| Dennis Chapman (Sr.) | 2023 Rim Rock Farm Classic | 2 | 15:17.80 |
| Dennis Chapman (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 3 | 15:24.55 |
| Jacob Finney (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 7 | 15:56.35 |
| Dennis Chapman (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 15:59.10 |
| Eli Jones (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 10 | 16:06.16 |
| Jacob Finney (Sr.) | 2023 Rim Rock Farm Classic | 20 | 16:13.50 |
| Eli Jones (Sr.) | 2023 Rim Rock Farm Classic | 33 | 16:30.80 |
| Aidan McGarry (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 23 | 16:31.43 |
| Aidan McGarry (Sr.) | 2023 Rim Rock Farm Classic | 42 | 16:36.70 |
| Eli Jones (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 16:43.60 |
| Owen Jensen (Sr.) | 2023 Rim Rock Farm Classic | 48 | 16:44.20 |
| Owen Jensen (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 36 | 16:50.23 |
| Michael Sauer (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 39 | 16:51.14 |
| Andrew Sauer (Sr.) | 2023 Rim Rock Farm Classic | 68 | 16:59.00 |
| Jack Goltl (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 54 | 17:02.50 |
| Andrew Sauer (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 56 | 17:03.72 |
| Michael Sauer (Sr.) | 2023 Rim Rock Farm Classic | 86 | 17:07.00 |
| Jacob Finney (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 17:07.60 |
| Aidan McGarry (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 17:23.90 |
| Michael Sauer (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 17:39.50 |
| Andrew Sauer (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 17:44.60 |
| Owen Jensen (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 17:53.70 |
| Jack Goltl (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 18:02.10 |
| Will Young (Sr.) | Augustana Twilight | 164 | 18:10.48 |
| Peter Youell (Fr.) | Augustana Twilight | 204 | 18:35.09 |
| Peter Youell (Fr.) | Class of the Metro | | 19:09.70 |
| Will Young (Sr.) | Class of the Metro | | 19:13.10 |
