EF's Ohio hs football Fab 5 Rankings and poll comparisons

By Eric Frantz Sep 19, 2017, 8:00am

Our take on the Buckeye State's top teams and where they rank in the AP, Fantastic 50 and MaxPreps state polls.

Isaiah Bowser highlights Sidney High School
Watch the Sidney senior and Northwestern recruit rush for 434 yards and six touchdowns in a 55-48 win over Xenia. Also threw two passes for 90 yards and a touchdown.


Our weekly take on who we think the top teams in Ohio are and who others do. Enjoy as we highlight and compare the MaxPreps computer rankings, the AP poll and Drew Pastuer's Fantastic 50 poll against our own opinion.

Heading into Week 5, LaSalle (II), Trotwood-Madison (III), Steubenville (IV), Wheelersburg (V), Marion Local (VI) and Minster (VII) are the unanimous top teams in their respective divisions. In D-I, two different teams are fighting it out for the top spot...

DIVISION I FAB 5



1. St. Xavier (Cincinnati) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 1
AP: 2
Fantastic 50: 2

2. St. Ignatius (Cleveland) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 2
AP: 1
Fantastic 50: 1

3. St. Edward (Lakewood) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 3
AP: 4
Fantastic 50: 4

4. Whitmer (Toledo) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 11
AP: 6
Fantastic 50: 12

5. Centerville - 4-0
MaxPreps: 4
AP: 7
Fantastic 50: 8

Dropped Out:
No. 5 Dublin Coffman - lost 31-14 to Olentangy



Others:
Archbishop Moeller (Cincinnati) - 3-1
Wayne (Huber Heights) - 3-1
Pickerington Central - 3-1
Pickerington North - 3-1
Mentor - 3-1
Colerain (Cincinnati) - 2-2
Elder (Cincinnati) - 3-1
Hilliard Bradley - 4-0
Lincoln (Gahanna) - 3-1
Stow-Munroe Falls - 4-0

DIVISION II FAB 5

1. La Salle (Cincinnati) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 1
AP: 1
Fantastic 50: 1

2. Anderson (Cincinnati) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 3
AP: 3
Fantastic 50: 7

3. Benedictine (Cleveland) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 12
AP: 8
Fantastic 50: 10

4. Winton Woods (Cincinnati) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 5
AP: 4
Fantastic 50: 3



5. Barberton - 4-0
MaxPreps: 17
AP: 10
Fantastic 50: 20

Dropped Out:
None

Others:
Archbishop Hoban (Akron) - 3-1
Sidney - 4-0
Hudson - 3-1
Avon - 4-0
Belmont (Dayton) - 4-0
St. Edward is one of Ohio's top ranked big schools.
St. Edward is one of Ohio's top ranked big schools.
Photo by Mark Porter/ScoutingOhio.com

DIVISION III FAB 5

1. Trotwood-Madison - 4-0
MaxPreps: 1
AP: 1
Fantastic 50: 3

2. Central Catholic (Toledo) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 2
AP: 2
Fantastic 50: 1

3. St. Vincent-St. Mary (Akron) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 9
AP: 3
Fantastic 50: 6
 
4. Franklin - 4-0
MaxPreps: 4
AP: 6
Fantastic 50: 5



5. Bishop Hartley (Columbus) - 3-1
MaxPreps: 5
AP: 13
Fantastic 50: 4

Dropped Out:
No. 3 St. Francis de Sales (Columbus) - lost 42-7 to Indianapolis Chatard

Others:
Archbishop Alter (Kettering) - 3-1
Notre Dame-Cathedral Latin (Chardon) - 4-0
Sandusky - 4-0
Padua Franciscan (Parma) - 4-0
Marion-Franklin (Columbus) - 4-0
Clyde - 4-0
St. Francis de Sales (Columbus) - 3-1

DIVISION IV FAB 5

1. Steubenville - 4-0
MaxPreps: 2
AP: 1
Fantastic 50: 1

2. Shelby - 4-0
MaxPreps: 1
AP: 8
Fantastic 50: 7



3. Perry - 4-0
MaxPreps: 7
AP: 2
Fantastic 50: 5

4. Valley View (Germantown) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 3
AP: 3
Fantastic 50: 8

5. Wyoming (Cincinnati) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 6
AP: 9
Fantastic 50: 6

Dropped Out:
None

Others:
Clinton-Massie (Clarksville) - 4-0
Clear Fork (Bellville) - 4-0
Licking Valley (Newark) - 4-0
London - 4-0
Firelands (Oberlin) - 4-0
Poland Seminary - 4-0
Waverly - 4-0

DIVISION V FAB 5



1. Wheelersburg - 4-0
MaxPreps: 1
AP: 4
Fantastic 50: 1

2. Eastwood (Pemberville) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 2
AP: 1
Fantastic 50: 2

3. Anna - 4-0
MaxPreps: 3
AP: 3
Fantastic 50: 5

4. Liberty Center - 4-0
MaxPreps: 6
AP: 5
Fantastic 50: 4

5. South Range (Canfield) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 4
AP: 2
Fantastic 50: 3

Dropped Out:
No. 4 Columbus Academy (Gahanna) - lost 38-28 to London



Others:
Genoa Area (Genoa) - 4-0
Gilmour Academy (Gates Mills) - 4-0
Grand Valley (Orwell) - 4-0
Greeneview (Jamestown) - 4-0
Columbus Academy (Gahanna) - 3-1

Marion Local is a unanimous No. 1 in Division VI.
Marion Local is a unanimous No. 1 in Division VI.
Photo by Michael Noyes

DIVISION VI FAB 5

1. Marion Local (Maria Stein) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 1
AP: 1
Fantastic 50: 1

2. Kirtland - 4-0
MaxPreps: 4
AP: 4
Fantastic 50: 3

3. St. Henry - 4-0
MaxPreps: 2
AP: 2
Fantastic 50: 4

4. Mogadore - 4-0
MaxPreps: 9
AP: 5
Fantastic 50: 8



5. Coldwater - 2-2
MaxPreps: 3
AP: 8
Fantastic 50: 2

Dropped Out:
No. 4 Shadyside - lost 48-41 to Meadowbrook

Others:
Norwayne (Creston) - 4-0
Nelsonville-York - 4-0
Fort Recovery - 2-2
Bethel (Tipp City) - 4-0
Shadyside - 3-1
Carey - 4-0
Shenandoah (Sarahsville) - 4-0
Smithville - 4-0

DIVISION VII FAB 5

1. Minster - 3-1
MaxPreps: 1
AP: 4
Fantastic 50: 1

2. Cuyahoga Heights (Cleveland) - 3-0
MaxPreps: 2
AP: 2
Fantastic 50: 2



3. Leipsic - 4-0
MaxPreps: 4
AP: 3
Fantastic 50: 5

4. St. Paul (Norwalk) - 4-0
MaxPreps: 7
AP: 6
Fantastic 50: 10

5. Dalton - 4-0
MaxPreps: 3
AP: 1
Fantastic 50: 3

Dropped Out
No. 3 Danville - lost 26-0 to Highland

Others:
Harvest Prep (Canal Winchester) - 3-1
Crestview (Convoy) - 4-0
Lehman Catholic (Sidney) - 3-1
Bishop Rosecrans (Zanesville) - 4-0
Danville - 3-1