2025-26
Head Coach: -
- Conference: District 9 Region 2
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 0-0
- Conference Record: 0-0
- National Rank: 2831
- State Rank: 99
- State Division Rank: 3
2024-25
Head Coach: -
- Conference: District 9 Region 2
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 14-1
- Conference Record: 6-0
- State Rank: 76
- State Division Rank: 2
2023-24
Head Coach: -
- Conference: District 9 Region 2
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 10-3
- Conference Record: 6-1
- State Rank: 208
- State Division Rank: 11
2022-23
Head Coach: Justin Bienkowski
- Conference: District 9 Region 2
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 12-2
- Conference Record: 7-0
- DMA Rank: 5
- State Rank: 169
- State Division Rank: 9
2021-22
Head Coach: Justin Bienkowski
- Conference: District 9 - Small North
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 6-5
- Conference Record: 3-1
- DMA Rank: 33
- State Rank: 357
- State Division Rank: 31
2020-21
Head Coach: -
- Conference: District 9 - Small North
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 3-4
- Conference Record: 3-4
- DMA Rank: 56
- State Rank: 499
- State Division Rank: 63
2019-20
Head Coach: Justin Bienkowski
- Conference: District 9 - Small North
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 2-6
- Conference Record: 2-3
- DMA Rank: 68
- National Rank: 13519
- State Rank: 547
- State Division Rank: 76
2018-19
Head Coach: Patrick Warnick
- Conference: District 9 - Small North
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 2-7
- Conference Record: 2-6
- DMA Rank: 70
- National Rank: 13760
- State Rank: 560
- State Division Rank: 83
2017-18
Head Coach: Patrick Warnick
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 2-7
- Conference Record: 2-6
- DMA Rank: 72
- National Rank: 13451
- State Rank: 555
- State Division Rank: 83
2016-17
Head Coach: Justin Bienkowski
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 0-9
- Conference Record: 0-6
- DMA Rank: 77
- National Rank: 13954
- State Rank: 581
- State Division Rank: 89
2015-16
Head Coach: Justin Bienkowski
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 6-5
- Conference Record: 5-1
- DMA Rank: 48
- National Rank: 9304
- State Rank: 392
- State Division Rank: 62
2014-15
Head Coach: Justin Bienkowski
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 3-6
- Conference Record: 3-5
- DMA Rank: 75
- National Rank: 12967
- State Rank: 545
- State Division Rank: 111
2013-14
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 4-6
- Conference Record: 4-5
- DMA Rank: 77
- National Rank: 11880
- State Rank: 522
- State Division Rank: 99
2012-13
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 13-1
- Conference Record: 6-0
- DMA Rank: 6
- National Rank: 1201
- State Rank: 51
- State Division Rank: 3
2011-12
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 12-2
- Conference Record: 5-0
- DMA Rank: 16
- National Rank: 2965
- State Rank: 117
- State Division Rank: 7
2010-11
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 7-5
- Conference Record: 5-2
- DMA Rank: 45
- National Rank: 6950
- State Rank: 305
- State Division Rank: 40
2009-10
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 6-4
- Conference Record: 5-3
- DMA Rank: 62
- National Rank: 8921
- State Rank: 403
- State Division Rank: 66
2008-09
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: Division A
- Overall Record: 3-6
- Conference Record: 3-6
- DMA Rank: 65
- National Rank: 9862
- State Rank: 440
- State Division Rank: 71
2007-08
Head Coach: Port Allegany Coach
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: -
- Overall Record: 6-4
- Conference Record: 5-2
- DMA Rank: 65
- National Rank: 8758
- State Rank: 386
2006-07
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain - Northern
- Division: -
- Overall Record: 2-7
- Conference Record: 2-3
- DMA Rank: 93
- National Rank: 11517
- State Rank: 510
2005-06
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain Northern
- Division: -
- Overall Record: 7-3
- Conference Record: 6-2
- DMA Rank: 54
- National Rank: 7909
- State Rank: 348
2004-05
Head Coach: Michael Bodamer
- Conference: Allegheny Mountain Northern
- Division: -
- Overall Record: 5-5
- Conference Record: 3-2
- DMA Rank: 69
- National Rank: 8946
- State Rank: 382