High school football: 2025 All-Great Lakes Region Preseason Football Team - Defense

By Eric Frantz Aug 13, 2025, 7:00am

Cincere Johnson, Joey O'Brien, Victor Singleton and Matt Sieg headline the All-Great Lakes defensive football teams.

Red Grange, Jim Brown, Dick Butkus, Dan Marino, Joe Montana and Charles Woodson. The Great Lakes region has cultivated a bumper crop of prep talent that's gone on to rank among the greatest players in football history. Here's a look at the next batch – the 2025 Preseason MaxPreps All-Great Lakes Region Football Team.
 
The all-star squad is made up of players from Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Minnesota, New York and Wisconsin.
@EFRANTZMP'S ALL-GREAT LAKES REGION FIRST TEAM DEFENSE

DL: Cincere Johnson, Glenville (Cleveland, Ohio), 6-3, 240, sr. (Ohio State)
DL: Braeden Jones, Chicago Mt. Carmel (Chicago, Ill.), 6-4, 250, sr. (USC)
DL: Jackson Ford, Malvern Prep (Malvern, Pa.), 6-4, 240, sr.
DL: McHale Blade, Simeon (Chicago, Ill.), 6-4, 245, sr. (Michigan)
DL: Howie Johnson, Forest Lake (Minn.), 6-3, 255, sr. (Minnesota)
LB: Terry Wiggins, Coatesville (Pa.), 6-3, 210, sr. (Penn State)
LB: Roman Igwebuike, Chicago Mt. Carmel (Chicago, Ill.), 6-3, 220, jr.
LB: Storm Miller Strongsville (Ohio), 6-3, 220, sr. (Texas A&M)
LB: Ja'kobe Clapper, St. Xavier (Cincinnati, Ohio), 6-1.5, 215, sr. (Notre Dame)
DB: Joey O'Brien, La Salle College (Wyndmoor, Pa.), 6-3, 185, sr.
DB: Victor Singleton, Central Catholic (Toledo, Ohio), 5-11, 160, sr. (Texas A&M)
DB: Matt Sieg, Fort Cherry (McDonald, Pa.), 5-11.5, 190, sr. (Penn State)
DB: Elbert Hill, Archbishop Hoban (Akron, Ohio), 5-10, 175, sr. (USC)
P: Lucas Tenbrock, St. Charles North (St. Charles, Ill.), 6-6, 220, sr. (Iowa State)
 
@EFRANTZMP'S ALL-GREAT LAKES REGION SECOND TEAM DEFENSE
 
DL: Eli Diane, Wayzata (Plymouth, Minn.), 6-4, 235, jr. (Minnesota)
DL: Recarder Kitchen, Muskegon (Mich.), 6-6, 230, jr.
DL: Antwoine Higgins, Anderson (Cincinnati, Ohio), 6-3, 215, jr.
DL: Malachi Ervin, Pickerington North (Pickerington, Ohio), 6-4, 220, sr. (Buffalo)
DL: Gabriel Hill, Naperville North (Ill.), 6-2, 275, sr. (Indiana)
LB: Brayden Reilly, St. Xavier (Cincinnati, OH), 6-3, 200, sr. (Northwestern)
LB: Cam Thomas, Lakota West (West Chester, Ohio), 6-2, 217, sr. (Illinois)
LB: Reston Lehman, Peters Township (McMurray, Pa.), 6-4, 230, sr. (Pitt)
LB: Marcus Jennings, Cass Tech (Detroit, Mich.), 6-2, 200, sr. (Pitt)
DB: Kaden Gebhardt, Olentangy (Lewis Center, Ohio), 6-2, 200, sr. (Clemson)
DB: Jakob Weatherspoon, Avon (Ohio), 5-10, 172, sr. (Ohio State)
DB: Gabriel Jenkins, Imani Christian Academy (Pittsburgh, Pa.), 6-1, 187, jr.
DB: Jay Timmons, Pine-Richland (Gibsonia, Pa.), 5-11, 185, sr. (Indiana)
P: Cooper Heimbach, Wheelersburg (Ohio), 6-1, 175, sr. 
 
@EFRANTZMP'S ALL-GREAT LAKES REGION THIRD TEAM DEFENSE
 
DL: Ashton Blatt, Central Catholic (Pittsburgh, Pa.), 6-4, 230, sr. (North Carolina)
DL: Parker Crim, Elida (Ohio), 6-3, 235, sr. (Illinois)
DL: Jaylen Mercer, Winton Woods (Cincinnati, Ohio), 6-5, 230, jr.
DL: Jayce Brewer, Franklin Central (Indianapolis, Ind.), 6-5, 210, jr.
DL: Reinaldo Perez, Columbus Academy (Gahanna, Ohio), 6-5, 245, jr.
LB: CJ Sanna, Olentangy (Lewis Center, Ohio), 6-3, 225, sr. (Ohio State)
LB: Aden Reeder, St. Xavier (Cincinnati, Ohio), 6-3, 210, sr. (Wisconsin)
LB: Maurice Barnes, Bishop McDevitt (Harrisburg, Pa.), 6-1, 200, sr.
LB: Angel Luciano, Steelton-Highspire (Steelton, Pa.), 6-1, 225, sr. (Minnesota)
DB: Ace Alston, Anderson (Cincinnati, Ohio), 5-11, 165, jr.
DB: Kaleb Elkins, Warren Central (Indianapolis, Ind.), 6-3, 185, jr.
DB: Messiah Tilson, Guilford (Rockford, Ill.), 6-2, 165, sr. (Kentucky)
DB: Tavares Harrington, Chicago Mt. Carmel (Ill.), 6-3, 175, jr.

@EFRANTZMP'S ALL-GREAT LAKES REGION HONORABLE MENTION DEFENSE
 
Defensive Linemen