2025-26
Head Coach: Trent Phegley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 17-7
- Conference Record: 6-1
- DMA Rank: 110
- State Rank: 252
- State Division Rank: 37
2024-25
Head Coach: Trent Phegley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 17-8
- Conference Record: 6-1
- DMA Rank: 108
- State Rank: 256
- State Division Rank: 28
2023-24
Head Coach: Trent Phegley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 7-16
- Conference Record: 3-4
- DMA Rank: 161
- State Rank: 410
- State Division Rank: 73
2022-23
Head Coach: JD Hoover
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 11-13
- Conference Record: 4-3
- DMA Rank: 151
- State Rank: 366
- State Division Rank: 58
2021-22
Head Coach: Bill Bland
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 6-17
- Conference Record: 1-5
- DMA Rank: 165
- State Rank: 422
- State Division Rank: 80
2020-21
Head Coach: Bill Bland
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 8-10
- Conference Record: 3-2
- State Rank: 386
- State Division Rank: 67
2019-20
Head Coach: Joe Smith
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 3-20
- Conference Record: 2-3
- DMA Rank: 179
- National Rank: 18960
- State Rank: 439
- State Division Rank: 91
2018-19
Head Coach: Joe Smith
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 11-13
- Conference Record: 4-1
- DMA Rank: 150
- National Rank: 16025
- State Rank: 374
- State Division Rank: 65
2017-18
Head Coach: Joe Smith
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 8-17
- Conference Record: 2-1
- DMA Rank: 168
- National Rank: 17355
- State Rank: 409
- State Division Rank: 75
2016-17
Head Coach: Joe Smith
- Conference: Hoosier Heartland - West
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 6-18
- Conference Record: 0-2
- DMA Rank: 172
- National Rank: 17494
- State Rank: 424
- State Division Rank: 79
2015-16
Head Coach: Joe Smith
- Conference: Hoosier Heartland- East
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 3-21
- Conference Record: 2-3
- DMA Rank: 175
- National Rank: 17029
- State Rank: 433
- State Division Rank: 87
2014-15
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 5-19
- Conference Record: 1-6
- DMA Rank: 165
- National Rank: 15883
- State Rank: 408
- State Division Rank: 83
2013-14
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 7-15
- Conference Record: 4-3
- DMA Rank: 162
- National Rank: 15344
- State Rank: 391
- State Division Rank: 77
2012-13
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 8-13
- Conference Record: 4-5
- DMA Rank: 145
- National Rank: 12958
- State Rank: 343
- State Division Rank: 54
2011-12
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 4-18
- Conference Record: 4-5
- DMA Rank: 177
- National Rank: 16555
- State Rank: 425
- State Division Rank: 86
2010-11
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 10-11
- Conference Record: 5-3
- DMA Rank: 149
- National Rank: 12543
- State Rank: 344
- State Division Rank: 58
2009-10
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 16-5
- Conference Record: 7-1
- DMA Rank: 97
- National Rank: 7898
- State Rank: 229
- State Division Rank: 18
2008-09
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: Division 1A
- Overall Record: 13-8
- Conference Record: 6-2
- DMA Rank: 130
- National Rank: 11756
- State Rank: 314
- State Division Rank: 43
2007-08
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: -
- Overall Record: 10-11
- Conference Record: 3-5
- DMA Rank: 139
- National Rank: 13567
- State Rank: 337
2006-07
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: -
- Overall Record: 10-12
- Conference Record: 4-4
- DMA Rank: 123
- National Rank: 12457
- State Rank: 300
2005-06
Head Coach: Rush McColley
- Conference: Midwest
- Division: -
- Overall Record: 11-10
- Conference Record: 4-4
- DMA Rank: 122
- National Rank: 10933
- State Rank: 272
2004-05
Head Coach: Joe Smith
- Conference: -
- Division: -
- Overall Record: 7-12
- Conference Record: 3-3