Pirates mascot photo.

Seton Hall Prep Baseball Game History

Mascot
Pirates
Team
Varsity 2026
Colors
Blue, White
Coach
N/A
Address
120 Northfield Ave, West Orange, NJ 07052
Overall
0-0
League
0-0

This is a compilation of Seton Hall Prep high school baseball all-time winning streaks. Also included is game history and how this team has fared against their opponents.
Note: Game history by game type and game history by opponent are only compiled from as far as MaxPreps dates back (07-08).

Winning Streaks

Start YearEnd YearStreak Length
2009201015

Game History by Game Type

Game TypeRecord
Overall391-81-3
Non-League167-37
League196-30-3
Playoffs28-14
Home207-31-1
Away131-37-2
Neutral53-13
In-State389-80-3
Out-of-State2-1

Game History by Opponent Type

Show All Games
OpponentRecordMost Recent Game
Livingston (Livingston, NJ)33-4
  1. 5/17/2025 6-0 (W)[+]
  2. 4/23/2025 4-0 (W)
  3. 4/3/2025 4-0 (W)
  4. 5/18/2024 6-0 (W)
  5. 5/16/2024 7-1 (L)
  6. 4/15/2024 4-3 (L)
  7. 5/17/2023 17-8 (L)
  8. 5/13/2023 4-3 (W)
  9. 4/17/2023 8-2 (W)
  10. 5/11/2022 6-3 (W)
  11. 4/25/2022 10-5 (W)
  12. 4/14/2022 5-1 (W)
  13. 5/26/2021 8-3 (W)
  14. 5/6/2021 4-3 (W)
  15. 6/3/2019 5-1 (W)
  16. 4/3/2019 12-1 (W)
  17. 4/30/2018 1-0 (W)
  18. 4/11/2018 5-0 (W)
  19. 5/24/2017 11-1 (W)
  20. 4/3/2017 3-1 (W)
  21. 5/25/2016 16-0 (W)
  22. 4/13/2016 4-3 (W)
  23. 5/11/2015 17-1 (W)
  24. 4/15/2015 12-2 (W)
  25. 5/5/2014 13-8 (W)
  26. 4/12/2014 6-2 (W)
  27. 5/6/2013 11-1 (W)
  28. 4/15/2013 10-6 (W)
  29. 5/14/2012 13-4 (W)
  30. 4/13/2012 9-2 (W)
  31. 5/13/2010 8-1 (W)
  32. 4/1/2010 4-3 (W)
  33. 5/12/2009 6-5 (L)
  34. 4/28/2009 10-9 (W)
  35. 5/21/2008 7-2 (W)
  36. 5/4/2008 8-1 (W)
  37. 4/21/2008 10-0 (W)
Nutley (Nutley, NJ)28-6
  1. 4/1/2025 7-2 (W)[+]
  2. 5/13/2024 13-1 (W)
  3. 4/22/2024 11-1 (W)
  4. 5/15/2023 10-0 (W)
  5. 5/3/2023 12-0 (W)
  6. 4/22/2022 6-2 (W)
  7. 4/4/2022 2-0 (W)
  8. 5/13/2021 14-0 (W)
  9. 4/27/2021 3-2 (W)
  10. 4/29/2019 13-2 (W)
  11. 4/8/2019 3-2 (W)
  12. 5/12/2018 3-2 (L)
  13. 4/27/2018 6-2 (L)
  14. 4/9/2018 2-1 (W)
  15. 4/26/2017 3-0 (W)
  16. 4/7/2017 4-0 (W)
  17. 5/21/2016 11-1 (W)
  18. 5/18/2016 5-4 (L)
  19. 4/18/2016 9-7 (W)
  20. 5/15/2015 6-1 (W)
  21. 5/9/2015 4-2 (W)
  22. 4/21/2015 9-3 (W)
  23. 4/16/2014 2-0 (W)
  24. 4/1/2014 4-3 (W)
  25. 4/17/2013 4-2 (W)
