Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

South SideEast Islip
Cyclones
14
Redmen
19

The East Islip (Islip Terrace, NY) varsity football team won Friday's neutral playoff game against South Side (Rockville Centre, NY) by a score of 19-14.

This game is a part of the "2023 Fall Boys Football New York: Long Island - Division III" tournament.

Q1Q2Q3Q4Final
South Side707014
East Islip1300619
Final score provided by J. Leotardo.
  • Recap
  • Scoretracker
  • Videos
  • Photos
  • Fan Chat
  • Matchup

Recap Video

Game Story

New York High School Football - East Islip sneaks past South Side

November 24, 2023: Rockville Centre, NY 11570

The East Islip Redmen football squad scored 19 points and restricted the host South Side Cyclones to 14 in the Redmen non-league victory on Friday.

The Redmen now possess a 10-2 record.

Kelly McgrathCyclones Reporter
Jason LeotardoRedmen Reporter
  • All
  • Q1
  • Q2
  • Q3
  • Q4
  • F

  1. Check In

    0 - 0 The scorer has checked in. South Side 0, East Islip 0
    Posted @ 4:36p

  2. Game Attendance

    Attendance Over 5,000
    Posted @ 4:36p

  3. Field Conditions

    Field Conditions Dry
    Posted @ 4:36p

  4. Weather Conditions

    Weather Conditions Cold
    Posted @ 4:36p
  5. 0 - 0

    Start of Game

    South Side1st Quarter
    South Side kicking off to East Islip.
    Posted @ 4:40p
  6. 0 - 6

    Passing Touchdown

    East Islip1st Quarter ~11 minutes to go
    East Islip - 75 Yd pass completed for a TD. South Side 0, East Islip 6
    Posted @ 4:41p
  7. 0 - 7

    Made Point After

    East Islip1st Quarter ~11 minutes to go
    East Islip - PAT Good. South Side 0, East Islip 7
    Posted @ 4:41p
  8. 0 - 13

    Passing Touchdown

    East Islip1st Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    East Islip - #5 Thomas Costarelli 3 Yd pass completed to #27 Matt Mcintee for a TD. South Side 0, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 4:48p
  9. 0 - 13

    Missed Point After

    East Islip1st Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    East Islip - PAT Missed. South Side 0, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 4:48p
  10. 7 - 13

    Score Correction

    South Side1st Quarter
    Score correction for South Side in 1st Quarter. South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:04p
  11. 7 - 13

    End of 1st Quarter

    2nd Quarter
    South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:08p

  12. Commentary

    2nd Quarter
    EI McIntee making play after play for big gains.
    Posted @ 5:11p
  13. 7 - 13

    Interception

    South Side2nd Quarter ~9 minutes to go
    South Side - #4 intercepts a East Islip pass and has the ball on their own 19-yard line. South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:14p
  14. 7 - 13

    Punt

    East Islip2nd Quarter ~7 minutes to go
    South Side has punted to East Islip. East Islip has the ball on their own 31-yard line. South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:19p
  15. 7 - 13

    Long Pass

    East Islip2nd Quarter ~6 minutes to go
    East Islip - #5 Thomas Costarelli with a long pass to #27 Matt Mcintee. East Islip has the ball on South Side's 30-yard line. South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:20p
  16. 7 - 13

    Turnover on Downs

    South Side2nd Quarter ~5 minutes to go
    East Islip has turned possession over on downs. South Side has the ball on their own 27-yard line. South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:23p
  17. 7 - 13

    Punt

    East Islip2nd Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    South Side has punted to East Islip. East Islip has the ball on their own 35-yard line. South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:27p
  18. 7 - 13

    Update

    East Islip2nd Quarter Under a minute
    East Islip - 2nd down, Under a minute, ball on South Side's 12-yard line. South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:32p
  19. 7 - 13

    Missed FG

    South Side2nd Quarter Under a minute
    East Islip turned over possession on a missed field goal. South Side has the ball on their own 14-yard line. South Side 7, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 5:36p
  20. 7 - 13

    Halftime

    Halftime
    South Side 7, East Islip 13
    We noticed it's halftime, please enjoy this video while you wait for the action to resume.
    Posted @ 5:36p
  21. 7 - 13

    Start of 3rd Quarter

    East Islip3rd Quarter
    East Islip to kick off to South Side.
    Posted @ 5:58p
  22. 13 - 13

    Fumble Recovery Returned for Touchdown

    South Side3rd Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    South Side - #22 Michael Melkonian with a 1-yard fumble return touchdown. South Side 13, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 6:04p
  23. 14 - 13

    Made Point After

    South Side3rd Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    South Side - PAT Good. South Side 14, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 6:04p

  24. Commentary

    3rd Quarter
    South Side #4 running towards the endzone lost the ball at the 1 and #22 picked it up and fell forward for the TD.
    Posted @ 6:07p
  25. 14 - 13

    End of 3rd Quarter

    4th Quarter
    South Side 14, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 6:24p

