Mitchell was the 31-14 winner over Tampa Catholic when they last played one another back in September of 2024, but their luck changed this time around. The Mustangs took a 41-36 hit to the loss column at the hands of the Crusaders on Friday. Despite 192 more yards than the Crusaders, the Mustangs couldn't convert that extra yardage to scores.

Cayden Thomas
09/12/25 @ East Lake | 92 |
09/05/25 vs Jefferson | 109 |
08/22/25 @ Gulf | 231 |
08/29/25 vs Northeast | 246 |
09/19/25 @ Tampa Catholic | 324 |
Defeat or not, Mitchell got some senior leadership from Cayden Thomas and Bryce Backus. Thomas threw for 324 yards and four TDs while picking up 12.0 yards per attempt, while Backus gained 167 total yards and two touchdowns. Those 324 passing yards set a new season-high mark for Thomas.
Even if they lost, Mitchell's defensive line still kept up the pressure with three sacks. Leading the way was Ethan Andrews with two. Andrews is also crushing it when it comes to total tackles: he's made at least five every time he's taken the field this season.
Tampa Catholic's win was the result of several impressive offensive performances. One of the most notable came from Kyreek Monette, who rushed for 68 yards and one score. Monette was no stranger to the big play, turning on the jets for a run that went for 67 yards. Braylon House was in the mix as well, providing Tampa Catholic with two touchdowns.
This is the second loss in a row for Mitchell and nudges their season record down to 3-2. As for Tampa Catholic, their win (their first of the season) made their record 1-4.
Mitchell didn't take long to hit the field again: they've already played their next game, a 21-17 victory against Land O' Lakes on the 26th. As for Tampa Catholic, they have also already played their next matchup, a 29-20 loss against Bishop Moore on the 26th.
Article generated by infoSentience based on data entered on MaxPreps