Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

Conotton ValleyGaraway

Rockets
6
Pirates
3

The Garaway (Sugarcreek, OH) varsity softball team lost Friday's home non-conference game against Conotton Valley (Bowerston, OH) in extra innings by a score of 6-3.

123456789RHE
Conotton Valley0011100036101
Garaway1000002003101
  • Recap
  • Box Score
  • Matchup Info

Game Stats

Conotton Valley (25-26)

Garaway (25-26)

Conotton Valley

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.2734233696002
1Gretchin Rolli (Sr).33343110000
2Ava Williams (Jr).40055122000
3Arionna Spano (Jr).25044110000
5Ashtyn Walker (Sr).00043000000
6Jenica Frutig (Sr).00055000000
10Brooklyn Kelley (So).33353111000
12D. Williams (Sr).40055020000
14Maddison Kelley (Sr).66753223002
15Emma Karns (Fr).00052000000
Garaway

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.29440343102200
4Jaylene Jimenez (Jr).25044110000
7Krista Miller (Sr).50054021000
9Landri Miller (Fr).00022000000
10True Tango (So).50054220000
12Audrey Miller (Jr).00021000000
13Sofia Conner (So).00022000000
17Kyleigh LaCroix (So).00022000000
19Klayah Glazer (Sr).25044010000
20Keaton Yoder (So).50054021100
25Nadia Pope (Jr).50054020100
28Kayla Miller (Sr).00043000000
Conotton Valley

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals14371219.342.455.797
1Gretchin Rolli (Sr)01000100.333.333.666
2Ava Williams (Jr)00010001.400.400.800
3Arionna Spano (Jr)00010002.250.250.500
5Ashtyn Walker (Sr)01010003.000.000.000
6Jenica Frutig (Sr)00010102.000.000.000
10Brooklyn Kelley (So)11010001.250.333.583
12D. Williams (Sr)00000014.400.400.800
14Maddison Kelley (Sr)00200000.8002.6673.467
15Emma Karns (Fr)01121002.500.000.500
Garaway

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals0241200210.368.353.721
4Jaylene Jimenez (Jr)00020011.250.250.500
7Krista Miller (Sr)01000012.500.5001.000
9Landri Miller (Fr)00010003.000.000.000
10True Tango (So)00100000.600.5001.100
12Audrey Miller (Jr)00110003.500.000.500
13Sofia Conner (So)00010000.000.000.000
17Kyleigh LaCroix (So)00020002.000.000.000
19Klayah Glazer (Sr)00010000.250.250.500
20Keaton Yoder (So)01010000.500.7501.250
25Nadia Pope (Jr)00110002.600.7501.350
28Kayla Miller (Sr)00120005.250.000.250
Conotton Valley

Baserunning

#Athlete NameSBSBA
Team Totals4
1Gretchin Rolli (Sr)1
2Ava Williams (Jr)1
7Leah Haney (So)1
10Brooklyn Kelley (So)1

Baserunning

Garaway has not entered any baserunning stats.
Conotton Valley

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals.97439271110
2Ava Williams (Jr).00010010
3Arionna Spano (Jr)1.00010100
4Whitney Watkins (Sr)1.00043100
5Ashtyn Walker (Sr)1.00077000
6Jenica Frutig (Sr)1.00041300
10Brooklyn Kelley (So)1.00042200
12D. Williams (Sr)1.0001312100
14Maddison Kelley (Sr)1.00052300
Garaway

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals.97438271010
4Jaylene Jimenez (Jr)1.00052300
5Zoe Jump (Sr)1.00033000
7Krista Miller (Sr)1.00022000
9Landri Miller (Fr)1.00010100
10True Tango (So)1.00042200
13Sofia Conner (So)1.00044000
17Kyleigh LaCroix (So)1.00011000
19Klayah Glazer (Sr)1.00077000
20Keaton Yoder (So).88996210
24Annabelle King (Fr)1.00020200
Conotton Valley

Pitching

#Athlete NameERAWLW%APPGSCGSOSVNHPG
Team Totals1.56101.00010
14Maddison Kelley (Sr)1.56101.00010
Garaway

Pitching

#Athlete NameERAWLW%APPGSCGSOSVNHPG
Team Totals3.1101.00010
5Zoe Jump (Sr)0010
9Landri Miller (Fr)3.8201.00010
24Annabelle King (Fr)2.620010
Conotton Valley

#Athlete NameIPHRERBBK2B3BHRBFAB
Team Totals9103241204036
14Maddison Kelley (Sr)9103241204036
Garaway

#Athlete NameIPHRERBBK2B3BHRBFAB
Team Totals910643724238
9Landri Miller (Fr)3.24321311816
24Annabelle King (Fr)5.16322412422
Conotton Valley

