| # | Name | GAA Avg | Goals Against | Min |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Matt HolowkaGOrchard Park | 5.486 | 48 | 420 |
| 2 | Ben MazurGLancaster | 6.522 | 103 | 758 |
| 3 | John ConteGOrchard Park | 7.310 | 53 | 348 |
| 4 | Eric DeakinGSJCI (Buffalo) | 8.300 | 120 | 694 |
| 5 | Symon JonathanGAkron | 8.427 | 158 | 900 |
| 6 | Coda KenyonGMedina | 10.105 | 104 | 494 |
| 7 | Mason PecoraroGMedina | 10.759 | 52 | 232 |