Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

CaldwellConotton Valley

Redskins
0
Rockets
4

The Conotton Valley (Bowerston, OH) varsity softball team won Thursday's neutral playoff game against Caldwell (OH) by a score of 4-0.

1234567RHE
Caldwell0000000021
Conotton Valley0000301490
  • Recap
  • Box Score
  • Matchup Info

Game Stats

Caldwell (25-26)

Conotton Valley (25-26)

Caldwell

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.0912322020000
2Makayla Mumaw (Sr).33333010000
3Lexi Franklin (Sr).00033000000
4B. Moracco (Jr).00033000000
7Cami Arick (So).00022000000
10Mattie Hessson (Jr).00022000000
16Sophia Marshall (Sr).33333010000
18C. Marshall (So).00021000000
22Colie Arick (Sr).00033000000
23Mea Hendershot (Fr).00022000000
Conotton Valley

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.2763129484201
1Gretchin Rolli (Sr).33333110000
2Ava Williams (Jr).00043001000
3Arionna Spano (Jr).33333010000
5Ashtyn Walker (Sr).00032000000
6Jenica Frutig (Sr).00033000000
10Brooklyn Kelley (So).50044220100
12D. Williams (Sr).25044010000
14Maddison Kelley (Sr).75044133101
15Emma Karns (Fr).00033000000
Caldwell

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals010110012.091.091.182
2Makayla Mumaw (Sr)00020000.333.333.666
3Lexi Franklin (Sr)00030001.000.000.000
4B. Moracco (Jr)00010000.000.000.000
7Cami Arick (So)00010000.000.000.000
10Mattie Hessson (Jr)00000001.000.000.000
16Sophia Marshall (Sr)00010000.333.333.666
18C. Marshall (So)01010000.000.000.000
22Colie Arick (Sr)00010011.000.000.000
23Mea Hendershot (Fr)00010000.000.000.000
Conotton Valley

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals11070216.267.448.715
1Gretchin Rolli (Sr)00000001.333.333.666
2Ava Williams (Jr)10010102.000.000.000
3Arionna Spano (Jr)00010000.333.333.666
5Ashtyn Walker (Sr)01000000.000.000.000
6Jenica Frutig (Sr)00010005.000.000.000
10Brooklyn Kelley (So)00010001.500.7501.250
12D. Williams (Sr)00000113.250.250.500
14Maddison Kelley (Sr)00000000.7501.7502.500
15Emma Karns (Fr)00030004.000.000.000

Baserunning

Caldwell has not entered any baserunning stats.
Conotton Valley

Baserunning

#Athlete NameSBSBA
Team Totals1
10Brooklyn Kelley (So)1
Caldwell

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals.9662921710
2Makayla Mumaw (Sr)1.00041300
3Lexi Franklin (Sr)1.00021100
4B. Moracco (Jr)1.00011000
7Cami Arick (So)1.00011000
10Mattie Hessson (Jr).75041210
16Sophia Marshall (Sr)1.00077000
18C. Marshall (So)1.00077000
22Colie Arick (Sr)1.00022000
23Mea Hendershot (Fr)1.00010100
Conotton Valley

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals.9632720610
1Gretchin Rolli (Sr).00010010
2Ava Williams (Jr)1.00011000
4Whitney Watkins (Sr)1.00043100
5Ashtyn Walker (Sr)1.00033000
6Jenica Frutig (Sr)1.00021100
10Brooklyn Kelley (So)1.00021100
12D. Williams (Sr)1.0001111000
14Maddison Kelley (Sr)1.00030300
Caldwell

Pitching

#Athlete NameERAWLW%APPGSCGSOSVNHPG
Team Totals3.0001.00010
2Makayla Mumaw (Sr)3.0001.00010
Conotton Valley

Pitching

#Athlete NameERAWLW%APPGSCGSOSVNHPG
Team Totals0.00101.00010
14Maddison Kelley (Sr)0.00101.00010
Caldwell

#Athlete NameIPHRERBBK2B3BHRBFAB
Team Totals79430713131
2Makayla Mumaw (Sr)79430713131
Conotton Valley

#Athlete NameIPHRERBBK2B3BHRBFAB
Team Totals6.210001002222
14Maddison Kelley (Sr)6.210001002222
Caldwell

#Athlete NameOBAOBPWPHBPSFSH/B#P
Team Totals.290.2900084
2Makayla Mumaw (Sr).290.2900084
Conotton Valley

#Athlete NameOBAOBPWPHBPSFSH/B#P
Team Totals.045.0450074
14Maddison Kelley (Sr).045.0450074
Stat Supplier Logo

Caldwell's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for softballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Stat Supplier Logo

Conotton Valley's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for softballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Game Story

Ohio High School Softball - Caldwell Conotton Valley

May 21, 2026: Caldwell, OH 43724

In Thursday's non-league test, the Conotton Valley Rockets (Bowerston, OH) softball squad the host Caldwell Redskins (Caldwell, OH), by a tally of 4-0.

Caldwell vs CVHS Softball Game Info

Thu., May. 21, 2026 @ 5p
The Conotton Valley (Bowerston, OH) varsity softball team won Thursday's neutral playoff game against Caldwell (OH) by a score of 4-0.

Rankings & Records

Caldwell (25-26)

OHDiv.
17015
OverallConferenceHomeAwayNeutralWin %Conference %RFRA
20-48-113-25-12-1.833.88917981

Conotton Valley (25-26)

OHDiv.
12311
OverallConferenceHomeAwayNeutralWin %Conference %RFRA
20-1011-111-16-73-2.667.91721173

Team Scoring Averages

123456789RHE
Caldwell		.9.71.21.21.31.11.4--7.59.41.7
Conotton Valley		2.0.81.5.81.1.8.403.07.07.6.7

Team Stat Comparison

CaldwellConotton Valley
.354Batting Average.290
.421On Base Percentage.374
.546Slugging Percentage.470
.936Fielding Percentage.957
.833Win Loss Percentage.692

Team Leaders

CaldwellConotton ValleyNational Avg.
#12 Hailee Hull.500Batting Average#14 Maddison Kelley.514.288
#5 Kali Astorga.667On Base Percentage#14 Maddison Kelley.606.406
#4 Breighlee Moracco.857Slugging Percentage#14 Maddison Kelley1.324.395
#13 Amaya Moten1.000Fielding Percentage#12 Delilah Williams1.000.828
#2 Makayla Mumaw.895Win Loss Percentage#10 Brooklyn Kelley1.000.557

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Caldwell1-1Conotton Valley3-0
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
3/25/26CaldwellBuckeye Trail(W) 13-13/26/26Buckeye TrailConotton Valley(W) 12-2
4/13/26Conotton ValleyBuckeye Trail(W) 7-1
4/9/26RidgewoodCaldwell(L) 10-45/16/26RidgewoodConotton Valley(W) 9-3

Record Breakdown

Caldwell (25-26)

Conotton Valley (25-26)
20-4
Overall
20-10
10-1
League
13-1
9-2
Non-League
4-8
0-1
Head to Head
1-0
1-1
Common Opponent
3-0
13-2
Home
11-1
5-1
Away
6-7
2-1
Neutral
3-2
1-1
Playoff
3-1
19-3
In-State
17-7
1-1
Out-of-State
3-3