High school football amid the pandemic: Is it working?

By Mitch Stephens Sep 21, 2020, 11:15am

Majority of states playing while some have flipped calendars after seeing successes navigating health protocols.

Preparing late last week for their nationally televised ESPNU game, Alabama high school football coaches Josh Floyd and Mark Freeman attended to similar due diligence tasks. None had to do with special teams, trick plays or conditioning.

Try spraying helmets, temperature checks and wiping down lockers, instead.

"Just trying to keep things normal and keep them safe," said Floyd before his No. 44 Hewitt-Trussville (Trussville) squad lost a 35-21 home game defending 7A state champion Thompson (Alabaster)

Said Freeman, whose team moved up four spots to No. 16 in the MaxPreps Top 25 with the victory: "We are just very blessed and thankful to be playing football. Thank the Lord everything is going well."

As well as can be expected during a global pandemic anyway.



Alabama is one of 27 states playing football in the fall, though seven more plan to join by the end of October.

That leaves 16 states committed to kick off in 2021, although Colorado last week gave its schools the option to play in either the fall or the spring. Thus far, 125 Colorado teams have opted for the fall and 28 in the spring.
Thompson's Sam Reynolds avoids would-be Hewitt-Trussville tacklers in Friday's Alabama showdown.
Thompson's Sam Reynolds avoids would-be Hewitt-Trussville tacklers in Friday's Alabama showdown.
Photo by Brandon Sumrall
Michigan and Delaware, which in August opted to move football to the spring, recently flipped to start in the fall. On Monday, Minnesota also approved a return to a traditional calendar, while Washington also looks at a fall football return. 
 
Certainly some of the waffle has had to do with encouraging COVID-19 numbers. But the example of how high school football and coronavirus have coexisted to date this season is another factor in the recent flips.

It certainly influenced Michigan's Sept. 3 switch, 20 days after announcing plans to push back football and other sports to the spring.

"With 25 states practicing and playing games and another eight states ready to go in a couple of days, it's different than three weeks ago," Michigan High School Athletic Association Executive Director Mark Yul told the Detroit Free Press at the time. "You're seeing states, whose COVID-19 numbers are far worse than Michigan's. It has been, nationwide, a very successful start to the year."

Success is relative, of course.

There's certainly more football game postponements this season compared to last, though it's not definitive if the causes are solely COVID related.



MaxPreps data reveals less football games have been played per state in 2020 compared to 2019, as shown, for example, in Week 3 of the following states: Alabama (445 games played in 2019, 356 in 2020), Indiana (353, 282), Tennessee (402, 279) and Utah (176, 160).

HIGH SCHOOL SPORTS RE-START: Updates from all 50 states

But many states, such as Tennessee, put restrictions on the number of regular-season games to safeguard against the virus. An endless list of other social-distancing guidelines have been suggested or mandated by every state association in the nation, not to mention the national governing body, the NFHS.

They include coaches wearing masks, longer sidelines, individual water bottles, one captain per coin toss, no team benches, sharing towels or handshakes, along with regular, upon obsessive sanitation and temperature taking.

Despite the extra duties, you'll hear no complaints from Freeman or Floyd. Then again, both teams headed into Friday 4-0 in anticipation of their televised game. For Hewitt-Trussville, it was the second time on ESPNU this season.

"We've been corona(virus) free since June 27," Freeman said proudly. "We've asked everyone involved from our coaches all the way to our student trainers to make great decisions. We spray our helmets every day after practice before the kids go in. After practice we again spray all lockers and equipment with a peroxide mist. We wear masks when inside our facility. We also check temps before everyone comes in and again as they leave.

"We play(ed) a great opponent Friday (in Hewitt-Trussville), but our biggest enemy is COVID."



Floyd said his program has taken on a similar commitment since early June.

"It's been a roller coaster and a real challenge for the coaches for sure," Floyd said. "It's not easy with all the extra responsibility. But it's been more than worth it. We want to be a source of hope for these kids. The best part is they get to be around each other. We've been living one day at a time and focusing on going to school, playing football and staying safe. Football has helped a ton of kids in our program and the state.
Corner Canyon (Draper, Utah) quarterback Jaxson Dart entered last week second in the country in yards passing and  touchdown passes.
Corner Canyon (Draper, Utah) quarterback Jaxson Dart entered last week second in the country in yards passing and touchdown passes.
File photo by Dave Arygle
"There were times in the spring and summer we had no idea what to expect. But to be here at midseason and playing Thompson on ESPN. We're very thankful."

Being thankful, humble and diligent have been key in Utah's success, said Utah High School Activities Association assistant director Jon Oglesby.

His state was the first to kick off the football season on Aug. 13, which drew much attention and even criticism. Especially when one of its top programs Bingham had to postpone a Week 1 game with Weber when three of its players came down with COVID.

Critics thought the early start date was reckless and dangerous.

But the state held steadfast that if all followed social-distance protocols, athletics, including a high-risk contact sport like football, could persevere safely.

Even with the state recording its highest coronavirus case mark of 911 on Thursday, only a handful of teams and games have been postponed.



Of course, when games do get canceled due to coronavirus issues, it makes news. Over the weekend, 6-0 Skyline was sidelined for two weeks, the Deseret News reported, after four athletes enrolled in the school’s football class tested positive.

Despite the occasional outbreak, Oglesby said the state has been "pleasantly surprised" by the overall success of forging ahead with athletics.

"It all goes back to our coaches, players, schools, administrators, athletic directors and parents taking the guidelines seriously," he said.

American Fork (Utah) athletic director Jeremy Lewis certainly did the second week of the season and gained national attention.

In the middle of the first half of his football team's varsity game with Timpview (Provo), he halted play, got on a loudspeaker and told the estimated 1,000 fans in the stands to wear masks, get back to their assigned seats and practice general social distancing guidelines laid out by state and local officials.

Otherwise, the game wouldn't go on.



That has generally set the tone through the first six weeks of the season. Yes, the Beehive State is more than halfway done with its regular season. Texas's large school divisions 5A and 6A, along with Wisconsin and South Carolina will play first games this week.

HIGH SCHOOL FOOTBALL KICKOFFS: Updates from all 50 states

Though the football season has gone by relatively smooth, Oglesby said, no one in his office is taking anything for granted.

"We have spikes in numbers and seven-day averages just like everyone else, and know things can change quickly," he said. "But we spent a lot of time with state health officials, national sources, collegiate partners, other state associations and state and political leaders building a plan that we hoped was sustainable."

Beyond the strong participation numbers and being the first state to play, Utah national visibility is largely because of the play of the nation's No. 14 Corner Canyon (Draper) and its quarterback Jaxson Dart, who, besides a cool name, entered last week second in the country in both passing yards and touchdowns.

The leader in both those categories was another Utah kid, American Fork's Maddux Madsen. In fact, nine of the top 10 national passing yardage leaders entering Friday were from Utah, which has played at one more game than every other state.



The extra notoriety for the state is nice, Oglesby said, but not a focus.

"We measure our success against ourselves not other states or state associations," he said. "We're happy to see our kids doing so well on any level, believe me, but honestly as long as they continue to stay safe and get the most out of the experience, that's what counts most."
Hewitt-Trussville enters its stadium Friday for a televised showdown with Thompson.
Hewitt-Trussville enters its stadium Friday for a televised showdown with Thompson.
Photo by Brandon Sumrall