| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1876 | Holy Cross | KY | 15-9 | 17.20 | 12.8 | -119 |
| 1877 | Saint Andrew's | FL | 23-3 | 17.20 | 2.2 | +45 |
| 1878 | C Catholic/Mt. St. Mary Academy | AR | 10-11 | 17.20 | 16.3 | +52 |
| 1879 | Paint Branch | MD | 17-6 | 17.20 | 10.7 | +34 |
| 1880 | O Okeene | OK | 29-1 | 17.20 | 3.5 | +56 |
| 1881 | Bishop Ford | NY | 19-3 | 17.20 | 6.7 | +385 |
| 1882 | Mt. Abraham | VT | 24-2 | 17.20 | 4.3 | +91 |
| 1883 | Fair Park | LA | 26-6 | 17.20 | 8.0 | +33 |
| 1884 | Howard Tech | TN | 30-5 | 17.20 | 6.5 | +39 |
| 1885 | Bay Port | WI | 12-12 | 17.20 | 15.1 | +50 |
| 1886 | Vista Murrieta | CA | 15-14 | 17.20 | 16.6 | +82 |
| 1887 | Halls | TN | 26-6 | 17.20 | 5.5 | +9 |
| 1888 | Lake Hamilton | AR | 18-9 | 17.20 | 13.7 | +29 |
| 1889 | Highlands Ranch | CO | 14-11 | 17.20 | 14.5 | +61 |
| 1890 | T.C. Roberson | NC | 28-4 | 17.20 | 5.9 | -138 |
| 1891 | Orange Lutheran | CA | 10-16 | 17.20 | 20.7 | +71 |
| 1892 | George Washington | WV | 14-7 | 17.20 | 11.8 | -338 |
| 1893 | Northside | GA | 24-8 | 17.20 | 11.3 | +53 |
| 1894 | East | NY | 19-5 | 17.20 | 6.0 | +61 |
| 1895 | Passaic Valley | NJ | 21-9 | 17.20 | 11.7 | +66 |
| 1896 | Roosevelt | TX | 23-9 | 17.10 | 9.9 | +119 |
| 1897 | Collegiate | KS | 20-6 | 17.10 | 6.5 | +86 |
| 1898 | McKinley | HI | 17-8 | 17.10 | 8.2 | +88 |
| 1899 | Fairmont | OH | 17-7 | 17.10 | 11.4 | -584 |
| 1900 | Bay | FL | 20-10 | 17.10 | 12.6 | +59 |