Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

Cathedral McCutcheon

Fighting Irish

Mavericks

The McCutcheon (Lafayette, IN) varsity softball team lost Wednesday's home non-conference game against Cathedral (Indianapolis, IN) by a score of 3-2.

	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	R	H	E
Cathedral	0	0	0	0	0	2	1	3	3	0
McCutcheon	1	0	1	0	0	0	0	2	7	3

Recap
Box Score
Awards
Matchup Info

Game Stats

McCutcheon (24-25)

Cathedral

Batting

#	Athlete Name	Avg	PA	AB	R	H	RBI	2B
	Team Totals	.231	28	26	3	6	3	1
2	J. Hazelwood (Fr)		3	3
3	Angie Valentine (Sr)	.500	3	2		1	2
4	Sydney Matthews (So)	.667	3	3	1	2
5	Anna Moore (Sr)		4	4
6	Amya Gary (Jr)		3	3
8	Lauren Wright (Sr)	.500	2	2		1
12	Ellis Land (Fr)				1
13	C. Hansbrough (So)				1
14	Lola Scarsi (Jr)		1	1
25	Sidney Feczko (Jr)	.333	3	3		1		1
28	Kelsey Beres (Jr)	.333	3	3		1	1
33	Maddie Liter (Sr)		3	2

McCutcheon

Batting

#	Athlete Name	Avg	PA	AB	R	H	RBI
	Team Totals	.292	27	24	2	7	1
2	Sydney Neumayr	.500	3	2	1	1	0
3	Aislyn Patel	.000	3	3	0	0	0
4	Emma Wykoff	.333	3	3	0	1	0
6	Kacie Nading	.333	3	3	0	1	0
8	Molly Davis	.667	3	3	0	2	1
10	Haley Peterson	.500	2	2	0	1	0
11	K. Peckinpaugh	.000	3	3	0	0	0
12	Aubrey Miller	.000	3	3	0	0	0
13	Sydney Osborn	1.000	1	1	0	1	0
16	Mallorie Beutel	.000	3	1	1	0	0

Cathedral

#	Athlete Name	BB	K	LOB	OBP	SLG	OPS
	Team Totals	2	12	10	.286	.269	.555
2	J. Hazelwood (Fr)		3	2	.000	.000	.000
3	Angie Valentine (Sr)	1	1		.667	.500	1.167
4	Sydney Matthews (So)				.667	.667	1.334
5	Anna Moore (Sr)		1	4	.000	.000	.000
6	Amya Gary (Jr)		1	1	.000	.000	.000
8	Lauren Wright (Sr)		1	2	.500	.500	1.000
14	Lola Scarsi (Jr)		1		.000	.000	.000
25	Sidney Feczko (Jr)		2		.333	.667	1.000
28	Kelsey Beres (Jr)				.333	.333	.666
33	Maddie Liter (Sr)	1	2	1	.333	.000	.333

McCutcheon

#	Athlete Name	BB	K	LOB	OBP	SLG	OPS
	Team Totals	3	5	4	.370	.292	.662
2	Sydney Neumayr	1	1	0	.667	.500	1.167
3	Aislyn Patel	0	1	2	.000	.000	.000
4	Emma Wykoff	0	0	1	.333	.333	.666
6	Kacie Nading	0	0	0	.333	.333	.666
8	Molly Davis	0	1	2	.667	.667	1.334
10	Haley Peterson	0	0	0	.500	.500	1.000
11	K. Peckinpaugh	0	2	4	.000	.000	.000
12	Aubrey Miller	0	0	1	.000	.000	.000
13	Sydney Osborn	0	0	0	1.000	1.000	2.000
16	Mallorie Beutel	2	0	0	.667	.000	.667

Cathedral

Baserunning

#	Athlete Name	SB	SBA
	Team Totals	1	2
3	Angie Valentine (Sr)	1	2

McCutcheon

Baserunning

#	Athlete Name	SB
	Team Totals	4
2	Sydney Neumayr	1
4	Emma Wykoff	1
8	Molly Davis	1
16	Mallorie Beutel	1

Cathedral

Fielding

#	Athlete Name	FP	TC	PO	A	DP	SBA	SB	CS	CS%
	Team Totals	1.000	31	21	10	5	2	1	1	.500
2	J. Hazelwood (Fr)	1.000	4	2	2	1
3	Angie Valentine (Sr)	1.000	3	1	2
5	Anna Moore (Sr)	1.000	3	2	1	1
6	Amya Gary (Jr)	1.000	2	2
13	C. Hansbrough (So)	1.000	1	1
25	Sidney Feczko (Jr)	1.000	5	2	3	2
28	Kelsey Beres (Jr)	1.000	6	4	2		2	1	1	.500
33	Maddie Liter (Sr)	1.000	7	7		1

McCutcheon

Fielding

#	Athlete Name	FP	TC	PO	E
	Team Totals	.875	24	21	3
2	Sydney Neumayr	1.000	12	12	0
3	Aislyn Patel	1.000	2	2	0
4	Emma Wykoff	.000	2	0	2
6	Kacie Nading	.500	2	1	1
7	A. Gillespie	1.000	1	1	0
11	K. Peckinpaugh	1.000	2	2	0
12	Aubrey Miller	1.000	2	2	0
16	Mallorie Beutel	1.000	1	1	0

Cathedral

Pitching

#	Athlete Name	ERA	W	L	W%	APP	GS	CG	SO	SV	NH	PG
	Team Totals	2.00	1		1.000	1	1	1
25	Sidney Feczko (Jr)	2.00	1		1.000	1	1	1

