While Gavin Pritzel delivered a dominant performance on Thursday, a win just wasn't in the cards for McCutcheon. Lafayette Jefferson had no answer to Pritzel as he scored 18 points.
Pritzel and McCutcheon will head out on the road to square off against Crawfordsville at 7:30 p.m. on Tuesday. McCutcheon is 6-0 against Crawfordsville going back to December of 2014, a lead they'll look to extend.