Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

Seton Hall Prep Nutley

Pirates

Raiders

The Nutley (NJ) varsity baseball team lost Monday's home conference game against Seton Hall Prep (West Orange, NJ) by a score of 12-7.

	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	R	H	E
Seton Hall Prep	0	4	0	1	0	5	2	12	11	3
Nutley	0	0	0	0	5	2	0	7	11	2

Final score provided by J. Goldberg.

Recap
Box Score
Fan Chat
Matchup Info

Game Stats

Nutley (25-26)

Seton Hall Prep

Batting

#	Athlete Name	Avg	PA	AB	R	H	RBI	2B	HR
	Team Totals	.344	41	32	12	11	12	2	3
3	John Deveau (Jr)	.333	4	3	1	1	1
6	Xavier McKnight (Sr)		4	3
7	Jack Webber (Jr)	.250	5	4	1	1
8	Patrick Cassels (Sr)		0	0	2	0
10	Noah Vargas (Fr)	.333	5	3	2	1	1
14	Jaxson Davis (Sr)	.250	4	4	2	1	2		1
22	Jordan Burwell (Sr)	.750	5	4	2	3	5		2
23	Joey Maiella (Jr)	.500	4	4		2	2	1
27	Devin Aiken (Sr)	.333	5	3	1	1
31	JJ Drennan (Sr)	.250	5	4	1	1	1	1

Nutley

Batting

Athlete Name	Avg	PA	AB	R	H	RBI	2B
Team Totals	.375	38	32	7	12	7	3
Andrew Raboy	.333	4	3	2	1	0	0
J. Veneziano	.667	4	3	0	2	1	0
John Machtemes	.667	4	3	1	2	3	0

Seton Hall Prep

#	Athlete Name	SF	BB	K	HBP	OBP	SLG	OPS
	Team Totals	2	6	6	1	.439	.688	1.126
3	John Deveau (Jr)		1			.500	.333	.833
6	Xavier McKnight (Sr)		1			.250	.000	.250
7	Jack Webber (Jr)				1	.400	.250	.650
10	Noah Vargas (Fr)		2	1		.600	.333	.933
14	Jaxson Davis (Sr)			2		.250	1.000	1.250
22	Jordan Burwell (Sr)	1		1		.600	2.250	2.850
23	Joey Maiella (Jr)			1		.500	.750	1.250
27	Devin Aiken (Sr)		2			.600	.333	.933
31	JJ Drennan (Sr)	1		1		.200	.500	.700

Nutley

Athlete Name	BB	K	HBP	ROE	FC	LOB	OBP	SLG	OPS
Team Totals	5	11	1	1	1	10	.474	.469	.943
Andrew Raboy	1	2	0	0	0	3	.500	.333	.833
J. Veneziano	1	0	0	0	0	0	.750	.667	1.417
John Machtemes	1	0	0	0	1	2	.750	.667	1.417

Seton Hall Prep

Baserunning

#	Athlete Name	SB	SBA
	Team Totals	2	2
10	Noah Vargas (Fr)	2	2

Baserunning

Nutley has not entered any baserunning stats.

Fielding

Seton Hall Prep has not entered any fielding stats.

Nutley

Fielding

Athlete Name	FP	TC	PO	A	E
Team Totals	.926	27	21	4	2
J. Veneziano	1.000	2	1	1	0
John Machtemes	1.000	3	3	0	0

Seton Hall Prep

Pitching

#	Athlete Name	ERA	W	W%	APP	GS
	Team Totals	5.00	1	1.000	4	1
17	J. Pontoriero (Sr)	0.00	1	1.000	1
24	Matthew Filiaci (So)	5.25			1	1
34	Ryan Depp (Fr)	21.00			1
44	Bryce Bradley (Jr)	0.00			1

Nutley

Pitching

Athlete Name	ERA	APP
Team Totals	7.00	1
Devon Schlitt	4.67	1
PJ Balsamo	0.00	1

Seton Hall Prep

#	Athlete Name	IP	H	R	ER	BB	K
	Team Totals	7	11	7	5	5	11
17	J. Pontoriero (Sr)	1.1	2	2	0		3
24	Matthew Filiaci (So)	4	5	3	3	3	6
34	Ryan Depp (Fr)	.2	3	2	2	1	1
44	Bryce Bradley (Jr)	1	1	0	0	1	1

