| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1851 | Metro Nashville | TN | 8-10 | -12.08 | -9.3 | -1 |
| 1852 | New Oxford | PA | 1-12 | -12.09 | -0.4 | -1 |
| 1853 | Liberty | NJ | 3-10 | -12.09 | -4.1 | -1 |
| 1854 | St. Mary's | MA | 5-13 | -12.10 | -4.8 | +3 |
| 1855 | Unity Reed | VA | 3-11 | -12.13 | -2.0 | -1 |
| 1856 | Big Walnut | OH | 4-11 | -12.14 | -3.8 | -3 |
| 1857 | Hampton Bays | NY | 2-13 | -12.16 | 0.2 | +7 |
| 1858 | Vergennes | VT | 6-14 | -12.18 | -4.9 | -2 |
| 1859 | Milford | MA | 4-11 | -12.24 | -4.1 | -4 |
| 1860 | Lake Catholic | OH | 2-11 | -12.37 | -1.1 | -2 |
| 1861 | Homewood-Flossmoor | IL | 5-13 | -12.38 | -5.6 | -1 |
| 1862 | New Egypt | NJ | 4-13 | -12.39 | -2.4 | -3 |
| 1863 | Manchester West | NH | 1-14 | -12.39 | 3.4 | -2 |
| 1864 | Hill-Murray | MN | 0-13 | -12.41 | 2.8 | -2 |
| 1865 | Copiague | NY | 3-11 | -12.45 | -2.2 | +5 |
| 1866 | Norwich Free Academy | CT | 4-12 | -12.48 | -4.2 | -3 |
| 1867 | East Lansing | MI | 1-13 | -12.50 | 0.1 | -2 |
| 1868 | Southeastern RVT | MA | 13-9 | -12.52 | -13.4 | -1 |
| 1869 | White Knoll | SC | 6-8 | -12.54 | -9.8 | -1 |
| 1870 | W Wellington School | OH | 1-14 | -12.66 | 3.4 | +1 |
| 1871 | Darlington | GA | 2-14 | -12.66 | 0.8 | +1 |
| 1872 | Bishop Loughlin | NY | 8-11 | -12.68 | -10.0 | +1 |
| 1873 | Alhambra | CA | 2-13 | -12.68 | -0.3 | -7 |
| 1874 | Lowell Catholic | MA | 7-11 | -12.73 | -8.4 | +1 |
| 1875 | Southeast Guilford | NC | 4-9 | -12.74 | -4.1 | -1 |