Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

CommackSmithtown East

Cougars
34
Bulls
37

The Smithtown East (Smithtown, NY) varsity football team won Saturday's home non-conference game against Commack (NY) by a score of 37-34.

Q1Q2Q3Q4Final
Commack----34
Smithtown East----37
Final score provided by A. Panchuk.
  • Recap
  • Scoretracker
  • Matchup Info

Game Story

New York High School Football - Smithtown East nips Commack

October 4, 2025: Smithtown, NY 11787

The crowd at Saturday's non-league contest between the Smithtown East Bulls (Smithtown, NY) and the visiting Commack Cougars (Commack, NY), witnessed Smithtown East's football squad edge Commack by a tally of 37-34.

The Bulls (2-2) will now prepare for their contest against Deer Park (Deer Park, NY). The Falcons enter the Section 11 Division II contest with a 1-3 record. In their last bout, Deer Park was tipped by Northport (Northport, NY), 33-6, in a league bout.

The Cougars now own a 1-3 record. They play next when they host Copiague for a Section 11 Division II bout on Saturday, October 11. Commack will encounter a Eagles team coming off a 27-17 league win over Centereach (Centereach, NY). The Eagles record now stands at 2-2.

Anthony PanchukCougars Reporter
  • All
  • Q2
  • Q3
  • Q4
  • F

  1. Check In

    2nd Quarter
    21 - 7 The scorer has checked in. Commack 21, SEHS 7
    Posted @ 6:47p

  2. Game Attendance

    2nd Quarter
    Attendance At least 1,000
    Posted @ 6:48p

  3. Field Conditions

    2nd Quarter
    Field Conditions Dry
    Posted @ 6:48p

  4. Weather Conditions

    2nd Quarter
    Weather Conditions Fair
    Posted @ 6:48p
  5. 21 - 13

    Passing Touchdown

    Smithtown East2nd Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - Pass completed for a TD. Commack 21, SEHS 13
    Posted @ 6:49p
  6. 21 - 14

    Made Point After

    Smithtown East2nd Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - PAT Good. Commack 21, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 6:50p
  7. 24 - 14

    Field Goal

    Commack2nd Quarter Under a minute
    Commack - Field Goal. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:26p
  8. 24 - 14

    Halftime

    Halftime
    Commack 24, SEHS 14
    We noticed it's halftime, please enjoy this video while you wait for the action to resume.
    Posted @ 7:26p
  9. 24 - 14

    Start of 3rd Quarter

    Commack3rd Quarter
    Commack to kick off to Smithtown East.
    Posted @ 7:31p
  10. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~11 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 1st down, ~11 minutes to go, ball on their own 35-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:32p
  11. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~11 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 2nd down, ~11 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 44-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:33p
  12. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~10 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 2nd down, ~10 minutes to go, ball on their own 38-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:34p
  13. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~10 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 3rd down, ~10 minutes to go, ball on their own 38-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:35p
  14. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~10 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 4th down, ~10 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 35-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:35p
  15. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~9 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 1st down, ~9 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 32-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:36p
  16. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~9 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 1st down, ~9 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 20-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:36p
  17. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 2nd down, ~8 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 17-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:37p
  18. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 3rd down, ~8 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 17-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:37p
  19. 24 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~7 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 2nd down, ~7 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 4-yard line. Commack 24, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:38p
  20. 27 - 14

    Score Correction

    Commack3rd Quarter
    Score correction for Commack in 3rd Quarter. Commack 27, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:39p
  21. 27 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~6 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 3rd down, ~6 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 8-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:39p
  22. 27 - 14

    Big Play - Sack

    Commack3rd Quarter ~6 minutes to go
    Commack with a sack. Smithtown East has the ball on Commack's 20-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:40p
  23. 27 - 14

    Update

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~5 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 4th down, ~5 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 20-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 14
    Posted @ 7:40p
  24. 27 - 17

    Field Goal

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~5 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 27 Yd Field Goal. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:40p
  25. 27 - 17

    Possession Update - Kickoff

    Commack3rd Quarter ~5 minutes to go
    Smithtown East kicked off to Commack. Commack has the ball on Smithtown East's 43-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:42p
  26. 27 - 17

    Long Run

    Commack3rd Quarter ~5 minutes to go
    Commack with a long run. Commack has the ball on Smithtown East's 40-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:43p
  27. 27 - 17

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Commack - 2nd down, ~4 minutes to go, ball on Smithtown East's 39-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:44p
  28. 27 - 17

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Commack - 2nd down, ~4 minutes to go, ball on Smithtown East's 49-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:46p
  29. 27 - 17

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Commack - 2nd down, ~4 minutes to go, ball on their own 39-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:47p
  30. 27 - 17

