| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1951 | Long Island Lutheran | NY | 16-8 | 17.00 | 10.5 | +209 |
| 1952 | Valley Christian | AZ | 34-1 | 17.00 | -0.3 | +59 |
| 1953 | Saint Ignatius College Prep | IL | 13-10 | 17.00 | 14.0 | +37 |
| 1954 | C Communications Tech | PA | 18-7 | 16.90 | 9.5 | +103 |
| 1955 | Browning | MT | 22-1 | 16.90 | 5.4 | +66 |
| 1956 | Redwood Valley | MN | 23-4 | 16.90 | 6.1 | +70 |
| 1957 | Canton | MI | 18-7 | 16.90 | 11.5 | +84 |
| 1958 | Burroughs | CA | 16-12 | 16.90 | 14.0 | +137 |
| 1959 | Red Land | PA | 19-6 | 16.90 | 9.5 | +42 |
| 1960 | Mayo | MN | 17-10 | 16.90 | 13.2 | +74 |
| 1961 | Mountain Vista | CO | 14-11 | 16.90 | 13.9 | +49 |
| 1962 | Ayala | CA | 13-13 | 16.90 | 16.0 | +101 |
| 1963 | Pittsburg | CA | 16-9 | 16.90 | 10.7 | +34 |
| 1964 | Greenville | TX | 21-10 | 16.90 | 10.8 | +107 |
| 1965 | South Eugene | OR | 12-15 | 16.90 | 18.2 | +73 |
| 1966 | Waukee | IA | 9-14 | 16.90 | 19.4 | +56 |
| 1967 | Dutch Fork | SC | 16-7 | 16.90 | 13.3 | +25 |
| 1968 | Winston-Salem Preparatory Academy | NC | 22-7 | 16.90 | 7.2 | +48 |
| 1969 | Mundy's Mill | GA | 17-9 | 16.90 | 10.3 | +2 |
| 1970 | Squalicum | WA | 20-7 | 16.90 | 11.2 | +120 |
| 1971 | D'Evelyn | CO | 19-7 | 16.90 | 10.3 | +82 |
| 1972 | Columbia | FL | 10-4 | 16.90 | 9.2 | +28 |
| 1973 | West Valley | WA | 15-11 | 16.90 | 14.1 | +64 |
| 1974 | Miller | CA | 17-11 | 16.90 | 13.8 | +80 |
| 1975 | Harvest Prep | OH | 23-2 | 16.90 | 3.0 | -997 |