John Jay

John Jay Indians

Varsity Softball

Cross River, NY

25-26

Overall

13-5

League

5-3 (2nd)

NY Rank

63

John Jay Softball History

Previous Seasons All-Time Roster

2025-26(16 players)
2015-16(11 players)
Head Coach: Timmy Collins
- Martin, Olivia(Jr.)
- Fisher, Kayla(Sr.)
- McCauley, Susan(Sr.)
- Berton, Ashley(Sr.)
- Herdrich, Megan(Sr.)
- Hammond, Nikki(Sr.)
- Castaldo, Danielle(So.)
- Carbaugh, Lane(So.)
- Downs, Emily(Sr.)
- Rohrer, Haley(Jr.)
- Altneu, Brooke(Fr.)
2014-15(1 players)
Head Coach: Angelo Formisano
- Swertfager, Theresa(Sr.)
2009-10(12 players)
Head Coach: Joe Mammoser
- Catanese, Rachel(Jr.)
- Masterson, Sara(So.)
- Matschke, Ali(So.)
- Eidam, Laura(Jr.)
- Merritt, Chelsea(Sr.)
- Garafolo, Paige(Sr.)
- Gullen, Victoria(So.)
- Antenucci, Natalie(Sr.)
- Mosello, Jesse(Jr.)
- Symer, Elise(Jr.)
- Silverstein, Maddy(So.)
- Rutherford, Ashleigh(So.)
2007-08(14 players)
Head Coach: Joe Mammoser
- Causa, Christine(Jr.)
- Ferris, Melinda(Jr.)
- Klimberg, Julie(Jr.)
- Voorhees, Kristen(Jr.)
- Fowler, Sam(Jr.)
- Antenucci, Natalie(So.)
- Forese, Emily(Jr.)
- Garafolo, Paige(So.)
- Simonetti, Tori(Sr.)
- Dewar, Caroline(Sr.)
- Torzilli, Gaby(Sr.)
- Mangione, Amanda(Sr.)
- Finn, Jackie(Jr.)
- Eidam, Laura(Fr.)
2006-07(15 players)
Head Coach: Joe Mammoser
- Torzilli, Gaby(Jr.)
- Koren, Jessica(Jr.)
- Reitman, Denise(Jr.)
- Roeckle, Kristen(Sr.)
- Bosin, Paige(Jr.)
- Begley, Kristen(Sr.)
- Voorhees, Kristen
- Devito, Tina(Sr.)
- McShane, Sarah
- Finn, Stephanie(Sr.)
- Dewar, Caroline(Jr.)
- Bonfantini, Lisa(Jr.)
- Mangione, Amanda(Jr.)
- Simonetti, Tori(Jr.)
- Finn, Jackie

John Jay High School

John Jay High School

60 N. Salem Rd.

Cross River, NY 10536-0463

Partnerships:

John Jay HS Tickets

About UsMobile AppsSubscribePrivacy PolicyTerms of useCalifornia NoticeSupport

© 2026 MaxPreps, Inc.

MaxPreps is a registered trademark of MaxPreps, Inc.