2023-24
Head Coach: Dwight Morrow Baseball
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North 1 Group 3
- Overall Record: 2-8
- League Record: 1-5
- DMA Rank: 413
- State Rank: 323
- State Division Rank: 19
2022-23
Head Coach: Dwight Morrow Baseball
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 9-15
- League Record: 2-6
- State Division Rank: 11
- DMA Rank: 426
- State Rank: 245
2021-22
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 7-5-1
- League Record: 0-1-1
- DMA Rank: 196
- State Rank: 106
- State Division Rank: 6
2020-21
Head Coach: Dwight Morrow Baseball
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 4-21
- League Record: 3-8
- State Rank: 327
- State Division Rank: 18
2019-20
Head Coach: Dwight Morrow Baseball
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record:
- League Record:
2018-19
Head Coach: Dwight Morrow Baseball
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record:
- League Record:
2017-18
Head Coach: Dwight Morrow Baseball
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 8-10
- League Record: 3-2
- DMA Rank: 256
- National Rank: 8023
- State Rank: 181
- State Division Rank: 8
2016-17
Head Coach: Dwight Morrow Baseball
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 12-14
- League Record: 7-5
- DMA Rank: 404
- National Rank: 8970
- State Rank: 242
- State Division Rank: 12
2015-16
Head Coach: Mario Lugones Jr.
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 14-15
- League Record: 4-5
- DMA Rank: 483
- National Rank: 9850
- State Rank: 281
- State Division Rank: 16
2014-15
Head Coach: Carmine Battista
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 7-12
- League Record: 4-4
- DMA Rank: 381
- National Rank: 7251
- State Rank: 233
- State Division Rank: 11
2013-14
Head Coach: Carmine Battista
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 1-5-1
- League Record: 0-4
2012-13
Head Coach: Carmine Battista
- League: Big North - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 0-13
- League Record: 0-6
- DMA Rank: 638
- National Rank: 12145
- State Rank: 371
- State Division Rank: 21
2011-12
Head Coach: Carmine Battista
- League: Freelance
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 0-6
- League Record: 0-3
2010-11
- League: Freelance
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 1-5
- League Record: 1-4
2009-10
Head Coach: Carmine Battista
- League: Bergen County - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 0-7
- League Record: 0-4
- DMA Rank: 727
- National Rank: 14725
- State Rank: 395
- State Division Rank: 22
2008-09
Head Coach: Carmine Battista
- League: Bergen County - American
- Division: Division North I Group II
- Overall Record: 0-6
- League Record: 0-5
- DMA Rank: 704
- National Rank: 13820
- State Rank: 374
- State Division Rank: 22
2007-08
Head Coach: Morrow
- League: Bergen County - American
- Division:
- Overall Record: 2-5
- League Record: 1-5
- DMA Rank: 637
- National Rank: 12118
- State Rank: 340