  26. 4/1/2013 8-7 (W)
  27. 5/24/2012 4-2 (L)
  28. 5/12/2012 9-1 (L)
  29. 4/24/2012 5-4 (W)
  30. 5/14/2011 5-2 (W)
  31. 4/21/2011 10-8 (W)
  32. 5/19/2010 11-7 (W)
  33. 4/23/2010 7-3 (W)
  34. 5/8/2009 10-4 (L)
Millburn (Millburn, NJ)28-13
  1. 5/10/2025 10-0 (W)[+]
  2. 4/25/2025 11-2 (W)
  3. 4/8/2025 11-0 (W)
  4. 4/19/2024 7-3 (W)
  5. 4/4/2024 1-0 (W)
  6. 5/21/2023 3-0 (L)
  7. 4/21/2023 3-0 (W)
  8. 4/5/2023 9-1 (L)
  9. 5/14/2022 3-1 (W)
  10. 4/27/2022 2-1 (W)
  11. 4/8/2022 2-1 (L)
  12. 5/22/2021 6-5 (L)
  13. 5/10/2021 11-2 (W)
  14. 4/19/2021 4-1 (L)
  15. 5/11/2019 8-2 (W)
  16. 4/17/2019 10-0 (W)
  17. 4/1/2019 6-4 (W)
  18. 4/23/2018 3-2 (L)
  19. 4/6/2018 6-5 (W)
  20. 5/20/2017 4-2 (W)
  21. 5/17/2017 9-3 (W)
  22. 4/17/2017 9-3 (L)
  23. 4/29/2016 4-3 (L)
  24. 4/8/2016 6-5 (W)
  25. 5/16/2015 12-6 (W)
  26. 5/1/2015 8-6 (L)
  27. 4/10/2015 8-3 (W)
  28. 4/28/2014 3-1 (L)
  29. 4/7/2014 1-0 (W)
  30. 4/29/2013 4-3 (L)
  31. 4/8/2013 5-3 (W)
  32. 4/25/2012 4-0 (W)
  33. 4/2/2012 1-0 (L)
  34. 5/28/2011 8-2 (W)
  35. 5/9/2011 7-2 (L)
  36. 4/26/2011 6-0 (W)
  37. 5/10/2010 11-3 (W)
  38. 4/14/2010 10-3 (W)
  39. 5/20/2009 4-1 (W)
  40. 5/1/2009 4-3 (W)
  41. 5/24/2008 8-7 (W)
Montclair (Montclair, NJ)24-5-3
  1. 5/15/2025 13-0 (W)[+]
  2. 5/3/2025 17-4 (W)
  3. 4/17/2024 8-7 (W)
  4. 4/1/2024 1-1 (T)
  5. 4/19/2023 10-4 (W)
  6. 4/3/2023 2-2 (T)
  7. 5/17/2022 9-2 (W)
  8. 4/11/2022 4-3 (L)
  9. 4/26/2021 2-2 (T)
  10. 5/25/2019 11-0 (W)
  11. 5/18/2019 12-1 (L)
  12. 4/16/2019 8-2 (L)
  13. 5/24/2018 7-1 (W)
  14. 5/1/2018 10-0 (W)
  15. 6/1/2017 6-4 (W)
  16. 5/15/2017 1-0 (W)
  17. 5/2/2017 11-0 (W)
  18. 5/14/2016 13-0 (W)
  19. 4/22/2016 11-1 (W)
  20. 4/2/2016 10-0 (W)
  21. 4/24/2015 5-3 (W)
  22. 4/4/2015 11-5 (W)
  23. 4/23/2014 15-5 (W)
  24. 4/5/2014 14-4 (W)
  25. 6/1/2013 4-2 (W)
  26. 4/24/2013 3-1 (W)
  27. 4/5/2013 3-2 (W)
  28. 5/7/2012 3-1 (W)
  29. 4/11/2012 11-4 (W)
  30. 4/15/2011 4-3 (L)
  31. 5/15/2010 9-1 (W)
  32. 4/16/2010 12-2 (L)
Bloomfield (Bloomfield, NJ)22-2
  1. 5/20/2024 18-2 (W)[+]
  2. 4/28/2023 9-3 (W)
  3. 5/21/2022 15-0 (W)
  4. 5/18/2022 14-3 (W)
  5. 4/18/2022 12-0 (W)
  6. 5/24/2021 11-3 (W)
  7. 4/29/2021 11-1 (W)
  8. 5/8/2017 13-1 (W)
  9. 4/13/2017 2-1 (W)
  10. 5/11/2016 20-0 (W)
  11. 4/25/2016 10-0 (W)
  12. 4/27/2015 13-0 (W)