Nutley

Athlete Name	IP	H	R	ER	BB	K	HR	BF	AB
Team Totals	7	11	12	7	6	6	3	41	34
Devon Schlitt	3	4	5	2	3	1	1	18	14
PJ Balsamo	2	1	0	0	2	3	0	9	7

Seton Hall Prep

#	Athlete Name	OBP	HBP
	Team Totals	2.833	1
24	Matthew Filiaci (So)	2.667
34	Ryan Depp (Fr)	4.000
44	Bryce Bradley (Jr)	1.500	1

Nutley

Athlete Name	OBA	OBP	HBP	#P	BK	SB
Team Totals	.324	.439	1	150	1	2
Devon Schlitt	.286	.444	1	65	0	1
PJ Balsamo	.143	.333	0	37	0	0

Nutley's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for baseballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Game Story

New Jersey High School Baseball - Nutley loses to Seton Hall Prep

April 27, 2026: Nutley, NJ 07110

The Nutley Raiders baseball squad (Nutley, NJ), was overwhelmed 12-7 in Monday's league contest with the visiting Seton Hall Prep Pirates (West Orange, NJ)

With the triumph, Seton Hall Prep moves its record to 12-3 on the season. The Pirates host Chaminade (Mineola, NY) to confront the Flyers in a non-league contest on Saturday, May 2. The Flyers come into the contest with a record of 9-7. Chaminade lost 4-1 in their recent league contest against St. Anthony's (Melville, NY)

The Raiders now possess a 11-7 record. They put it on the line next when they host Barringer for a non-league contest on Saturday, May 2. Nutley will confront a Blue Bears squad coming off a 10-4 non-league loss to Newark Tech (Newark, NJ). The Blue Bears record now stands at 4-7.

MaxPreps
Game Started

SHP
Pirates
0 - 0

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 4:32p
2nd Inning

SHP
Pirates
2 - 0

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 4:32pReport Spam
2nd Inning

SHP
Pirates
3 - 0

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 4:34pReport Spam
2nd Inning

SHP
Pirates
4 - 0

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 4:34pReport Spam
3rd Inning

SHP
Pirates
4 - 0

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 4:44pReport Spam
4th Inning

SHP
Pirates
4 - 0

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 4:58pReport Spam
4th Inning

SHP
Pirates
5 - 0

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 5:04pReport Spam
5th Inning

SHP
Pirates
5 - 0

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 5:20pReport Spam
5th Inning

SHP
Pirates
5 - 1

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 5:36pReport Spam
5th Inning

SHP
Pirates
5 - 2

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 5:39pReport Spam
5th Inning

SHP
Pirates
5 - 3

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 5:39pReport Spam
5th Inning

SHP
Pirates
5 - 4

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 5:41pReport Spam
5th Inning

SHP
Pirates
5 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 5:49pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
5 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 5:53pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
6 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:03pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
7 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:03pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
9 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:08pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
8 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:08pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
10 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:08pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
11 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:09pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
12 - 5

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:10pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
12 - 6

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:23pReport Spam
6th Inning

SHP
Pirates
12 - 7

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:23pReport Spam
7th Inning

SHP
Pirates
12 - 7

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 6:31pReport Spam
J. Goldberg
Final

SHP
Pirates
12 - 7

Nutley
Raiders

Posted @ 12:14p

SHP @ Nutley Baseball Game Info

Mon., Apr. 27, 2026 @ 4p

Park Oval-Nutley High School

The Nutley (NJ) varsity baseball team lost Monday's home conference game against Seton Hall Prep (West Orange, NJ) by a score of 12-7.

