| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1951 | McDowell | PA | 14-9-0 | 13.10 | 8.7 | +260 |
| 1952 | Simon Kenton | KY | 28-12-0 | 13.10 | 5.3 | +145 |
| 1953 | East Ascension | LA | 14-15-0 | 13.09 | 15.0 | -103 |
| 1954 | Caruthersville | MO | 19-3-0 | 13.08 | 0.8 | -94 |
| 1955 | Red Bank Catholic | NJ | 19-8-0 | 13.08 | 6.6 | -378 |
| 1956 | Benicia | CA | 19-12-0 | 13.08 | 6.5 | +788 |
| 1957 | Interboro | PA | 20-1-0 | 13.08 | -2.8 | -139 |
| 1958 | Southern Boone | MO | 17-8-0 | 13.07 | 7.0 | -138 |
| 1959 | Lago Vista | TX | 25-13-0 | 13.07 | 6.6 | +615 |
| 1960 | Dickinson | ND | 29-9-0 | 13.07 | 2.1 | +357 |
| 1961 | St. Joseph Catholic | MS | 27-7-0 | 13.07 | 1.4 | +214 |
| 1962 | Apex | NC | 16-10-0 | 13.06 | 9.6 | -313 |
| 1963 | Fairmont | OH | 15-9-1 | 13.06 | 10.0 | -453 |
| 1964 | Trion | GA | 24-8-0 | 13.05 | 2.8 | +432 |
| 1965 | Desert Mountain | AZ | 13-17-0 | 13.05 | 15.6 | -161 |
| 1966 | West Forsyth | NC | 19-8-0 | 13.05 | 6.6 | -167 |
| 1967 | Kirkwood | MO | 12-6-0 | 13.05 | 9.3 | -930 |
| 1968 | Enterprise | UT | 21-6-0 | 13.05 | -1.7 | +1,184 |
| 1969 | Monarch | CO | 14-7-0 | 13.04 | 8.5 | -117 |
| 1970 | Bridgewater-Raynham | MA | 18-7-0 | 13.04 | 5.6 | -211 |
| 1971 | Boiling Springs | SC | 18-9-1 | 13.03 | 8.0 | -105 |
| 1972 | Sandia | NM | 18-9-0 | 13.03 | 7.9 | -385 |
| 1973 | Kennett | MO | 9-6-0 | 13.03 | 9.5 | +235 |
| 1974 | Floyd Central | IN | 10-9-0 | 13.03 | 12.7 | +20 |
| 1975 | West Islip | NY | 20-5-0 | 13.01 | 1.0 | +391 |