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Commack - 2nd down, ~4 minutes to go, ball on their own 36-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:48p
  31. 27 - 17

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Commack - 3rd down, ~4 minutes to go, ball on their own 43-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:49p
  32. 27 - 17

    Long Pass

    Commack3rd Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    Commack with a long pass. Commack has the ball on Smithtown East's 43-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:50p
  33. 27 - 17

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    Commack - 1st down, ~3 minutes to go, ball on Smithtown East's 26-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:50p
  34. 27 - 17

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    Commack - 1st down, ~3 minutes to go, ball on Smithtown East's 3-yard line. Commack 27, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:51p
  35. 33 - 17

    Rushing Touchdown

    Commack3rd Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    Commack - 3 Yd Rushing TD. Commack 33, SEHS 17
    Posted @ 7:51p
  36. 33 - 23

    Kick Return Touchdown

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - Kick Return for a TD. Commack 33, SEHS 23
    Posted @ 7:54p
  37. 33 - 24

    Made Point After

    Smithtown East3rd Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - #24 PAT Good. Commack 33, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 7:55p
  38. 34 - 24

    Score Correction

    Commack3rd Quarter
    Score correction for Commack in 3rd Quarter. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 7:55p
  39. 34 - 24

    Possession Update - Kickoff

    Commack3rd Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    Smithtown East kicked off to Commack. Commack has the ball on Smithtown East's 49-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 7:57p
  40. 34 - 24

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~2 minutes to go
    Commack - 2nd down, ~2 minutes to go, ball on Smithtown East's 44-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 7:58p
  41. 34 - 24

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter ~1 minute to go
    Commack - 2nd down, ~1 minute to go, ball on Smithtown East's 37-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 7:59p
  42. 34 - 24

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter Under a minute
    Commack - 2nd down, Under a minute, ball on their own 48-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:01p
  43. 34 - 24

    Update

    Commack3rd Quarter Under a minute
    Commack - 3rd down, Under a minute, ball on their own 46-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:02p

  44. Game Delayed

    3rd Quarter
    The game has been delayed. Injury
    Posted @ 8:02p
  45. 34 - 24

    End of 3rd Quarter

    4th Quarter
    Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:04p
  46. 34 - 24

    Update

    Commack4th Quarter ~11 minutes to go
    Commack - 4th down, ~11 minutes to go, ball on Smithtown East's 47-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:06p
  47. 34 - 24

    Punt

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~11 minutes to go
    Commack has punted to Smithtown East. Smithtown East has the ball on their own 13-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:07p
  48. 34 - 24

    Long Run

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~11 minutes to go
    Smithtown East with a long run. Smithtown East has the ball on their own 49-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:08p
  49. 34 - 24

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~11 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 2nd down, ~11 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 24-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:09p
  50. 34 - 24

    Long Run

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~10 minutes to go
    Smithtown East with a long run. Smithtown East has the ball on Commack's 8-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:10p
  51. 34 - 24

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~9 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 2nd down, ~9 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 8-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:11p
  52. 34 - 24

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~9 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 3rd down, ~9 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 8-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:12p
  53. 34 - 24

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~9 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 4th down, ~9 minutes to go, ball on Commack's 8-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 24
    Posted @ 8:12p
  54. 34 - 27

    Field Goal

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - #24 kicks a 15 Yd Field Goal. Commack 34, SEHS 27
    Posted @ 8:13p
  55. 34 - 27

    Possession Update - Kickoff

    Commack4th Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    Smithtown East kicked off to Commack. Commack has the ball on their own 45-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 27
    Posted @ 8:15p
  56. 34 - 27

    Update

    Commack4th Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    Commack - 2nd down, ~8 minutes to go, ball on their own 47-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 27
    Posted @ 8:16p
  57. 34 - 27

    Interception

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~7 minutes to go
    Smithtown East intercepts a Commack pass. Commack 34, SEHS 27
    Posted @ 8:18p
  58. 34 - 27

    Red Zone Alert

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    Smithtown East is inside Commack's 20. Commack 34, SEHS 27
    Posted @ 8:24p
  59. 34 - 33

    Rushing Touchdown

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - 6 Yd Rushing TD. Commack 34, SEHS 33
    Posted @ 8:26p
  60. 34 - 34

    Made Point After

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    Smithtown East - #24 PAT Good. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:26p
  61. 34 - 34

    Fumble Recovery

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    Smithtown East recovered a fumble by Commack and has the ball on their own 34-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:31p
  62. 34 - 34

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~1 minute to go
    Smithtown East - 3rd down, ~1 minute to go, ball on Commack's 41-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:35p

