| 8/30/21 | Hartford | Lawrence | | | 8/28/21 | Hartford | New Buffalo | |
| 9/1/21 | Lawrence | Covert | | | 10/20/21 | New Buffalo | Covert | |
| 9/7/21 | Lawrence | Eau Claire | | | 10/5/21 | New Buffalo | Eau Claire | |
| 9/8/21 | Lawrence | Eau Claire | | | | | | |
| 10/30/21 | Lawrence | Eau Claire | | | | | | |
| 9/14/21 | River Valley | Lawrence | | | 10/27/21 | River Valley | New Buffalo | |
| 9/15/21 | River Valley | Lawrence | | | | | | |
| 9/29/21 | Michigan Lutheran | Lawrence | | | 9/1/21 | Michigan Lutheran | New Buffalo | |
| 10/4/21 | Bridgman | Lawrence | (L) 3-0 | | 9/11/21 | Bridgman | New Buffalo | (L) 2-0 |
| | | | | 9/25/21 | Bridgman | New Buffalo | (L) 2-0 |
| | | | | 10/11/21 | Bridgman | New Buffalo | (L) 3-1 |
| 10/6/21 | Lawrence | Our Lady of the Lake Catholic | | | 9/8/21 | Our Lady of the Lake Catholic | New Buffalo | |
| | | | | 11/2/21 | New Buffalo | Our Lady of the Lake Catholic | |
| 10/12/21 | Lawrence | Howardsville Christian | | | 9/16/21 | New Buffalo | Howardsville Christian | |
| 10/18/21 | Grace Christian | Lawrence | | | 9/29/21 | New Buffalo | Grace Christian | |
| 10/27/21 | Countryside Academy | Lawrence | | | 10/13/21 | Countryside Academy | New Buffalo | |
| | | | | 10/14/21 | Countryside Academy | New Buffalo | |