  13. 4/6/2015 10-1 (W)
  14. 5/2/2014 11-9 (W)
  15. 4/11/2014 4-2 (W)
  16. 5/3/2013 4-2 (L)
  17. 4/13/2013 8-3 (W)
  18. 5/10/2012 11-1 (W)
  19. 4/30/2012 12-2 (W)
  20. 4/7/2012 11-1 (W)
  21. 5/6/2011 17-4 (W)
  22. 4/11/2011 20-2 (W)
  23. 5/7/2010 10-0 (W)
  24. 4/12/2010 13-3 (L)
West Essex (West Essex, NJ)20-1
  1. 5/12/2025 11-1 (W)[+]
  2. 4/16/2025 4-3 (W)
  3. 5/8/2024 7-0 (W)
  4. 5/10/2023 10-5 (W)
  5. 4/20/2022 9-0 (W)
  6. 4/1/2022 11-1 (W)
  7. 5/17/2021 10-0 (W)
  8. 4/23/2021 14-3 (W)
  9. 5/15/2019 8-3 (W)
  10. 5/9/2019 7-0 (W)
  11. 4/15/2019 11-2 (W)
  12. 4/20/2016 2-0 (W)
  13. 5/11/2014 5-0 (W)
  14. 4/17/2014 7-3 (W)
  15. 4/3/2014 6-5 (L)
  16. 5/9/2013 5-2 (W)
  17. 4/18/2013 8-4 (W)
  18. 4/3/2013 4-2 (W)
  19. 5/18/2012 11-1 (W)
  20. 4/20/2012 20-2 (W)
  21. 5/5/2010 11-0 (W)
Columbia (Columbia, NJ)20-4
  1. 5/20/2025 4-1 (W)[+]
  2. 4/17/2025 8-0 (W)
  3. 4/30/2024 9-3 (W)
  4. 4/5/2024 10-0 (W)
  5. 4/24/2023 8-1 (W)
  6. 4/6/2023 8-7 (W)
  7. 5/4/2022 8-6 (L)
  8. 4/30/2019 17-4 (W)
  9. 4/24/2019 5-0 (W)
  10. 4/20/2018 7-3 (W)
  11. 4/10/2018 6-4 (L)
  12. 5/1/2017 6-0 (W)
  13. 4/10/2017 11-1 (W)
  14. 5/3/2014 9-1 (W)
  15. 4/27/2012 13-1 (W)
  16. 4/4/2012 15-0 (W)
  17. 4/28/2010 16-2 (W)
  18. 4/5/2010 18-17 (L)
  19. 5/6/2009 7-4 (W)
  20. 5/5/2009 7-4 (W)
  21. 4/15/2009 11-3 (W)
  22. 5/10/2008 2-0 (W)
  23. 4/25/2008 6-4 (W)
  24. 4/3/2008 9-7 (L)
Roxbury (Roxbury, NJ)16-4
  1. 5/23/2025 4-0 (W)[+]
  2. 5/21/2024 13-3 (W)
  3. 5/27/2023 11-6 (W)
  4. 5/12/2022 14-4 (W)
  5. 5/1/2021 24-9 (W)
  6. 4/18/2019 14-10 (L)
  7. 5/26/2018 6-1 (W)
  8. 4/20/2017 4-0 (W)
  9. 4/21/2016 7-3 (L)
  10. 5/22/2015 4-3 (W)
  11. 5/15/2014 13-0 (W)
  12. 5/16/2013 5-3 (W)
  13. 4/19/2012 13-6 (W)
  14. 5/25/2011 8-6 (L)
  15. 5/21/2011 8-6 (L)
  16. 4/3/2010 10-3 (W)
  17. 5/19/2009 10-0 (W)
  18. 4/28/2009 16-9 (W)
  19. 5/14/2008 3-1 (W)
  20. 4/18/2008 11-5 (W)
Caldwell (Caldwell, NJ)15-3
  1. 5/7/2025 9-0 (W)[+]
  2. 4/14/2025 14-0 (W)
  3. 5/11/2024 5-2 (W)
  4. 4/24/2024 8-1 (W)
  5. 4/8/2024 12-1 (W)
  6. 4/26/2023 9-5 (L)
  7. 4/10/2023 4-2 (L)
  8. 4/13/2022 6-3 (L)
  9. 5/12/2021 9-1 (W)
  10. 5/7/2018 8-1 (W)
  11. 4/13/2018 5-3 (W)
  12. 5/16/2016 9-2 (W)
  13. 4/15/2016 9-1 (W)
  14. 5/13/2015 14-2 (W)
  15. 4/17/2015 11-1 (W)
  16. 5/12/2014 3-0 (W)
  17. 5/13/2013 2-1 (W)
