NFL playoffs: Patrick Mahomes vs. Josh Allen showdown highlights Texas-California quarterback rivalry

By Mitch Stephens Jan 21, 2022, 11:30am

Six of eight remaining playoff signal-callers from either Golden or Longhorn states.

The bragging rights of Texas and California continue to mount this weekend with the NFL playoffs. The two states boast three native quarterbacks each as four games will determine the finalists for the NFC and AFC championship games.

The two states have traditionally featured the game's top players in the sport's premier position.

Entering the 2021 season, 13 of the 30 NFL teams started quarterbacks who prepped in either Texas (seven) or California (six).

On Saturday, Ryan Tannehill from Big Spring (Texas) leads Tennessee against Cincinnati at 4:30 p.m. (ET), followed by Aaron Rodgers of Pleasant Valley (Chico, Calif.) and his Green Bay Packers, hosting the San Francisco 49ers at 8:15 p.m.



On Sunday, Texas and California quarterbacks square off in both games as Matt Stafford of Highland Park (Dallas) and his Los Angeles Rams travel to Tampa Bay to face the Bucs and Tom Brady of Serra (San Mateo, Calif.) at 3 p.m., followed by Josh Allen of Firebaugh (Calif.) and the Buffalo Bills traveling to the Kansas City Chiefs and Patrick Mahomes, of Whitehouse (Texas) at 6:30 p.m.
Patrick Mahomes accounted for more than 5,500 yards and 65 touchdowns his senior year at Whitehouse.
Patrick Mahomes accounted for more than 5,500 yards and 65 touchdowns his senior year at Whitehouse.
File photo by Kyle Dantzler
Other Texas natives to be named starting quarterbacks for their NFL teams to start the season: Chicago's Andy Dalton of Katy, Philadelphia's Jalen Hurts of Channelview, Cleveland's Baker Mayfield of Lake Travis (Austin) and Arizona's Kyler Murray of Allen.

Other California natives as 2021 starting NFL quarterbacks: Oakland's Derek Carr of Bakersfield Christian (Bakersfield), Carolina's Sam Darnold of San Clemente and Detroit's Jared Goff of Marin Catholic (Kentfield).

Other states to lay claim to current NFL playoff quarterbacks are Illinois with San Francisco's Jimmy Garoppolo of Rolling Meadows and Ohio with Cincinnati's Joe Burrow of Athens (The Plains).

If rating this weekend's California-Texas quarterbacks as high school players/college prospects, it would go like this:

1. Stafford: A 2006 graduate, the then-6-foot-3, 210-pounder was a five-star recruit and the No. 1 rated pro-style quarterback in the country. Despite missing three games with a knee injury, he completed 209 of 322 his senior season for 4,108 yards and 38 touchdowns leading Highland Park to a 15-0 record and 4A-1 state title. At the time, Mel Kiper Jr. predicted Stafford would someday be a No. 1 pick overall in a NFL Draft, which he was in 2009.

2. Mahomes: The MaxPreps 2013-14 Male Athlete of the Year was a three-sport star at Whitehouse, where he might have been better known in baseball and basketball. He did have a remarkable senior football season, accounting for more than 5,500 yards and 65 touchdowns for the 12-1 Wildcats, earning him 4A Texas State Player of the Year honors by the Associated Press. He was ranked the No. 398 recruit overall nationally by 247Sports and No. 29-rated QB. Mahomes had three college offers and picked Texas Tech.



3. Brady: Now considered the G.O.A.T, Brady was barely recruited as a quarterback out of Serra. Instead the left-hand hitting catcher was known as a top baseball prospect. He didn't play a down of tackle football until his freshman season and even then he was a backup on a winless team. But his big right arm eventually caught the attention of some. He threw for 3,514 yards and 33 touchdowns as a two-year varsity starter but neither squad made the playoffs. He did garner enough attention to secure a scholarship at Michigan.

4. Tannehill: Known more as an all-around athlete, Tannehill actually was a defensive back as a sophomore at Big Spring, before displaying moderate success as a dual-threat starting quarterback his final two seasons. He threw for 2,510 and rushed for 922 as a junior and 1,258 and 617 during an injury-plagued senior campaign. Also a basketball and track and field standout, Tannehill was rated a three-star football recruit, the No. 80 rated player overall in Texas and accepted his only Division I offer to Texas A&M.

5. Rodgers: At an unimposing 5-10, 165 pounds, Rodgers got no Division I offers as a senior despite starting two years and throwing for more than 4,440 yards. He set several school records including single-game marks of 440 all-purpose yards and six touchdowns. He could have walked on at Illinois, but instead made big impressions at Butte College in Northern California before transferring to Cal.

6. Allen: Also a three-sport standout at Firebaugh, Allen had no football recruiting rankings coming out of high school despite throwing for more than 5,200 career yards in three varsity seasons and 59 touchdowns. He was the team's leading scorer on the basketball team and at 6-3, 180-pounds at the time, could throw a baseball 90 mph. He was offered to walk on at San Diego State but instead opted to play quarterback at Reedley College, a JUCO, for one season before moving on to Wyoming.