 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Lacrosse Game | vs. Midwood (Brooklyn, NY)* | | - |
| Mon 5/7 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Softball Game | vs. Petrides (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Wed 5/9 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | vs. McKee Vo-Tech (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Wed 5/9 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Softball Game | @ McKee Vo-Tech (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Fri 5/11 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | @ McKee Vo-Tech (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Fri 5/11 @ 4:00 PM | Varsity Softball Game | vs. Wagner (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Sat 5/12 @ 12:00 PM | Varsity Baseball Game | @ Xaverian (Brooklyn, NY) | | - |
| Sat 5/12 @ 3:00 PM | Varsity Lacrosse Game | vs. Long Island Lutheran (Brookville, NY) | | - |
| Mon 5/14 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | vs. Wagner (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Wed 5/16 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | @ Wagner (Staten Island, NY)* | | - |
| Wed 5/16 @ 4:00 PM | JV Baseball Game | @ Monsignor Farrell (Staten Island, NY) | | - |
| Wed 5/16 @ 5:30 PM | JV Baseball Game | @ Monsignor Farrell (Staten Island, NY) | | - |
| Thu 5/17 @ 4:00 PM | JV Baseball Game | @ Monsignor Farrell (Staten Island, NY) | | - |
| Sat 5/19 @ 12:30 PM | Varsity Baseball Game | @ Xaverian (Brooklyn, NY) | | - |
| Wed 5/23 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | vs. Riverdale/Kingsbridge Academy (Bronx, NY) | | - |
| Sat 5/26 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | vs. Manhattan Center for Science & Math (New York, NY)*** | | - |
| Sat 5/26 @ TBA | Varsity Baseball Game | vs. Manhattan Center for Science & Math (New York, NY)*** | | - |