  18. 5/12/2013 6-1 (W)
Newark Academy (Newark Academy, NJ)13-0
  1. 5/23/2023 10-0 (W)[+]
  2. 4/10/2019 12-0 (W)
  3. 5/21/2018 12-1 (W)
  4. 5/18/2018 13-3 (W)
  5. 4/24/2017 3-0 (W)
  6. 4/5/2017 5-1 (W)
  7. 4/28/2016 6-2 (W)
  8. 4/6/2016 13-0 (W)
  9. 4/29/2015 9-0 (W)
  10. 4/8/2015 10-0 (W)
  11. 4/8/2011 13-3 (W)
  12. 4/9/2010 11-0 (W)
  13. 4/26/2008 21-1 (W)
Randolph (Randolph, NJ)13-4
  1. 4/5/2025 13-3 (W)[+]
  2. 4/6/2024 6-4 (L)
  3. 4/8/2023 9-4 (L)
  4. 4/9/2022 1-0 (W)
  5. 4/14/2018 10-0 (W)
  6. 4/15/2017 6-3 (L)
  7. 4/1/2015 5-4 (W)
  8. 4/19/2014 3-0 (W)
  9. 4/20/2013 4-1 (W)
  10. 4/14/2012 5-4 (W)
  11. 4/16/2011 7-2 (W)
  12. 4/24/2010 9-2 (W)
  13. 4/17/2010 9-2 (W)
  14. 5/7/2009 6-5 (W)
  15. 4/17/2009 5-0 (W)
  16. 5/7/2008 13-6 (L)
  17. 4/16/2008 4-3 (W)
Verona (Verona, NJ)11-0
  1. 4/10/2024 11-0 (W)[+]
  2. 5/5/2023 10-0 (W)
  3. 4/12/2023 10-2 (W)
  4. 4/30/2021 14-0 (W)
  5. 5/8/2018 3-2 (W)
  6. 5/11/2017 6-0 (W)
  7. 4/29/2017 3-1 (W)
  8. 4/19/2017 8-0 (W)
  9. 5/12/2016 5-1 (W)
  10. 5/7/2014 7-2 (W)
  11. 5/1/2010 7-2 (W)
Morristown (Morristown, NJ)11-3
  1. 4/6/2019 3-2 (L)[+]
  2. 4/8/2017 4-1 (W)
  3. 5/19/2016 4-3 (W)
  4. 4/11/2015 7-0 (W)
  5. 5/8/2014 7-2 (W)
  6. 4/6/2013 5-3 (W)
  7. 4/5/2012 9-3 (W)
  8. 4/30/2011 12-4 (W)
  9. 4/20/2010 3-0 (L)
  10. 4/27/2009 8-3 (L)
  11. 4/8/2009 11-5 (W)
  12. 4/23/2008 5-3 (W)
  13. 4/2/2008 9-1 (W)
  14. 4/1/2008 9-1 (W)
Morris Knolls (Morris Knolls, NJ)10-0
  1. 4/30/2025 18-3 (W)[+]
  2. 5/25/2024 9-8 (W)
  3. 4/26/2013 14-6 (W)
  4. 4/16/2012 9-3 (W)
  5. 5/22/2010 6-4 (W)
  6. 5/21/2010 6-4 (W)
  7. 5/11/2009 11-9 (W)
  8. 4/13/2009 9-1 (W)
  9. 5/13/2008 5-2 (W)
  10. 4/7/2008 10-0 (W)
West Orange (West Orange, NJ)10-1
  1. 4/28/2017 9-2 (W)[+]
  2. 5/1/2014 13-3 (W)
  3. 4/9/2014 7-1 (W)
  4. 5/1/2013 13-1 (W)
  5. 4/10/2013 10-3 (W)
  6. 5/17/2012 2-0 (W)
  7. 5/5/2012 11-2 (W)
  8. 4/9/2012 7-1 (W)
  9. 5/3/2010 6-3 (L)
  10. 4/7/2010 5-4 (W)
  11. 4/6/2010 5-4 (W)
Morris Hills (Morris Hills, NJ)9-1
  1. 6/2/2021 8-0 (W)[+]
  2. 5/22/2019 8-1 (W)
  3. 5/17/2018 12-0 (W)
  4. 5/16/2017 7-1 (W)
  5. 5/5/2015 4-3 (W)
  6. 5/13/2014 7-3 (W)
  7. 4/13/2013 12-2 (W)
  8. 5/24/2010 15-5 (W)
  9. 5/18/2010 15-5 (W)
  10. 5/19/2009 3-0 (L)
East Side (East Side, NJ)8-0
  1. 5/5/2018 4-2 (W)[+]
