Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

CastonBremen

Comets
19
Lions
3

The Bremen (IN) varsity softball team lost Monday's home non-conference game against Caston (Fulton, IN) by a score of 19-3.

1234567RHE
Caston511030--19231
Bremen02100--351
Final score provided by M. Huppert.
  • Recap
  • Box Score
  • Awards
  • Matchup Info

Box Score Stats

Caston (25-26)

Bremen (25-26)
1
Double Plays
1

Game Stats

Caston (25-26)

Bremen (25-26)

Caston

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.6224337192318401
1Lexie Field (Fr).60055332000
3Natalie Warner (Jr).75054431100
4Hadlie Coffing (So).25054013000
6Avery Baldwin (Sr).75044133000
7Mia Mersch (So).66753221000
10Abby Apperson (So).60055230000
11Kylee Logan (Sr)1.00055453200
14Myli Rude (Sr).50054222001
42J. Middleton (Fr).33343113100
Bremen

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.25026203531
2I. Calentine (Sr)11
3Madi Milleman (Jr)321
4Karla Arias (Fr)22
6Eliana Grubbs (Sr)1.0003221
7M. Shumaker (Sr)421
8Kenzie Scott (So).5002212
11McKenna Binkley (Fr)22
12Peyton Reed (Sr)11
13Peyton Johnson (So).5003211
14Faith Hostetler (So)11
15Lili Cullen (Fr).500221
17Aubri O'Keefe (So)211
Caston

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals10421056.651.8111.462
1Lexie Field (Fr)00000021.600.6001.200
3Natalie Warner (Jr)00100001.8001.0001.800
4Hadlie Coffing (So)10010011.200.250.450
6Avery Baldwin (Sr)00010001.750.7501.500
7Mia Mersch (So)00200000.800.6671.467
8Ava Russell (So)00000001
10Abby Apperson (So)00000010.600.6001.200
11Kylee Logan (Sr)000000001.0001.4002.400
14Myli Rude (Sr)00001010.6001.2501.850
42J. Middleton (Fr)00100001.500.6671.167
Bremen

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals3731.423.300.723
3Madi Milleman (Jr)1.333.000.333
4Karla Arias (Fr)2.000.000.000
6Eliana Grubbs (Sr)11.0001.5002.500
7M. Shumaker (Sr)11.500.000.500
8Kenzie Scott (So)1.500.5001.000
11McKenna Binkley (Fr)2.000.000.000
12Peyton Reed (Sr)1.000.000.000
13Peyton Johnson (So)11.667.5001.167
15Lili Cullen (Fr)1.500.5001.000
17Aubri O'Keefe (So)1.500.000.500
Caston

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals.9552215612
3Natalie Warner (Jr)1.00010100
4Hadlie Coffing (So)1.00030300
10Abby Apperson (So).75041211
11Kylee Logan (Sr)1.00088000
14Myli Rude (Sr)1.00066001
Bremen

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals.955221561
2I. Calentine (Sr)1.00011
3Madi Milleman (Jr)1.00033
6Eliana Grubbs (Sr)1.000725
7M. Shumaker (Sr)1.00033
8Kenzie Scott (So)1.00011
11McKenna Binkley (Fr)1.00011
13Peyton Johnson (So).750431
15Lili Cullen (Fr)1.00011
17Aubri O'Keefe (So)1.00011
Caston

Pitching

#Athlete NameERAWLW%APPGSCGSOSVNHPG
Team Totals2.80101.00020
3Natalie Warner (Jr)0.000010
4Hadlie Coffing (So)3.50101.00010
Bremen

Pitching

#Athlete NameERAWLW%APPGSCGSOSVNHPG
Team Totals29.081.00011
6Eliana Grubbs (Sr)11.411
7M. Shumaker (Sr)11
10Lexi Mammon (So)1
18Carter Mason (Fr)67.741.0001
Caston

#Athlete NameIPHRERBBK2B3BHRBFAB
Team Totals55324702620
3Natalie Warner (Jr)111012075
4Hadlie Coffing (So)44223501915
Bremen

#Athlete NameIPHRERBBK2B3BHRBFAB
Team Totals4.122191852414336
6Eliana Grubbs (Sr)312551222321
10Lexi Mammon (So)33230
18Carter Mason (Fr)11011102211714
Caston

#Athlete NameOBAOBPWPHBPSFSH/B#P
Team Totals.250.42312107
3Natalie Warner (Jr).200.4291133
4Hadlie Coffing (So).267.4210174
Bremen

#Athlete NameOBAOBPWPHBPSFSH/B#P
Team Totals.611.66711
6Eliana Grubbs (Sr).571.5911
10Lexi Mammon (So)1.0001
18Carter Mason (Fr).714.7501
Stat Supplier Logo

Caston's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for softballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Game Story

Indiana High School Softball - Bremen knocked off by Caston

May 4, 2026: Bremen, IN 46506

The Caston Comets overwhelmed the host Bremen Lions softball squad by a count of 19-3 in Monday's non-league challenge.

Next, the Comets meet the Manchester Squires (North Manchester, IN) in a non-league challenge, on Tuesday, May 5. Caston will attempt to upgrade on its 8-4 season record.

The Lions (4-12) will now prepare for their challenge against Knox (Knox, IN). The Redskins go into the Northern State challenge with a 14-3 record. In their last challenge, Knox toppled Tri-County (Wolcott, IN), 5-2, in a non-league challenge.

Players of the Game

Caston (25-26)

Caston has not selected any Players of the Game.

Bremen (25-26)

Congratulations to #6 Eliana Grubbs for being selected the Bremen Softball Player of the Game.

Caston @ Bremen Softball Game Info

Mon., May. 4, 2026 @ 5:30p
The Bremen (IN) varsity softball team lost Monday's home non-conference game against Caston (Fulton, IN) by a score of 19-3.

Rankings & Records

Caston (25-26)

INClass
22340
OverallConferenceHomeAwayNeutralWin %Conference %RFRA
11-104-46-45-50-1.524.500187140

Bremen (25-26)

INClass
26469
OverallConferenceHomeAwayNeutralWin %Conference %RFRA
7-202-83-104-80-2.259.200164247

Team Scoring Averages

1234567RHE
Caston		2.12.01.51.2.91.9.18.99.32.8
Bremen		1.31.4.41.01.0.9.86.17.52.6

Team Stat Comparison

CastonBremen
.346Batting Average.284
.427On Base Percentage.389
.491Slugging Percentage.379
.887Fielding Percentage.908
.550Win Loss Percentage.259

Team Leaders

CastonBremenNational Avg.
#11 Kylee Logan.559Batting Average#6 Eliana Grubbs.552.287
#44 Wrigley DeBarge.667On Base Percentage#10 Lexi Mammon1.000.406
#11 Kylee Logan.912Slugging Percentage#6 Eliana Grubbs.828.395
#25 Bella Girton1.000Fielding Percentage#14 Faith Hostetler1.000.828
#3 Natalie Warner.750Win Loss Percentage#10 Lexi Mammon1.000.556

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Caston1-0Bremen1-0
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
5/14/26CastonTriton(W) 15-34/29/26TritonBremen(W) 12-2

Record Breakdown

Caston (25-26)

Bremen (25-26)
11-10
Overall
7-20
4-4
League
2-8
7-5
Non-League
4-10
1-0
Head to Head
0-1
1-0
Common Opponent
1-0
6-4
Home
3-10
5-5
Away
4-8
0-1
Neutral
0-2
0-1
Playoff
0-1
11-10
In-State
7-20
0-0
Out-of-State
0-0