| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1951 | Oratory Prep | NJ | 3-11-0 | -5.44 | 4.7 | -- |
| 1952 | Santa Fe | FL | 9-6-0 | -5.50 | -9.4 | +1 |
| 1953 | St. Luke's | CT | 4-5-0 | -5.51 | -3.7 | +40 |
| 1954 | Averill Park | NY | 5-12-0 | -5.51 | 2.7 | +3 |
| 1955 | Canyon Crest Academy | CA | 4-7-0 | -5.53 | 0.3 | +17 |
| 1956 | Mountain Island Charter | NC | 7-10-0 | -5.54 | 0.5 | +18 |
| 1957 | North Broward Prep | FL | 2-15-0 | -5.55 | 9.0 | +14 |
| 1958 | East | PA | 2-13-0 | -5.56 | 7.9 | -6 |
| 1959 | Croton-Harmon | NY | 6-10-0 | -5.57 | -2.7 | +10 |
| 1960 | Morgan | CT | 11-9-0 | -5.58 | -7.2 | -2 |
| 1961 | Woodgrove | VA | 2-10-0 | -5.61 | 7.1 | -23 |
| 1962 | Owatonna | MN | 4-10-0 | -5.62 | 1.1 | -1 |
| 1963 | Middleborough | MA | 5-10-0 | -5.63 | 0.2 | +16 |
| 1964 | Bartlett | TN | 4-8-0 | -5.64 | 0.1 | -5 |
| 1965 | Robinson | FL | 4-9-0 | -5.64 | 2.0 | +3 |
| 1966 | Troy | MI | 6-7-0 | -5.65 | -4.3 | -2 |
| 1967 | Godwin | VA | 3-11-0 | -5.65 | 5.1 | +25 |
| 1968 | North Penn | PA | 1-8-0 | -5.66 | 8.2 | -6 |
| 1969 | Lakeside | GA | 11-6-0 | -5.66 | -12.1 | -2 |
| 1970 | Mill Valley | KS | 5-8-0 | -5.67 | -2.2 | -- |
| 1971 | Cardinal O'Hara | PA | 4-6-0 | -5.72 | -3.2 | -6 |
| 1972 | Dalton | GA | 5-12-0 | -5.72 | 1.3 | +5 |
| 1973 | Edgemont | NY | 9-7-0 | -5.72 | -8.9 | +69 |
| 1974 | Southampton | NY | 6-9-0 | -5.72 | -2.0 | -11 |
| 1975 | Rancho Bernardo | CA | 3-13-0 | -5.75 | 5.8 | +9 |