| 9/1/21 | Standish-Sterling | Ithaca | | | 10/20/21 | Bullock Creek | Standish-Sterling | |
| 9/8/21 | Ithaca | Valley Lutheran | | | 9/1/21 | Valley Lutheran | Bullock Creek | |
| 9/15/21 | Millington | Ithaca | | | 9/8/21 | Bullock Creek | Millington | |
| 9/18/21 | Ithaca | Shepherd | (W) 2-0 | | 9/13/21 | Shepherd | Bullock Creek | (W) 2-0 |
| 9/18/21 | Ithaca | Shepherd | (W) 2-0 | | | | | |
| 9/22/21 | Ithaca | Nouvel Catholic Central | | | 8/22/21 | Nouvel Catholic Central | Bullock Creek | |
| | | | | 9/15/21 | Nouvel Catholic Central | Bullock Creek | |
| 9/29/21 | St. Louis | Ithaca | | | 9/22/21 | St. Louis | Bullock Creek | |
| 10/13/21 | Michigan Lutheran Seminary | Ithaca | | | 10/27/21 | Bullock Creek | Michigan Lutheran Seminary | |
| 10/16/21 | Hemlock | Ithaca | | | 9/29/21 | Bullock Creek | Hemlock | |
| 10/27/21 | Ithaca | Hemlock | | | | | | |
| 10/20/21 | Carrollton | Ithaca | | | 10/13/21 | Carrollton | Bullock Creek | |