#Athlete NameOBAOBPWPHBPSFSH/B#P
Team Totals.278.35000133
14Maddison Kelley (Sr).278.35000133
Garaway

#Athlete NameOBAOBPWPHBPSFSH/B#P
Team Totals.263.33301125
9Landri Miller (Fr).250.3330142
24Annabelle King (Fr).273.3330083
Stat Supplier Logo

Conotton Valley's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for softballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Stat Supplier Logo

Garaway's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for softballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Game Story

Ohio High School Softball - Conotton Valley Garaway

April 24, 2026: Sugarcreek, OH 44681

The Conotton Valley Rockets softball team scored 6 runs and held the host Garaway Pirates to 3 in the Rockets non-league win on Friday.

The Rockets now sport a 9-6 record. They put it on the line next when they travel to New Philadelphia for a non-league battle on Saturday, April 25. Conotton Valley will confront a Quakers team coming off a 3-2 non-league loss to River View (Warsaw, OH). The Quakers record now stands at 5-12.

With the loss, Garaway moves to 14-4 on the season. The Pirates host Sandy Valley (Magnolia, OH) to confront the Cardinals in a Inter Valley South battle on Monday, April 27. The Cardinals come into the battle with a record of 14-5. Sandy Valley won 22-1 in their recent non-league battle against Malvern (Malvern, OH)

CVHS @ Garaway Softball Game Info

Fri., Apr. 24, 2026 @ 5p
The Garaway (Sugarcreek, OH) varsity softball team lost Friday's home non-conference game against Conotton Valley (Bowerston, OH) in extra innings by a score of 6-3.

Rankings & Records

Conotton Valley (25-26)

OHDiv.
17516
OverallConferenceHomeAwayNeutralWin %Conference %RFRA
17-911-19-16-72-1.654.91718470

Garaway (25-26)

OHDiv.
672
OverallConferenceHomeAwayWin %Conference %RFRA
23-59-313-310-2.821.75027074

Team Scoring Averages

123456789RHE
Conotton Valley		1.7.81.6.91.0.9.403.07.17.3.7
Garaway		2.21.51.81.91.2.71.5009.611.51.6

Team Stat Comparison

Conotton ValleyGaraway
.285Batting Average.397
.373On Base Percentage.452
.471Slugging Percentage.655
.957Fielding Percentage.956
.682Win Loss Percentage.750

Team Leaders

Conotton ValleyGarawayNational Avg.
#14 Maddison Kelley.516Batting Average#11 Kayla Coblentz1.000.289
#14 Maddison Kelley.605On Base Percentage#11 Kayla Coblentz1.000.408
#14 Maddison Kelley1.344Slugging Percentage#9 Landri Miller1.250.398
#12 Delilah Williams1.000Fielding Percentage#1 Calli Hostetler1.000.829
#10 Brooklyn Kelley1.000Win Loss Percentage#24 Annabelle King.833.561

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Conotton Valley10-1Garaway7-1
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
3/26/26Buckeye TrailConotton Valley(W) 12-24/3/26Buckeye TrailGaraway(W) 12-1
4/13/26Conotton ValleyBuckeye Trail(W) 7-15/19/26GarawayBuckeye Trail
4/6/26MalvernConotton Valley(W) 19-14/17/26GarawayMalvern(W) 16-0
4/8/26Conotton ValleyMalvern(W) 18-2
4/14/26Conotton ValleyStrasburg-Franklin(L) 4-13/28/26Strasburg-FranklinGaraway(L) 8-3
4/28/26Strasburg-FranklinConotton Valley(W) 2-15/8/26GarawayStrasburg-Franklin(W) 7-6
4/22/26Conotton ValleyTuscarawas Central Catholic(W) 10-14/21/26GarawayTuscarawas Central Catholic(W) 15-0
5/11/26Tuscarawas Central CatholicConotton Valley(W) 15-1
4/29/26NewcomerstownConotton Valley(W) 2-04/10/26GarawayNewcomerstown(W) 8-1
4/30/26Conotton ValleyNewcomerstown(W) 14-8
5/16/26RidgewoodConotton Valley(W) 9-34/6/26GarawayRidgewood(W) 12-1
4/8/26GarawayRidgewood(W) 8-0

Record Breakdown

Conotton Valley (25-26)

Garaway (25-26)
17-9
Overall
23-5
13-1
League
9-3
4-8
Non-League
12-2
1-0
Head to Head
0-1
10-1
Common Opponent
7-1
9-1
Home
13-3
6-7
Away
10-2
2-1
Neutral
0-0
0-0
Playoff
0-0
14-6
In-State
23-5
3-3
Out-of-State
0-0