| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | Saint Lawrence Academy | CA | 2-11 | -8.26 | 1.5 | -110 |
| 2002 | Walsingham Academy | VA | 1-15 | -8.29 | 1.9 | -114 |
| 2003 | Hamilton | NJ | 1-14 | -8.32 | 1.2 | -111 |
| 2004 | Licking Valley | OH | 2-15 | -8.37 | 1.3 | -109 |
| 2005 | Dedham | MA | 0-8 | -8.37 | 2.1 | -- |
| 2006 | Rossford | OH | 3-12 | -8.38 | 1.1 | -112 |
| 2007 | Park | MN | 0-9 | -8.42 | 1.6 | -135 |
| 2008 | Delmar | DE | 2-13 | -8.42 | 1.5 | -110 |
| 2009 | Queens Teaching | NY | 1-11 | -8.43 | 2.3 | -113 |
| 2010 | Thorncreek Christian School | CO | 3-11 | -8.44 | 0.9 | -108 |
| 2011 | Dickinson | DE | 3-11 | -8.46 | 1.3 | -110 |
| 2012 | East Gaston | NC | 0-9 | -8.48 | 3.6 | -115 |
| 2013 | Mid-Peninsula | CA | 2-10 | -8.49 | 1.8 | -109 |
| 2014 | Brandywine | MI | 1-10 | -8.49 | 1.4 | -111 |
| 2015 | Montezuma-Cortez | CO | 1-13 | -8.53 | 2.0 | -110 |
| 2016 | StoneBridge | VA | 1-8 | -8.53 | 0.9 | -110 |
| 2017 | White Pine | NV | 2-10 | -8.54 | 1.0 | -108 |
| 2018 | North Fremont | ID | 0-8 | -8.58 | 3.5 | -110 |
| 2019 | Park Center | MN | 0-9 | -8.58 | 1.9 | -- |
| 2020 | Vail Mountain | CO | 3-11 | -8.58 | 1.2 | -109 |
| 2021 | Ashland | MA | 2-12 | -8.58 | 1.9 | -- |
| 2022 | Owatonna | MN | 0-8 | -8.59 | 1.6 | -- |
| 2023 | Liberty Center | OH | 2-12 | -8.59 | 1.3 | -116 |
| 2024 | A-Tech | NY | 1-10 | -8.60 | 1.2 | -112 |
| 2025 | Etna | CA | 1-11 | -8.62 | 1.4 | -115 |