Rankings & Records

Seton Hall Prep (25-26)

NJ	Div.
9	3

Overall	League	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	League %	RF	RA
20-4	10-1	12-1	6-1	2-2	.833	.909	175	67

Nutley (25-26)

NJ	Div.
88	6

Overall	League	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	League %	RF	RA
15-13	1-6	13-6	2-6	0-1	.536	.143	167	134

Team Scoring Averages

	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	R	H	E
Seton Hall Prep	1.1	1.3	1.5	.8	1.4	1.0	1.3	-	-	-	7.3	8.3	1.2
Nutley	1.2	1.9	.5	.9	.4	.6	.7	1.3	0	1.0	6.0	6.7	1.6

Seton Hall Prep Videos

Nutley Videos

Nutley doesn't have any videos.

Head-to-Head

Seton Hall Prep won last month

4/27 @ 4p 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 R H E

Seton Hall Prep 0 4 0 1 0 5 2 12 11 3
Nutley 0 0 0 0 5 2 0 7 11 2

The Seton Hall Prep (West Orange, NJ) varsity baseball team won Monday's away conference game against Nutley (NJ) by a score of 12-7.
Box score
Seton Hall Prep won 3 days ago

5/16 @ 12p 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 R H E

Nutley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0
Seton Hall Prep 0 0 4 0 0 2 0 6 7 1

The Nutley (NJ) varsity baseball team lost Saturday's neutral tournament game against Seton Hall Prep (West Orange, NJ) by a score of 6-0.
Box score

5/16 @ 12p	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	R	H	E
Nutley	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2	0
Seton Hall Prep	0	0	4	0	0	2	0	6	7	1

Team Stat Comparison

Seton Hall Prep		Nutley
.332	Batting Average	.261
.458	On Base Percentage	.419
.470	Slugging Percentage	.356
-	Fielding Percentage	.941
.833	Win Loss Percentage	.200

Team Leaders

Seton Hall Prep		Nutley	National Avg.
#22 Jordan Burwell.522	Batting Average	John Machtemes.365	.244
#22 Jordan Burwell.615	On Base Percentage	Christian Sebastiano.667	.386
#22 Jordan Burwell.971	Slugging Percentage	John Machtemes.540	.313
-	Fielding Percentage	PJ Balsamo1.000	.858
#17 Joseph Pontoriero1.000	Win Loss Percentage	Nick Gaccione0	.533

Common Opponents

School	Common Opp. Rec.		School	Common Opp. Rec.
Seton Hall Prep	9-1		Nutley	5-3

Date	Away	Home	Result	Date	Away	Home	Result
3/31/26	Montclair	Seton Hall Prep	(W) 8-1	5/18/26	Nutley	Montclair	(L) 6-5
4/2/26	Seton Hall Prep	Montclair	(W) 6-3
4/13/26	Seton Hall Prep	Millburn	(W) 14-2	5/1/26	Millburn	Nutley	(W) 5-2
4/15/26	Millburn	Seton Hall Prep	(W) 5-0
4/20/26	West Essex	Seton Hall Prep	(L) 4-3	5/4/26	West Essex	Nutley
4/22/26	Seton Hall Prep	West Essex	(W) 11-0	5/9/26	West Essex	Nutley
5/1/26	Barringer	Seton Hall Prep	(W) 10-0	5/2/26	Barringer	Nutley	(W) 16-6
5/7/26	Verona	Seton Hall Prep	(W) 5-3	4/13/26	Verona	Nutley	(W) 10-6
				4/15/26	Nutley	Verona	(W) 11-4
5/12/26	Seton Hall Prep	Livingston	(W) 10-2	5/19/26	Nutley	Livingston
5/14/26	Livingston	Seton Hall Prep	(W) 7-3
5/19/26	Caldwell	Seton Hall Prep		5/6/26	Caldwell	Nutley	(W) 4-2
				5/12/26	Caldwell	Nutley	(L) 4-3
				5/14/26	Nutley	Caldwell	(L) 2-1

Record Breakdown

Seton Hall Prep (25-26)		Nutley (25-26)
20-4	Overall	15-13
10-1	League	1-6
5-1	Non-League	14-6
2-0	Head to Head	0-2
9-1	Common Opponent	5-3
12-1	Home	13-6
6-1	Away	2-6
2-2	Neutral	0-1
0-0	Playoff	0-0
19-2	In-State	15-13
1-2	Out-of-State	0-0