Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

FillmoreAndover

Eagles
7
Panthers
2

The Andover (NY) varsity baseball team lost Tuesday's home non-conference game against Fillmore (NY) by a score of 7-2.

1234567RHE
Fillmore30001037100
Andover1000010242
  • Recap
  • Box Score
  • Matchup Info

Game Stats

Fillmore (25-26)

Fillmore

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.33334307107003
1C. McCumiskey (Jr).25044110000
2James Hillman (Sr).00042001000
4Liam McCumiskey (Fr).50032010000
9Braylon Hatch (Jr).00033000000
10Avery Potter (So).25044110000
14M. Nusbickel (Jr).66743021000
20Isaac Wilcox (Jr).50044223002
21Jared Boon (So).75044332001
27Wade DeRock (So).00044000000
Fillmore

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals10172116.382.6331.015
1C. McCumiskey (Jr)00000001.250.250.500
2James Hillman (Sr)10001002.250.000.250
4Liam McCumiskey (Fr)00100100.667.5001.167
9Braylon Hatch (Jr)00020002.000.000.000
10Avery Potter (So)00000012.250.250.500
14M. Nusbickel (Jr)00001001.750.6671.417
20Isaac Wilcox (Jr)00010001.5002.0002.500
21Jared Boon (So)00000000.7501.5002.250
27Wade DeRock (So)00040002.000.000.000
Fillmore

Baserunning

#Athlete NameSBSBA
Team Totals4
14M. Nusbickel (Jr)3
21Jared Boon (So)1
Fillmore

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals1.00032211100
1C. McCumiskey (Jr)1.00075200
4Liam McCumiskey (Fr)1.00021100
8Blake Washburn (Fr)1.00010100
9Braylon Hatch (Jr)1.00011000
10Avery Potter (So)1.00030300
14M. Nusbickel (Jr)1.00040400
20Isaac Wilcox (Jr)1.00011000
21Jared Boon (So)1.0001313000
Fillmore

Pitching

#Athlete NameERAWLW%APPGSCGSOSVNHPG
Team Totals2.00101.00010
10Avery Potter (So)0.000010
14M. Nusbickel (Jr)2.33101.00010
Fillmore

#Athlete NameIPHRERBBK2B3BHRBFAB
Team Totals74221602625
10Avery Potter (So)100011043
14M. Nusbickel (Jr)64220502222
Fillmore

#Athlete NameOBAOBPWPHBPSFSH/B#PBKPOSB
Team Totals.160.1920087002
10Avery Potter (So).000.2500015001
14M. Nusbickel (Jr).182.1820072001
Stat Supplier Logo

Fillmore's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for baseballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Andover (25-26)

Andover has not entered stats for this game.

Game Story

New York High School Baseball - Fillmore defeats Andover

April 21, 2026: Andover, NY 14806

The Fillmore Eagles baseball team scored 7 runs and held the host Andover Panthers to 2 in the Eagles non-league win on Tuesday.

The Eagles now hold a 5-1 record. They take the field next when they travel to Hinsdale Central for a non-league test on Monday, April 27.

With the defeat, Andover drops to 0-1 on the year. The Panthers travel to Mount Morris (Mount Morris, NY) to play the Blue Devils in a non-league test on Friday, April 24. The Blue Devils go into the test with a record of 0-7. Mount Morris lost 17-4 in their recent league test against Keshequa (Nunda, NY)

Fillmore @ Andover Baseball Game Info

Tue., Apr. 21, 2026 @ 6p
Andover Central School
The Andover (NY) varsity baseball team lost Tuesday's home non-conference game against Fillmore (NY) by a score of 7-2.

Rankings & Records

Fillmore (25-26)

NYSection
15627
OverallLeagueHomeAwayWin %League %RFRA
6-11-04-12-0.8571.0007011

Andover (25-26)

OverallHomeAwayWin %RFRA
1-20-11-1.3331815

Team Scoring Averages

1234567RHE
Fillmore		3.03.21.5.3.51.31.310.07.7.8
Andover		1.51.5.51.03.01.006.04.02.0

Head-to-Head

  • Fillmore won this week
    4/21 @ 6p1234567RHE
    Fillmore30001037100
    Andover1000010242

    The Fillmore (NY) varsity baseball team won Tuesday's away non-conference game against Andover (NY) by a score of 7-2.

    Box score
  • Game starts in 21 day

    The Andover (NY) varsity baseball team has an away non-conference game @ Fillmore (NY) on Sunday, May 17 @ 1:30p.

    Preview game

Team Stat Comparison

FillmoreAndover
.307Batting Average-
.435On Base Percentage-
.471Slugging Percentage-
.959Fielding Percentage-
1.000Win Loss Percentage-

Team Leaders

FillmoreAndoverNational Avg.
#17 Tucker Pomeroy.500Batting Average
-
.245
#21 Jared Boon.565On Base Percentage
-
.389
#20 Isaac Wilcox.941Slugging Percentage
-
.315
0/5 Parker George1.000Fielding Percentage
-
.858
#14 Malcom Nusbickel1.000Win Loss Percentage
-
.541

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Fillmore4-0Andover0-1
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
3/30/26Hinsdale CentralFillmore(W) 25-15/2/26Hinsdale CentralAndover
4/27/26FillmoreHinsdale Central5/11/26AndoverHinsdale Central
4/1/26FillmoreAlfred-Almond4/20/26AndoverAlfred-Almond
5/4/26Alfred-AlmondAndover
5/4/26Alfred-AlmondAndover
4/15/26FillmoreBolivar-Richburg(W) 6-23/30/26AndoverBolivar-Richburg
5/4/26Bolivar-RichburgFillmore5/14/26Bolivar-RichburgAndover
4/17/26FriendshipFillmore(W) 16-04/29/26AndoverFriendship
5/7/26FillmoreFriendship5/18/26FriendshipAndover
4/24/26Avoca CentralFillmore(W) 11-15/8/26Avoca CentralAndover
4/29/26Genesee ValleyFillmore4/17/26AndoverGenesee Valley(L) 6-2
5/18/26FillmoreGenesee Valley5/7/26Genesee ValleyAndover
5/5/26Jasper-TroupsburgFillmore4/27/26Jasper-TroupsburgAndover

Record Breakdown

Fillmore (25-26)

Andover (25-26)
6-1
Overall
1-2
1-0
League
0-0
5-1
Non-League
1-2
1-0
Head to Head
0-1
4-0
Common Opponent
0-1
4-1
Home
0-1
2-0
Away
1-1
0-0
Neutral
0-0
0-0
Playoff
0-0
6-1
In-State
1-2
0-0
Out-of-State
0-0