Who is really No. 1 - Shiloh Christian or Trinity?

By Mitch Stephens Sep 3, 2010, 8:42am

Herbstreit National Kickoff showdown not only pits Arkansas and Texas powers, but man versus machine rankings as well.

ARLINGTON, Texas – One team has been basking in the national spotlight for almost a decade.

One team is one victory away from diving there helmet first.


One team flexes and powers and muscles up.

One team spreads and diverts and throws abound.

One team is from football-renowned Texas.



One team is from neighboring Arkansas, known for its hogs, apple blossoms and fiddles.

Despite the differences, there is one impressive and distinct common denominator: both are No. 1 in the country.

At least that’s according to MaxPreps.com, which ranks high school football teams nationally by two different methods, a computer, or the Freeman rankings, and via writers, the human element, called the Xcellent 25.

Trinity (Euless, Texas), the old dog in this national trick, is No. 1 among the writers. Shiloh Christian, the new kid on the turf from Springdale, Ark., is tops according to the computer.

The two face off Monday at a most appropriate destination – the Shangri Lai of sports stadiums – the $1.2-billion Cowboys Stadium with its monstrous 72-foot tall video board that weighs approximately 1.2 million pounds.

It is the opening act of a four-game set in the Kirk Herbstreit National Kickoff Classic in Texas. Kickoff is scheduled for 10:30 a.m. (Central Time) and will be televised live by Fox Sports Net.



The other three games will be televised as well and feature, perennial national power St. Thomas Aquinas (Fort Lauderdale, Fla.) against Skyline (Dallas) at 1:30 p.m., Cedar Hill (Texas) versus Guyer (Denton, Texas) at 4:30 p.m. and DeSoto (Texas) against Bowie (Arlington, Texas) at 7:30 p.m.

There will be more than a two dozen future Division I stars showcased in the star-studded event, but the double No. 1 showdown is indeed the main event. 

Kiehl Frazier should keep Shiloh close with his arm and legs.
Kiehl Frazier should keep Shiloh close with his arm and legs.
Photo by Richey Miller
When Shiloh Christian jumped to the top spot on the computer rankings – the Saints are No. 22 in the Xcellent 25 – following an impressive 54-22 opening-week win over Watson Chapel, coach Josh Floyd wasn’t sure whether to laugh or tear up his underdog card.

“Well, it’s exciting (being ranked No. 1) for the fans and the program, but not so much for the coaches,” he said good-naturedly on Wednesday. “We’ve addressed it with the team. We’re not going to bring it up. Our philosophy is let’s just take care of the season and if we get ranked somewhere high at the end, then let’s get excited.”

But frankly, there’s already so much about the program and current team to get the heart pumping.

Pride and tradition



The Saints have played in four straight state championship games, winning three including last season when they went 13-1. The school, located in the northwestern region of Arkansas – in a town considered the largest meat producing company in the world and touted the “Chicken Capital of the World” – opened in 1976 and started playing football in 1989.

Shiloh Christian has won six state crowns, the first in 1998 when Floyd was the starting senior quarterback. He took over as head coach seven seasons ago and has a 71-13 record. In 21 years plus, the Saints are 198-67-2.

“We’ve been able to maintain some pride and tradition,” Floyd said. “I think we’ve improved over time by playing a tough non-conference schedule. We’ve gone outside the area to see how we’d do against better competition and that’s helped us, win or lose.”

The biggest win in school history probably wasn’t a state-title game, but last year’s 37-36 season-opening triumph at perennial national power Evangel Christian Academy (Shreveport, La.). The season before, the Saints flopped in their first huge national test, losing at home to Evangel 47-9.

Trinity's Brandon Carter (10) is heading to Oklahoma.
Trinity's Brandon Carter (10) is heading to Oklahoma.
Photo by Keith Owens
“(The victory last season) was a big boost for our confidence,” Floyd said.

They’ll need to throw their collective chests way out to slug it out with Trinity, a Texas large-school champion three of the last five years – 2005, 2007 and 2009.



Though talent is surely abundant – and with the likes of receiver Brandon Carter and tailback Tevin Williams this year is no different – what drives the Trojans is a cattle line of beefy linemen, a blue collar approach and a tradition of excellence set forth by 43-year coaching veteran Steve Lineweaver.

“They don’t have ridiculous talent year-to-year,” Dallas Morning News columnist and MaxPreps correspondent Max Wixon said. “But they’re a machine. They have a solid team concept and they just plug in the pieces year after year.”

