Flag football showdown lives up to the hype as No. 2 JSerra hands No. 1 Orange Lutheran first loss, 18-7

By Steve Montoya Sep 30, 2025, 9:45pm

Defense comes up big for the Lions as they improve to 20-0.

In an anticipated flag football game that matched up the top two teams in the nation Tuesday, No. 2 JSerra Catholic (San Juan Capistrano, Calif.) knocked off previously-unbeaten Orange Lutheran (Orange, Calif.) 18-7. 

JSerra Catholic leaned on a relentless defense and timely plays from its young quarterbacks to improve to 20-0 on the year. Orange Lutheran, the defending Southern Section Division 1 champion, dropped to 18-1.

Tessa Russell of JSerra set the tone early, jumping a route and racing in for a pick-six to give the Lions a 6-0 first-quarter lead. Orange Lutheran answered in the second period when star quarterback Makena Cook converted a fourth-and-goal with a strike to Josie Anderson for a touchdown and extra point to put the Lancers ahead 7-6. Freshman Ava Irwin came up with a big-time interception late in the first half to stall an Orange Lutheran drive.

The Lions grabbed momentum to open the second half as freshman quarterback Kate Meier scrambled in for a touchdown on fourth down to put the Lions back on top 12-7. 

Both defenses continued to trade stops until JSerra struck again early in the fourth when sophomore quarterback Ava Van Heerde found Irwin on a 20-yard touchdown pass to extend the lead to 18-7.

Sterling Flores intercepted Cook midway through the fourth quarter before Russell sealed the win with her second pick of the game. The Lions held Orange Lutheran well below their season scoring average of over 35 points per game.
Sophomore quarterback Ava Van Heerde accounted for one touchdown in the big win for JSerra Catholic. (PHOTO: Ming Chung Lin)
Sophomore quarterback Ava Van Heerde accounted for one touchdown in the big win for JSerra Catholic. (PHOTO: Ming Chung Lin)