It's hard to turn regular season success into postseason wins, a fact Providence can now relate to. While the 2-2 score might suggest a draw, it was the Heritage Christian Eagles who were credited with the victory on Saturday. The Heritage Christian Eagles got it done in the shootout by posting five goals to the Providence Pioneers' four. Providence were given a dose of their own medicine in this game as Heritage Christian apparently hadn't forgotten their loss the last time these teams played back in October of 2024.
Livy Theobald and Cooper Stiefvater scored both of Providence's goals, bringing their combined season tally to 32 goals.

Pioneers
| 10/25/25 vs Heritage Christian | 2-2 |
| 10/18/25 vs Evansville Christian | 6-0 |
| 10/16/25 vs White River Valley | 9-0 |
| 10/11/25 vs Shawe Memorial | 6-1 |
| 10/09/25 vs Christian Academy | 6-0 |
With the defeat, Providence broke their six-match winning streak and moved their record to 14-4-4. As for Heritage Christian, the win (which was their fifth in a row) raised their record to 15-7.
Providence does not have any more games scheduled as of now. As for Heritage Christian, they didn't take long to hit the pitch again: they've already played their next contest, a 3-0 victory against Bremen on the 1st.
Article generated by infoSentience based on data entered on MaxPreps