Lineweaver told us two years ago: “Obviously we have some good players roll through here. And we’ve got good support from our administration. But I think most important is we’re a blue collar area. The kids don’t stay inside a lot.”

Rock stars


That’s made Lineweaver’s job a whole lot easier. Then again, he’s been successful wherever he’s coached including winning a state 3A championship at Commerce.

“A coach’s worst nightmare is having to go around the halls convincing kids into playing (football),” he said. “You don’t have to do that at Trinity. They all want to come out and play. It’s kind of a popular thing to be a member of the Trojans football team.”



Same goes for Floyd at Shiloh.

Shiloh lineman Samuel Harvill is going to Kansas State.
Shiloh lineman Samuel Harvill is going to Kansas State.
Photo by Richey Miller
The Saints are definitely rock stars around Springdale as shown in their glitzy and highly professional video montages displayed on their extravagant team website.

“It’s time to leave our legacy,” is the credo of the current group and no doubt a victory against Trinity would cement it.

Floyd said the opportunity to make the five-hour road trip to Dallas to play in the colossal Cowboys’ Stadium is, well, colossal.

“It’s an opportunity we just couldn’t pass up,” he said “As exciting as it is, I’ve made it quite clear that this is a football game and we need to do all the things necessary to win.

“They have a big and strong football team with great athletes. We have to make some stops. These guys obviously don’t mess around. We know we have to play a great football game.”



But, just as obviously, he has some great players to get the job done, starting at quarterback.

Auburn-commit Kiehl Frazier is considered the second best dual-threat quarterback in the country, according to MaxPreps/CBS College Sports recruiting expert Tom Lemming.

He passed for more than 3,800 yards and 48 touchdowns in 2009 and is supported by a pair of Division I linemen, Kansas-commit Travis Bodenstein (6-5, 295) and Kansas State-bound Samuel Harvill (6-0, 255).

As big and physical as Trinity is up front, Floyd thinks he has the linemen to compete.

“We do feel like our defensive lines is one of our strengths,” he said. “Up and down in the trenches the game will likely be decided.”

Battle of attrition



If that’s the case, Trinity certainly seems to have an edge in size and depth.

Shiloh Christian, with 40 on its roster, has 12 lineman larger than 200 pounds, including 6-5, 292-pound sophomore Jacob Ralph. Trinity boasts 88 players, including 39 linemen, with 36 of them at least 200 pounds, 18 larger than 250 and five more than 300 pounds.

Trinity first-year QB Kautai was impressive last week.
Trinity first-year QB Kautai was impressive last week.
Photo by Keith Owens
Trinity should win the attrition war.

They also have the skill set, starting with Oklahoma-bound Carter (5-11, 160), who had 111 yard receiving yards and two touchdowns last week in a 35-0 win over a very good Lee squad. Carter, who scored the game-winning overtime touchdown in last year’s state-title game, 41-38 over Westlake, is also supposed to play quarterback in Wildcat formations.

Lineweaver didn't show it off much against Lee.

Instead, first-year starting quarterback Kailahi Kautai was, like most Trinity signal-callers - very efficient - completing 9 of 13 passes for 155 yards and rushing for 91 more. He had to replace Willie Hubbard, who last year was the MVP of the district without eye-opening numbers.



The bulk of the running will be from Williams, who last year in this event was the star with 22 carries for 210 yards and three touchdowns in a 41-21 win over nationally-ranked Bingham (Utah), and Terrrence Tusan.

Last year Williams, a 6-1, 185-pound specimen, got hurt at midseason but the Trojans simply went to Tusan a 5-5, 155-pound scatback who went for 1,237 yards and 21 touchdowns. With five starters back on the offensive line the running game should be formidably and the defense, as proved in last week’s shutout, is stout.

Other college players are Baylor-bound Suleiman Masumbuko (6-3, 270), a defensive lineman and tight end Nila Kasitati (6-4, 270), along with uncommitted linebacker Jonathan Yenga, who had 167 tackles last season.

Trinity seems to have the advantage of being near home and having played in Cowboys Stadium last year. Shiloh Christian has played just once in Texas in 2006. The Saints defeated Prestonwood Christian, the then defending TAPPs champion from Plano, to open the season.

Shiloh went on to go 14-0 and win the state crown.

“That was a very good experience for us,” Floyd said. “We’re hoping for another.”

Look for previews of the other three Herbstreit Texas games on Monday.