Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

CaldwellNutley

Chiefs
2
Raiders
4

The Nutley (NJ) varsity baseball team won Wednesday's home conference game against Caldwell (West Caldwell, NJ) in extra innings by a score of 4-2.

12345678RHE
Caldwell01000010240
Nutley000020024101
  • Recap
  • Box Score
  • Matchup Info

Game Stats

Caldwell (25-26)

Caldwell has not entered stats for this game.

Nutley (25-26)

Nutley

Batting

#Athlete NameAvgPAABRHRBI2B3BHRGS
Team Totals.30339334104100
Andrew Raboy.00043100000
J. Veneziano.50044020000
John Machtemes.00043000000
Nick Gaccione.00011000000
Nutley

#Athlete NameSFSH/BBBKHBPROEFCLOBOBPSLGOPS
Team Totals006400111.410.333.743
Andrew Raboy00110014.250.000.250
J. Veneziano00000001.500.5001.000
John Machtemes00100003.250.000.250
Nick Gaccione00010000.000.000.000
Nutley

Fielding

#Athlete NameFPTCPOAEDPTPPBSBASBCSCS%
Team Totals.9602524010
Andrew Raboy1.00011000
J. Veneziano1.00044000
John Machtemes1.00011000
Stat Supplier Logo

Nutley's stats are presented by GameChanger: live mobile scorekeeping for baseballGameChanger Media, Inc (ai)

Game Story

New Jersey High School Baseball - Caldwell held off by Nutley

May 6, 2026: Nutley, NJ 07110

The Nutley Raiders the visiting Caldwell Chiefs baseball squad by a score of 4-2 in Wednesday's league outing.

Next up, the Raiders battle the Wayne Valley Indians (Wayne, NJ) in a non-league outing, on Thursday, May 7. Nutley will attempt to advance on its 14-8 season record. The Indians come into the outing with a 8-10 record after their 11-1 non-league win over Lakeland Regional (Wanaque, NJ).

The Chiefs (19-3) will now prepare for their outing against West Essex (North Caldwell, NJ). The Knights come into the non-league outing with a 12-5 record. In their last outing, West Essex tipped St. Benedict's Prep (Newark, NJ), 6-5, in a non-league outing.

Caldwell @ Nutley Baseball Game Info

Wed., May. 6, 2026 @ 4:30p
The Nutley (NJ) varsity baseball team won Wednesday's home conference game against Caldwell (West Caldwell, NJ) in extra innings by a score of 4-2.

Rankings & Records

Caldwell (25-26)

NJDiv.
111
OverallLeagueHomeAwayWin %League %RFRA
19-43-112-27-2.826.75016160

Nutley (25-26)

NJDiv.
554
OverallLeagueHomeAwayWin %League %RFRA
15-91-213-52-4.625.333158116

Team Scoring Averages

12345678910RHE
Caldwell		1.5.5.72.51.7.52.001.0-7.06.3.8
Nutley		1.42.1.61.1.5.6.82.501.06.66.91.5

Head-to-Head

  • Nutley won last week
    5/6 @ 4:30p12345678RHE
    Caldwell01000010240
    Nutley000020024101

    The Caldwell (West Caldwell, NJ) varsity baseball team lost Wednesday's away conference game against Nutley (NJ) in extra innings by a score of 4-2.

    Box score
  • Game starts in a day

    The Caldwell (West Caldwell, NJ) varsity baseball team has an away conference game @ Nutley (NJ) on Tuesday, May 12 @ 4:30p.

    Preview game
  • Game starts in 3 day

    The Nutley (NJ) varsity baseball team has an away conference game @ Caldwell (West Caldwell, NJ) on Thursday, May 14 @ 4p.

    Preview game

Team Stat Comparison

CaldwellNutley
-Batting Average.272
-On Base Percentage.438
-Slugging Percentage.373
-Fielding Percentage.946
-Win Loss Percentage.500

Team Leaders

CaldwellNutleyNational Avg.
-
Batting AverageJohn Machtemes.400.244
-
On Base PercentageChristian Sebastiano.667.386
-
Slugging PercentageJohn Machtemes.580.313
-
Fielding PercentagePJ Balsamo1.000.859
-
Win Loss PercentageNick Gaccione0.535

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Caldwell10-3Nutley9-3
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
3/30/26CaldwellMontclair Kimberley Academy(W) 4-34/20/26Montclair Kimberley AcademyNutley(W) 13-0
3/31/26Montclair Kimberley AcademyCaldwell(W) 12-34/20/26Montclair Kimberley AcademyNutley(W) 10-3
4/6/26CaldwellSt. Benedict's Prep(W) 12-23/31/26NutleySt. Benedict's Prep(W) 6-2
4/8/26St. Benedict's PrepCaldwell(W) 11-13/31/26St. Benedict's PrepNutley(W) 6-2
4/2/26St. Benedict's PrepNutley(W) 6-0
4/2/26NutleySt. Benedict's Prep
4/13/26CaldwellWest Orange(W) 12-14/6/26West OrangeNutley(L) 6-1
4/15/26West OrangeCaldwell(W) 8-74/8/26NutleyWest Orange(L) 8-7
4/17/26VeronaCaldwell(L) 4-24/13/26VeronaNutley(W) 10-6
4/20/26VeronaCaldwell(L) 8-44/15/26NutleyVerona(W) 11-4
4/20/26VeronaCaldwell(W) 3-0
4/22/26CaldwellCedar Grove(W) 5-35/20/26Cedar GroveNutley
4/27/26LivingstonCaldwell(W) 10-05/19/26NutleyLivingston
5/4/26CaldwellMillburn(W) 13-15/1/26MillburnNutley(W) 5-2
5/7/26CaldwellWest Essex(L) 9-35/4/26West EssexNutley
5/9/26West EssexNutley
5/19/26CaldwellSeton Hall Prep4/27/26Seton Hall PrepNutley(L) 12-7
5/16/26NutleySeton Hall Prep
5/21/26BarringerCaldwell5/2/26BarringerNutley(W) 16-6

Record Breakdown

Caldwell (25-26)

Nutley (25-26)
19-4
Overall
15-9
3-1
League
1-2
16-3
Non-League
14-7
0-1
Head to Head
1-0
10-3
Common Opponent
9-3
12-2
Home
13-5
7-2
Away
2-4
0-0
Neutral
0-0
0-0
Playoff
0-0
19-4
In-State
15-9
0-0
Out-of-State
0-0