  2. 4/18/2018 12-1 (W)
  3. 4/5/2018 13-0 (W)
  4. 5/4/2013 9-1 (W)
  5. 5/17/2010 12-5 (W)
  6. 4/22/2010 12-1 (W)
  7. 4/21/2010 12-5 (W)
  8. 4/25/2009 11-1 (W)
Cedar Grove (Cedar Grove, NJ)7-0
  1. 5/9/2022 6-0 (W)[+]
  2. 5/10/2018 10-0 (W)
  3. 5/6/2017 9-1 (W)
  4. 5/7/2016 7-0 (W)
  5. 5/2/2015 5-0 (W)
  6. 5/17/2014 7-6 (W)
  7. 5/7/2011 7-0 (W)
West Morris Central (West Morris Central, NJ)7-0
  1. 5/22/2013 3-2 (W)[+]
  2. 5/16/2012 11-4 (W)
  3. 5/4/2010 8-1 (W)
  4. 5/22/2009 3-2 (W)
  5. 4/7/2009 5-1 (W)
  6. 5/5/2008 7-3 (W)
  7. 4/14/2008 7-5 (W)
Bergen Catholic (Bergen Catholic, NJ)6-0
  1. 6/3/2022 5-3 (W)[+]
  2. 6/1/2018 7-2 (W)
  3. 6/3/2016 8-5 (W)
  4. 5/29/2012 12-2 (W)
  5. 6/3/2011 10-7 (W)
  6. 5/28/2008 10-1 (W)
Belleville (Belleville, NJ)6-0
  1. 5/3/2021 14-0 (W)[+]
  2. 5/2/2016 5-0 (W)
  3. 4/11/2016 9-3 (W)
  4. 5/7/2015 21-3 (W)
  5. 5/4/2015 14-1 (W)
  6. 4/13/2015 12-1 (W)
Mount Olive (Mount Olive, NJ)6-0
  1. 5/10/2017 6-3 (W)[+]
  2. 4/14/2016 12-0 (W)
  3. 5/23/2015 11-1 (W)
  4. 5/10/2009 11-1 (W)
  5. 5/2/2008 9-1 (W)
  6. 4/11/2008 17-6 (W)
Old Bridge (Old Bridge, NJ)6-2
  1. 4/19/2025 9-3 (L)[+]
  2. 4/27/2024 6-3 (W)
  3. 4/30/2022 6-5 (L)
  4. 5/5/2021 8-1 (W)
  5. 4/20/2019 7-1 (W)
  6. 4/21/2018 10-1 (W)
  7. 4/22/2017 1-0 (W)
  8. 4/16/2016 2-1 (W)
St. Joseph (St. Joseph, NJ)6-2
  1. 4/11/2024 10-1 (W)[+]
  2. 5/22/2023 2-1 (W)
  3. 4/29/2022 2-1 (W)
  4. 5/27/2021 8-2 (W)
  5. 4/27/2019 3-0 (W)
  6. 4/28/2018 5-0 (W)
  7. 5/18/2009 3-2 (L)
  8. 5/19/2008 10-8 (L)
West Morris Mendham (West Morris Mendham, NJ)5-0
  1. 5/4/2017 9-1 (W)[+]
  2. 5/10/2016 1-0 (W)
  3. 5/19/2015 3-2 (W)
  4. 5/20/2014 7-1 (W)
  5. 5/21/2013 8-1 (W)
St. Joseph Regional (St. Joseph Regional, NJ)5-1
  1. 5/30/2025 12-2 (W)[+]
  2. 6/7/2022 4-2 (W)
  3. 5/29/2018 2-0 (W)
  4. 6/7/2016 6-2 (W)
  5. 5/29/2015 7-6 (L)
  6. 6/4/2013 10-2 (W)
Hanover Park (Hanover Park, NJ)5-1
  1. 4/2/2015 10-0 (W)[+]
  2. 4/22/2014 17-7 (W)
  3. 4/23/2013 13-3 (W)
  4. 4/18/2012 6-0 (W)
  5. 4/29/2010 15-14 (W)
  6. 4/22/2008 7-6 (L)
St. Peter's Prep (St. Peter's Prep, NJ)3-0
  1. 6/4/2021 2-0 (W)[+]
  2. 5/24/2019 6-0 (W)
  3. 5/21/2010 6-4 (W)
East Orange Campus (East Orange Campus, NJ)3-0
  1. 4/1/2009 12-1 (W)[+]
  2. 4/30/2008 13-0 (W)
  3. 4/9/2008 15-0 (W)
Ridge (Ridge, NJ)3-1
  1. 5/8/2025 1-0 (W)[+]
