Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

McGrawCincinnatus Central

Eagles
5
Lions
6

The Cincinnatus Central (Cincinnatus, NY) varsity softball team won Friday's home conference game against McGraw (NY) by a score of 6-5.

1234567RHE
McGraw1004000562
Cincinnatus Central1020021662
  • Recap
  • Box Score
  • Matchup Info

Game Stats

McGraw (25-26)

McGraw has not entered stats for this game.

Cincinnatus Central (25-26)

Cincinnatus Central

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.2313526665110
2Lucy Finch.50042012010
5Brady Kemp.00043000000
7Payton Gerrard.33343210000
10Jelsie Stafford.00044101000
12Addison Stith.00041000000
12Madison Stover.50044022100
16Lydia Scutt.00031200000
17Neveah Billings.25044010000
19Hannah Ellerson.25044110000
Cincinnatus Central

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals00752227.429.346.775
2Lucy Finch00200002.7501.5002.250
5Brady Kemp00100001.250.000.250
7Payton Gerrard00001101.500.333.833
10Jelsie Stafford00020113.000.000.000
12Addison Stith00300001.750.000.750
12Madison Stover00000002.500.7501.250
16Lydia Scutt00111002.667.000.667
17Neveah Billings00000013.250.250.500
19Hannah Ellerson00020002.250.250.500
Cincinnatus Central

Baserunning

#Athlete NameSBSBA
Team Totals1
10Jelsie Stafford1
Cincinnatus Central

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals.9172421120
5Brady Kemp1.00022000
7Payton Gerrard1.00022000
10Jelsie Stafford1.00011000
12Addison Stith1.00021100
12Madison Stover1.0001010000
16Lydia Scutt.66764020
17Neveah Billings1.00011000
Cincinnatus Central

Pitching

#Athlete NameERAWLW%APPGSCGSOSVNHPG
Team Totals5.00101.00010
7Payton Gerrard5.00101.00010
Cincinnatus Central

#Athlete NameIPHRERBBK2B3BHRBFAB
Team Totals765581003527
7Payton Gerrard765581003527
Cincinnatus Central

#Athlete NameOBAOBPWPHBPSFSH/B#P
Team Totals.222.40000138
7Payton Gerrard.222.40000138
Stat Supplier Logo

Cincinnatus Central's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for softballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Game Story

New York High School Softball - McGraw can't get by Cincinnatus Central

May 8, 2026: Cincinnatus, NY 13040

The Cincinnatus Central Lions edged the visiting McGraw Eagles softball squad by a count of 6-5 in Friday's league challenge.

Next, the Lions meet the Stockbridge Valley Indians (Munnsville, NY) in a Section 3 Central Counties - American challenge, on Tuesday, May 12. Cincinnatus Central will attempt to upgrade on its 12-0 season record. The Indians enter the challenge with a 0-5 record after their 6-5 league loss to McGraw (McGraw, NY).

The Eagles (12-2) will now prepare for their challenge against Weedsport (Weedsport, NY). The Warriors enter the non-league challenge with a 4-5 record. In their last challenge, Weedsport edged Hammond Central (Hammond, NY), 11-2, in a non-league challenge.

McGraw @ CCHS Softball Game Info

Fri., May. 8, 2026 @ 4:30p
Cincinnatus High School
The Cincinnatus Central (Cincinnatus, NY) varsity softball team won Friday's home conference game against McGraw (NY) by a score of 6-5.

Rankings & Records

McGraw (25-26)

NYSectionState Class
10684
OverallLeagueHomeAwayNeutralWin %League %RFRA
18-35-210-17-21-0.857.71422053

Cincinnatus Central (25-26)

NYSectionState Class
7272
OverallLeagueHomeAwayWin %League %RFRA
17-08-010-07-01.0001.00016547

Team Scoring Averages

12345678RHE
McGraw		1.71.01.61.6.1.41.0-10.56.41.4
Cincinnatus Central		2.81.22.11.41.71.31.11.09.79.01.8

Head-to-Head

  • Cincinnatus Central won on 4/30/2026
    4/30 @ 4:30p1234567RHE
    CCHS11101015101
    McGraw1000100223

    The Cincinnatus Central (Cincinnatus, NY) varsity softball team won Thursday's away conference game against McGraw (NY) by a score of 5-2.

    Box score
  • Cincinnatus Central won last month
    5/8 @ 4:30p1234567RHE
    McGraw1004000562
    CCHS1020021662

    The McGraw (NY) varsity softball team lost Friday's away conference game against Cincinnatus Central (Cincinnatus, NY) by a score of 6-5.

    Box score

Team Stat Comparison

McGrawCincinnatus Central
-Batting Average.323
-On Base Percentage.455
-Slugging Percentage.439
-Fielding Percentage.918
-Win Loss Percentage1.000

Team Leaders

McGrawCincinnatus CentralNational Avg.
-
Batting Average#7 Payton Gerrard.429.288
-
On Base Percentage#14 Kim Hill.571.407
-
Slugging Percentage#2 Lucy Finch.738.396
-
Fielding Percentage#10 Jelsie Stafford1.000.828
-
Win Loss Percentage#17 Neveah Billings1.000.558

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
McGraw9-0Cincinnatus Central10-0
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
4/2/26McGrawGroton(W) 20-14/21/26GrotonCincinnatus Central(W) 18-0
4/11/26Morrisville-EatonMcGraw(W) 6-45/26/26Morrisville-EatonCincinnatus Central(W) 6-2
4/14/26Stockbridge ValleyMcGraw(W) 8-44/17/26Stockbridge ValleyCincinnatus Central(W) 12-3
5/7/26McGrawStockbridge Valley(W) 6-55/12/26Cincinnatus CentralStockbridge Valley(W) 6-2
4/23/26McGrawOtselic Valley(W) 23-04/16/26Otselic ValleyCincinnatus Central(W) 18-0
5/13/26Otselic ValleyMcGraw5/1/26Cincinnatus CentralOtselic Valley(W) 16-0
4/27/26McGrawBrookfield Central(W) 18-04/13/26Cincinnatus CentralBrookfield Central(W) 13-2
5/4/26Brookfield CentralMcGraw(W) 17-05/7/26Brookfield CentralCincinnatus Central(W) 7-3
4/28/26OnondagaMcGraw(W) 13-14/24/26Cincinnatus CentralOnondaga(W) 7-6
4/28/26LaFayette/OnondagaMcGraw(W) 13-14/24/26Cincinnatus CentralLaFayette/Onondaga(W) 7-6

Record Breakdown

McGraw (25-26)

Cincinnatus Central (25-26)
18-3
Overall
17-0
5-2
League
8-0
11-1
Non-League
8-0
0-2
Head to Head
2-0
9-0
Common Opponent
10-0
10-1
Home
10-0
7-2
Away
7-0
1-0
Neutral
0-0
0-0
Playoff
0-0
18-3
In-State
17-0
0-0
Out-of-State
0-0