Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

The Oakcrest (Mays Landing, NJ) varsity soccer team lost Tuesday's home non-conference match against The Pilgrim Academy (Egg Harbor City, NJ) by a score of 5-1.

	1	2	Final
The Pilgrim Academy	-	-	5
Oakcrest	-	-	1

Final score provided by C. Baehner.

Recap
Box Score
Matchup Info

Match Stats

The Pilgrim Academy (25-26)

The Pilgrim Academy

Field Stats

#	Athlete Name	Goals	Asst	Pts
	Team Totals	5	9	19
2	Kai Conley (Sr)	1		2
3	Brennan Ruga (Sr)		1	1
5	Jared McGonagle (Sr)	1		2
6	Robert Seary (Jr)		1	1
8	John Clemento (Jr)	1		2
9	Jake Menno (So)		1	1
14	Owen Ruga (Fr)	1		2
16	Ben Peterson (Fr)		1	1
17	Liam Goodrich (Sr)		2	2
18	Jason Remlein (So)		1	1
20	Mason Parmer (Sr)	1	2	4

The Pilgrim Academy

#	Athlete Name	G	Shots	SOG %
	Team Totals	5	7	.0
2	Kai Conley (Sr)	1	1	.0
5	Jared McGonagle (Sr)	1	2	.0
8	John Clemento (Jr)	1	1	.0
9	Jake Menno (So)		3	.0
14	Owen Ruga (Fr)	1
20	Mason Parmer (Sr)	1

The Pilgrim Academy

Goaltending

#	Athlete Name	G. Min	OT Min	Opp SOG	GA	Saves	Save %	GAA
	Team Totals				1	6
	Owen Seavey (Sr)				1	6

The Pilgrim Academy

#	Athlete Name	PK Saves	PKA	SO	Win	Loss	Tie
	Team Totals				1
	Owen Seavey (Sr)				1

Oakcrest (25-26)

Oakcrest has not entered stats for this match.

Match Story

New Jersey High School Soccer - The Pilgrim Academy knocks off Oakcrest

September 23, 2025: Mays Landing, NJ 08330

The The Pilgrim Academy Pioneers soccer team scored 5 points and limited the host Oakcrest Falcons to 1 in the Pioneers non-league triumph on Tuesday.

Next, the Pioneers face the Abundant Life Academy (Nutley, NJ) in a Jersey United game, on Friday, September 26. The Pilgrim Academy will attempt to advance on its 4-3 season record. The come into the game with a 2-3 record after their 3-0 league win over Kearny Christian Academy (Kearny, NJ).

The Falcons (5-1) will now prepare for their game against Absegami (Galloway, NJ). The Braves come into the non-league game with a 2-2 record.

TPA @ Oakcrest Soccer Match Info

Tue., Sep. 23, 2025 @ 4p

Oakcrest Turf

The Oakcrest (Mays Landing, NJ) varsity soccer team lost Tuesday's home non-conference match against The Pilgrim Academy (Egg Harbor City, NJ) by a score of 5-1.

Rankings & Records

The Pilgrim Academy (25-26)

National	NJ
2,308	128

Overall	League	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	League %	GF	GA
17-4	9-2	8-3	7-1	2-0	.810	.818	76	21

Oakcrest (25-26)

National	NJ	Div.
5,399	284	14

Overall	League	Home	Away	Win %	League %	GF	GA
12-3-2	8-0-1	6-2-1	6-1-1	.765	.944	39	15

Team Scoring Averages

	1	2	OT1	Final
The Pilgrim Academy	1.9	1.5	1.0	3.6
Oakcrest	1.3	1.3	0	2.3

Team Stat Comparison

The Pilgrim Academy		Oakcrest
75	Goals	-
63	Assists	-
131	Shots	-

Team Leaders

The Pilgrim Academy		Oakcrest	National Avg.
#5 Jared McGonagle17	Goals	-	4
#3 Brennan Ruga10	Assists	-	3
#9 Jake Menno27	Shots	-	12

Common Opponents

School	Common Opp. Rec.		School	Common Opp. Rec.
The Pilgrim Academy	1-0		Oakcrest	1-0

Date	Away	Home	Result		Date	Away	Home	Result
10/9/25	Holy Spirit	The Pilgrim Academy	(W) 5-1		9/22/25	Oakcrest	Holy Spirit	(W) 4-0

Record Breakdown

The Pilgrim Academy (25-26)		Oakcrest (25-26)
17-4	Overall	12-3-2
9-2	League	8-0-1
5-1	Non-League	4-2-1
1-0	Head to Head	0-1
1-0	Common Opponent	1-0
8-3	Home	6-2-1
7-1	Away	6-1-1
2-0	Neutral	0-0
2-0	Playoff	0-1
17-4	In-State	12-3-2
0-0	Out-of-State	0-0