  2. 5/6/2024 12-2 (W)
  3. 5/8/2023 5-3 (L)
  4. 5/1/2019 18-13 (W)
Christian Brothers Academy (Christian Brothers Academy, NJ)3-2
  1. 4/13/2024 11-1 (W)[+]
  2. 5/11/2023 8-7 (L)
  3. 5/19/2022 1-0 (W)
  4. 4/24/2021 7-6 (L)
  5. 5/16/2019 3-2 (W)
Hun (Hun, NJ)3-4
  1. 4/28/2025 7-3 (W)[+]
  2. 5/4/2024 9-4 (W)
  3. 4/27/2023 7-1 (L)
  4. 4/21/2022 5-1 (L)
  5. 5/14/2021 7-2 (L)
  6. 5/3/2019 2-0 (L)
  7. 5/4/2018 3-0 (W)
Delbarton (Delbarton, NJ)3-6
  1. 6/7/2021 3-0 (L)[+]
  2. 5/29/2019 7-5 (L)
  3. 6/5/2018 8-0 (L)
  4. 5/30/2017 1-0 (L)
  5. 5/31/2013 9-3 (W)
  6. 6/1/2012 7-6 (L)
  7. 5/29/2009 7-3 (L)
  8. 5/30/2008 10-8 (W)
  9. 4/12/2008 6-4 (W)
Montclair Kimberley Academy (Montclair Kimberley Academy, NJ)2-0
  1. 4/21/2014 14-4 (W)[+]
  2. 4/22/2013 13-1 (W)
Union (Union, NJ)2-0
  1. 4/24/2014 10-0 (W)[+]
  2. 4/25/2013 3-2 (W)
Monsignor Farrell (Monsignor Farrell, NY)2-1
  1. 4/20/2024 11-1 (W)[+]
  2. 4/22/2023 6-0 (L)
  3. 4/2/2022 4-2 (W)
Pope John XXIII (Pope John XXIII, NJ)2-1
  1. 5/26/2015 7-5 (W)[+]
  2. 6/7/2011 4-3 (L)
  3. 5/25/2009 9-8 (W)
Glen Ridge (Glen Ridge, NJ)1-0
  1. 5/2/2025 16-0 (W)
St. Benedict's Prep (St. Benedict's Prep, NJ)1-0
  1. 5/3/2024 1-0 (W)
Dwight-Englewood (Dwight-Englewood, NJ)1-0
  1. 5/28/2024 10-0 (W)
Hudson Catholic (Hudson Catholic, NJ)1-0
  1. 5/22/2024 14-0 (W)
Newark Tech (Newark Tech, NJ)1-0
  1. 5/4/2019 24-0 (W)
Westfield (Westfield, NJ)1-0
  1. 5/8/2019 7-1 (W)
Monroe Township (Monroe Township, NJ)1-0
  1. 4/23/2016 3-2 (W)
Paramus Catholic (Paramus Catholic, NJ)1-0
  1. 5/31/2016 4-3 (W)
St. Augustine Prep (St. Augustine Prep, NJ)1-0
  1. 6/11/2016 4-2 (W)
West Milford (West Milford, NJ)1-0
  1. 5/13/2009 4-3 (W)
Governor Livingston (Governor Livingston, NJ)1-0
  1. 3/25/2008 18-2 (W)
Toms River East (Toms River East, NJ)1-0
  1. 3/29/2008 11-8 (W)
DePaul Catholic (DePaul Catholic, NJ)1-1
  1. 6/4/2025 12-10 (L)[+]
  2. 5/31/2011 7-3 (W)
Hunterdon Central (Hunterdon Central, NJ)1-1
  1. 5/19/2021 7-6 (W)[+]
  2. 5/6/2019 5-1 (L)
Don Bosco Prep (Don Bosco Prep, NJ)1-5
  1. 5/30/2024 2-1 (L)[+]
  2. 5/26/2023 11-2 (L)
  3. 6/10/2022 4-2 (L)
  4. 5/27/2014 7-1 (L)
  5. 5/29/2013 6-0 (W)
  6. 6/3/2008 3-2 (L)
Gloucester Catholic (Gloucester Catholic, NJ)0-1
  1. 6/9/2013 2-0 (L)
Toms River North (Toms River North, NJ)0-1
  1. 4/16/2009 11-0 (L)