Port Allegany is 0-5 against St. Marys since December of 2015 but things could change on Monday. The Gators will take on the Flying Dutch in a holiday battle at 7:00 p.m. Both come into the contest bolstered by wins in their previous matches.
Port Allegany is headed in fresh off scoring the most points they have all season. They took down Coudersport 54-38 on Saturday. The victory made it back-to-back wins for the Gators.

Jenna Renner
| 12/13/25 vs Coudersport | 23 |
| 12/08/25 vs Galeton | 16 |
| 01/09/25 vs Austin | 16 |
| 12/04/24 @ Kane | 12 |
| 01/30/25 vs Northern Potter | 11 |
Port Allegany relied on the efforts of Jenna Renner, who went 8-for-11 to rack up 23 points in addition to seven boards and three steals, and Brynn Evens, who dropped a double-double with 11 points and 13 rebounds. Those 23 points gave Renner a new career-high. Another player making a difference was Breah Fillhart, who posted four points and six boards.
Port Allegany smashed the offensive glass and finished the game with 20 offensive rebounds. That strong performance was nothing new for the team: they've now pulled down at least 12 offensive boards every time they've taken the court this season.
Meanwhile, even if it wasn't a dominant performance, St. Marys beat Elk County Catholic 45-39 on Friday. The victory continues a trend for the Flying Dutch in their matchups with the Crusaders: they've now won three in a row.
Port Allegany's record is now 2-3. As for St. Marys, their record now sits at 4-1.
Port Allegany couldn't quite get it done against St. Marys in their previous matchup back in January of 2021 as they fell 43-35. Can the Gators avenge their loss or is history doomed to repeat itself? We'll find out soon enough.
Article generated by infoSentience based on data entered on MaxPreps