  63. Game Delayed

    4th Quarter
    The game has been delayed. Smithtown time out.
    Posted @ 8:36p
  64. 34 - 34

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter ~1 minute to go
    Smithtown East - 4th down, ~1 minute to go, ball on Commack's 39-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:38p

  65. Game Delayed

    4th Quarter
    The game has been delayed. Smithtown’s second timeout.
    Posted @ 8:38p
  66. 34 - 34

    Punt

    Commack4th Quarter ~1 minute to go
    Smithtown East has punted to Commack. Commack has the ball on their own 34-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:40p
  67. 34 - 34

    Update

    Commack4th Quarter Under a minute
    Commack - 1st down, Under a minute, ball on Smithtown East's 35-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:42p
  68. 34 - 34

    Interception

    Smithtown East4th Quarter Under a minute
    Smithtown East intercepts a Commack pass and has the ball on their own 31-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:46p
  69. 34 - 34

    Long Pass

    Smithtown East4th Quarter Under a minute
    Smithtown East with a long pass. Smithtown East has the ball on Commack's 40-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:47p
  70. 34 - 34

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter Under a minute
    Smithtown East - 1st down, Under a minute, ball on Commack's 37-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:48p

  71. Game Delayed

    4th Quarter
    The game has been delayed. Smithtown’s final timeout.
    Posted @ 8:48p
  72. 34 - 34

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter Under a minute
    Smithtown East - 2nd down, Under a minute, ball on Commack's 18-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:50p

  73. Game Delayed

    4th Quarter
    The game has been delayed. Commack’s second timeout.
    Posted @ 8:51p
  74. 34 - 34

    Update

    Smithtown East4th Quarter Under a minute
    Smithtown East - 1st down, Under a minute, ball on Commack's 14-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 34
    Posted @ 8:53p

  75. Game Delayed

    4th Quarter
    The game has been delayed. Commack’s final timeout.
    Posted @ 8:54p
  76. 34 - 37

    Field Goal

    Smithtown East4th Quarter Under a minute
    Smithtown East - 19 Yd Field Goal. Commack 34, SEHS 37
    Posted @ 8:55p
  77. 34 - 37

    Possession Update - Kickoff

    Commack4th Quarter Under a minute
    Smithtown East kicked off to Commack. Commack has the ball on their own 25-yard line. Commack 34, SEHS 37
    Posted @ 8:57p
  78. 34 - 37

    End of Game

    Final
    Commack 34, SEHS 37
    Posted @ 8:58p

Commack @ SEHS Football Game Info

Sat., Oct. 4, 2025 @ 6p
The Smithtown East (Smithtown, NY) varsity football team won Saturday's home non-conference game against Commack (NY) by a score of 37-34.

Scoretracker Providers

Anthony PanchukCougars Reporter

Rankings & Records

Commack (25-26)

NYSectionState Class
394359
OverallLeagueHomeAwayWin %League %PFPA
3-53-42-21-3.375.429182266

Smithtown East (25-26)

NYSectionState Class
298259
OverallLeagueHomeAwayWin %League %PFPA
5-44-33-12-3.556.571306257

Team Scoring Averages

Q1Q2Q3Q4Final
Commack		5.01.81.87.322.8
Smithtown East		14.07.011.74.734.0

Commack Videos

Commack doesn't have any videos.

Smithtown East Videos

  • Play video icon 10/10 Highlights vs Sayville 3:35
  • Play video icon 09/5 Highlights @ Lindenhurst 3:30

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Commack3-4Smithtown East3-4
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
9/12/25West BabylonCommack(W) 35-710/17/25Smithtown EastWest Babylon(W) 48-7
9/20/25East IslipCommack(L) 42-149/27/25Smithtown EastEast Islip(L) 61-21
9/27/25CommackBellport(L) 47-711/1/25Smithtown EastBellport(L) 20-14
10/11/25CopiagueCommack(W) 36-2910/25/25CopiagueSmithtown East(W) 56-14
10/18/25CommackNorth Babylon(L) 53-439/13/25North BabylonSmithtown East(L) 34-28
10/24/25CommackDeer Park(W) 13-810/10/25Smithtown EastDeer Park(W) 31-21
11/1/25Half Hollow Hills EastCommack(L) 43-011/8/25Smithtown EastHalf Hollow Hills East(L) 59-28

Record Breakdown

Commack (25-26)

Smithtown East (25-26)
3-5
Overall
5-4
3-4
League
4-3
0-1
Non-League
1-0
0-1
Head to Head
1-0
3-4
Common Opponent
3-4
2-2
Home
3-1
1-3
Away
2-3
0-0
Neutral
0-0
0-0
Playoff
0-1
3-5
In-State
5-4
0-0
Out-of-State
0-0