| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1926 | Normal Community | IL | 11-9-0 | 12.26 | 11.3 | -406 |
| 1927 | Lower Dauphin | PA | 15-7-0 | 12.26 | 6.3 | +50 |
| 1928 | Bishop Hartley | OH | 17-9-0 | 12.26 | 7.3 | +74 |
| 1929 | Osceola | FL | 19-9-0 | 12.26 | 6.8 | +278 |
| 1930 | Highland | IN | 14-4-0 | 12.25 | 3.4 | +157 |
| 1931 | North Broward Prep | FL | 15-12-0 | 12.24 | 10.4 | +264 |
| 1932 | Ralston Valley | CO | 13-7-0 | 12.24 | 8.3 | -72 |
| 1933 | Trinity Catholic | CT | 17-8-0 | 12.24 | 7.1 | +279 |
| 1934 | Nettleton | MS | 21-8-0 | 12.23 | 3.6 | +364 |
| 1935 | Hueytown | AL | 23-13-0 | 12.23 | 8.8 | -81 |
| 1936 | Hazelwood West | MO | 17-6-0 | 12.22 | 4.8 | -98 |
| 1937 | Fox Creek | SC | 12-3-1 | 12.22 | 1.3 | +551 |
| 1938 | Grayson | GA | 11-11-0 | 12.22 | 12.0 | +797 |
| 1939 | Bainbridge | WA | 20-4-0 | 12.21 | 1.6 | -292 |
| 1940 | Myers Park | NC | 15-9-0 | 12.21 | 7.3 | +598 |
| 1941 | Spring Valley | SC | 12-8-0 | 12.21 | 7.4 | +405 |
| 1942 | Mount Paran Christian | GA | 19-6-0 | 12.21 | 4.0 | -85 |
| 1943 | Lapel | IN | 23-10-0 | 12.21 | 4.5 | +474 |
| 1944 | Bullard | TX | 18-8-0 | 12.21 | 6.3 | +455 |
| 1945 | Flint Hill | VA | 18-6-0 | 12.20 | 4.9 | -482 |
| 1946 | J.P. Stevens | NJ | 17-7-1 | 12.19 | 5.9 | -169 |
| 1947 | Gilman | MD | 17-10-0 | 12.19 | 9.6 | -169 |
| 1948 | Arcadia | AZ | 20-11-0 | 12.19 | 7.0 | -52 |
| 1949 | Mercersburg Academy | PA | 15-4-1 | 12.17 | 2.8 | +377 |
| 1950 | Cache | OK | 14-15-0 | 12.17 | 13.7 | +347 |