  26. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    Through 3 quarters
    Posted @ 6:25p
  27. 14 - 13

    Update

    East Islip4th Quarter ~8 minutes to go
    East Islip - 1st down, ~8 minutes to go, ball on South Side's 40-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 6:29p
  28. 14 - 13

    Long Run

    East Islip4th Quarter ~7 minutes to go
    East Islip - #5 Thomas Costarelli with a long run. East Islip has the ball on South Side's 25-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 6:30p
  29. 14 - 13

    Update

    East Islip4th Quarter ~6 minutes to go
    East Islip - 3rd down, ~6 minutes to go, ball on South Side's 27-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 13
    Posted @ 6:32p
  30. 14 - 19

    Passing Touchdown

    East Islip4th Quarter ~6 minutes to go
    East Islip - #5 Thomas Costarelli 27 Yd pass completed to #27 Matt Mcintee for a TD. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:33p
  31. 14 - 19

    Passing Two Point Conversion Failed

    East Islip4th Quarter ~6 minutes to go
    East Islip - 2Pt Conversion Failed. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:34p
  32. 14 - 19

    Update

    South Side4th Quarter ~4 minutes to go
    South Side - 3rd down, ~4 minutes to go, ball on their own 17-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:38p

  33. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    South Side facing a 4th down from their own 17 with 3:47 left in 4th choose to punt.
    Posted @ 6:40p
  34. 14 - 19

    Update

    East Islip4th Quarter ~3 minutes to go
    East Islip - 1st down, ~3 minutes to go, ball on South Side's 21-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:41p

  35. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    EI ball at South Side 18 yard line 2:38 to go.
    Posted @ 6:42p
  36. 14 - 19

    Turnover on Downs

    South Side4th Quarter ~2 minutes to go
    East Islip has turned possession over on downs. South Side has the ball on their own 18-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:44p

  37. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    4th down and 8 for South Side 2:15 left
    Posted @ 6:47p

  38. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    1st down
    Posted @ 6:48p
  39. 14 - 19

    Update

    South Side4th Quarter ~2 minutes to go
    South Side - 1st down, ~2 minutes to go, ball on their own 36-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:48p
  40. 14 - 19

    Update

    South Side4th Quarter Under a minute
    South Side - 1st down, Under a minute, ball on East Islip's 29-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:53p
  41. 14 - 19

    Update

    South Side4th Quarter Under a minute
    South Side - 3rd down, Under a minute, ball on East Islip's 26-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:54p

  42. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    :18 seconds
    Posted @ 6:55p

  43. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    In a crazy situation, players scrambling all over the field. The South Side quarterback spiked the ball on fourth down to stop the clock…
    Posted @ 6:57p

  44. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    Huge mistake
    Posted @ 6:57p
  45. 14 - 19

    Turnover on Downs

    East Islip4th Quarter Under a minute
    South Side has turned possession over on downs. East Islip has the ball on their own 20-yard line. South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 6:58p

  46. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    EI in Victory Formation
    Posted @ 6:59p

  47. Commentary

    4th Quarter
    East Islip has won the Div III LIC
    Posted @ 7:02p
  48. 14 - 19

    End of Game

    Final
    South Side 14, East Islip 19
    Posted @ 7:04p

Highlight Videos

  • Play video icon 10-yard Run vs South Side 0:15
  • Play video icon Tackle for Loss vs South Side 0:48

Game Photos

Photos by Ray Passaro

  1. MaxPreps Staff

    Beware of spam! Please do not follow links to third party sites. Report suspicious posts using the 'Report Spam' button.

  2. J. Ruecker

    Dont miss the latest updates,check Ig: federal_fb23

Scoretracker Providers

Kelly McgrathCyclones Reporter
Jason LeotardoRedmen Reporter

Rankings & Records

South Side (23-24)

NYSectionState Class
3633
OverallLeagueHomeAwayNeutralWin %League %PFPA
10-26-15-04-11-1.833.857343100

East Islip (23-24)

NYSectionState Class
1311
OverallLeagueHomeAwayNeutralWin %League %PFPA
10-25-25-02-23-0.833.714336158

Team Scoring Averages

Q1Q2Q3Q4Final
South Side		9.811.27.04.628.6
East Islip		6.86.07.25.828.0

South Side Videos

  • Play video icon South Side football highlights Hewlett High School 0:49

East Islip Videos

  • Play video icon Recap: East Islip vs. Sayville 2023 3:02
  • Play video icon Recap: East Islip vs. Westhampton Beach 2023 2:50

Record Breakdown

South Side (23-24)

East Islip (23-24)
10-2
Overall
10-2
6-1
League
5-2
1-0
Non-League
1-0
0-1
Head to Head
1-0
0-0
Common Opponent
0-0
5-0
Home
5-0
4-1
Away
2-2
1-1
Neutral
3-0
3-1
Playoff
4-0
10-2
In-State
10-2
0-0
Out-of-State
0-0