McCutcheon

Pitching

#	Athlete Name	ERA	W	L	W%	APP	GS	CG	SO	SV	NH	PG
	Team Totals	0.00	0	0		1				0
11	K. Peckinpaugh	0.00	0	0		1				0

Cathedral

#	Athlete Name	IP	H	R	ER	BB	K	2B	3B	HR	BF	AB
	Team Totals	7	5	2	2	3	5				27	24
25	Sidney Feczko (Jr)	7	5	2	2	3	5				27	24

McCutcheon

#	Athlete Name	IP	H	R	ER	BB	K	2B	3B	HR	BF	AB
	Team Totals	7	3	3	0	2	12			0	28	26
11	K. Peckinpaugh	7	3	3	0	2	12			0	28	26

Cathedral

#	Athlete Name	OBA	OBP	WP	HBP	SF	SH/B	#P
	Team Totals	.208	.296	2				108
25	Sidney Feczko (Jr)	.208	.296	2				108

McCutcheon

#	Athlete Name	OBA	OBP	WP	HBP	SF	SH/B	#P
	Team Totals	.115	.179	1	0			113
11	K. Peckinpaugh	.115	.179	1	0			113

McCutcheon's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for softballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Game Story

Indiana High School Softball - Cathedral sneaks past McCutcheon

May 14, 2025: Lafayette, IN 47909

The Cathedral Fighting Irish softball team scored 3 runs and held the host McCutcheon Mavericks to 2 in the Fighting Irish non-league win on Wednesday.

The Fighting Irish now possess a 21-0 record. They put it on the line next when they host Ben Davis for a non-league battle on Thursday, May 15. Cathedral will confront a Giants team coming off a 10-4 non-league loss to Roncalli (Indianapolis, IN). The Giants record now stands at 10-10.

With the loss, McCutcheon moves to 9-11 on the season. The Mavericks travel to Lafayette Central Catholic (Lafayette, IN) to meet the Knights in a non-league challenge on Thursday, May 15. The Knights go into the challenge with a record of 1-17. Lafayette Central Catholic lost 11-0 in their recent non-league challenge against Seeger (West Lebanon, IN)

Players of the Game

Cathedral (24-25)

Congratulations to #28 Kelsey Beres for being selected the Cathedral Softball Player of the Game.

McCutcheon (24-25)

McCutcheon has not selected any Players of the Game.

Cathedral @ McCutcheon Softball Game Info

Wed., May. 14, 2025 @ 5:30p

At McCutcheon High School

The McCutcheon (Lafayette, IN) varsity softball team lost Wednesday's home non-conference game against Cathedral (Indianapolis, IN) by a score of 3-2.

Rankings & Records

Cathedral (24-25)

IN	Class
2	1

Overall	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	RF	RA
29-2	12-1	10-1	7-0	.935	326	80

McCutcheon (24-25)

IN	Class
76	29

Overall	Conference	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	Conference %	RF	RA
11-15	0-1	2-7	7-7	2-1	.423	.000	182	157

Team Scoring Averages

	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	R	H	E
Cathedral	1.7	2.0	1.9	1.9	1.3	1.5	1.4	10.5	11.0	.6
McCutcheon	1.1	1.7	1.3	1.0	.9	1.1	.3	7.0	8.4	1.8

Team Stat Comparison

Cathedral		McCutcheon
.428	Batting Average	.303
.500	On Base Percentage	.378
.667	Slugging Percentage	.494
.973	Fielding Percentage	.895
.935	Win Loss Percentage	.667

Team Leaders

Cathedral		McCutcheon	National Avg.
#7 Shelby Johnson.667	Batting Average	#16 Mallorie Beutel.449	.287
#7 Shelby Johnson.875	On Base Percentage	#16 Mallorie Beutel.500	.406
#3 Angie Valentine1.094	Slugging Percentage	#11 Kaidynn Peckinpaugh.873	.393
#10 Mackenzie White1.000	Fielding Percentage	#2 Sydney Neumayr.980	.829
#33 Maddie Liter1.000	Win Loss Percentage	#11 Kaidynn Peckinpaugh.800	.558

Common Opponents

School	Common Opp. Rec.		School	Common Opp. Rec.
Cathedral	5-0		McCutcheon	2-4

Date	Away	Home	Result	Date	Away	Home	Result
4/8/25	Cathedral	Harrison	(W) 4-1	4/15/25	McCutcheon	Harrison	(L) 5-1
				5/27/25	McCutcheon	Harrison	(L) 3-1
4/14/25	Cathedral	Danville	(W) 16-5	4/10/25	McCutcheon	Danville	(W) 14-3
4/21/25	Cathedral	Kokomo	(W) 10-3	4/23/25	Kokomo	McCutcheon	(W) 7-3
4/30/25	Cathedral	Noblesville	(W) 7-5	5/19/25	McCutcheon	Noblesville	(L) 7-5
5/1/25	Cathedral	Avon	(W) 15-10	5/8/25	McCutcheon	Avon	(L) 12-2

Record Breakdown

Cathedral (24-25)		McCutcheon (24-25)
29-2	Overall	11-15
0-0	League	0-1
20-2	Non-League	9-11
1-0	Head to Head	0-1
5-0	Common Opponent	2-4
12-1	Home	2-7
10-1	Away	7-7
7-0	Neutral	2-1
6-0	Playoff	0-1
28-2	In-State	11-15
1-0	Out-of-State	0-0