Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

WagnerTottenville

Falcons
1
Pirates
3

The Tottenville (Staten Island, NY) varsity soccer team won Thursday's home non-conference match against Wagner (Staten Island, NY) by a score of 3-1.

12Final
Wagner--1
Tottenville--3
Final score provided by S. ScoreFinder.
  • Recap
  • Matchup Info

Match Story

New York High School Soccer - Tottenville Wagner

September 18, 2025: Staten Island, NY 10312

Fans at Thursday's non-league battle between the Tottenville Pirates (Staten Island, NY) and the visiting Wagner Falcons (Staten Island, NY), saw Tottenville's soccer squad knock off Wagner by a final score of 3-1.

With the triumph, Tottenville moves its record to 3-0 on the campaign. The Pirates travel to New Dorp (Staten Island, NY) to meet the Central Cougars in a non-league match on Monday, September 22. The Central Cougars come into the match with a record of 3-0. New Dorp won 5-2 in their recent non-league battle against McKee Vo-Tech (Staten Island, NY)

Next up, the Falcons confront the McKee Vo-Tech Seagulls (Staten Island, NY) in a non-league match, on Tuesday, September 30. Wagner will attempt to move on its 1-2 season record.

Wagner @ Tottenville Soccer Match Info

Thu., Sep. 18, 2025 @ 4p
The Tottenville (Staten Island, NY) varsity soccer team won Thursday's home non-conference match against Wagner (Staten Island, NY) by a score of 3-1.

Rankings & Records

Wagner (25-26)

NationalNYSection
3,10127157
OverallHomeAwayWin %GFGA
4-42-22-2.5002413

Tottenville (25-26)

NationalNYSection
989746
OverallHomeAwayWin %GFGA
8-1-24-0-14-1-1.8184317

Team Scoring Averages

12Final
Wagner		003.0
Tottenville		1.02.03.9

Head-to-Head

  • Tottenville won on 9/18/2025
    9/18 @ 4p12Final
    Wagner--1
    Tottenville--3

    The Wagner (Staten Island, NY) varsity soccer team lost Thursday's away non-conference match against Tottenville (Staten Island, NY) by a score of 3-1.

    Box score
  • Tottenville won last month
    10/9 @ 4p12Final
    Tottenville--2
    Wagner000

    The Tottenville (Staten Island, NY) varsity soccer team won Thursday's away non-conference match against Wagner (Staten Island, NY) by a score of 2-0.

    Box score

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Wagner4-2Tottenville4-0-2
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
9/11/25McKee Vo-TechWagner(W) 3-19/9/25TottenvilleMcKee Vo-Tech(W) 4-3
9/30/25WagnerMcKee Vo-Tech(W) 4-110/5/25McKee Vo-TechTottenville(T) 1-1
9/13/25Port RichmondWagner9/11/25TottenvillePort Richmond(W) 8-1
10/11/25Port RichmondWagner(W) 7-09/30/25Port RichmondTottenville(W) 8-1
10/14/25WagnerPort Richmond(W) 7-1
9/16/25WagnerNew Dorp(L) 2-19/22/25TottenvilleNew Dorp(T) 1-1
10/7/25New DorpWagner(L) 3-110/14/25New DorpTottenville(W) 4-3

Record Breakdown

Wagner (25-26)

Tottenville (25-26)
4-4
Overall
8-1-2
0-0
League
0-0
4-4
Non-League
8-1-2
0-2
Head to Head
2-0
4-2
Common Opponent
4-0-2
2-2
Home
4-0-1
2-2
Away
4-1-1
0-0
Neutral
0-0
0-0
Playoff
0-0
4-4
In-State
8-1-2
0-0
Out-of-State
0-0