Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

Columbia City Garrett

Eagles

Railroaders

The Garrett (IN) varsity volleyball team won Tuesday's home non-conference match against Columbia City (IN) by a score of 3-1.

	S1	S2	S3	S4	Wins
Columbia City	25	26	13	18	1
Garrett	23	28	25	25	3

Final score provided by B. Thomas.

Recap
Box Score
Matchup Info

Match Stats

Garrett (25-26)

Columbia City

Attacking

#	Athlete Name	SP	K	K/S	Kill %	Att	E	Hit %
	Team Totals	4	31	7.8	25.4	122	24	.057
1	Maddy Hiss (Jr)	4	6	1.5	30.0	20	1	.250
2	S. Wilkinson (Jr)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0
3	Emme Carnahan (Sr)	4	0	0.0	.0	1	0	.000
4	S. Van buskirk (Sr)	4	7	1.8	30.4	23	2	.217
5	M. Fraunfelder (Sr)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0
6	Ella Peppler (So)	4	4	1.0	15.4	26	6	-.077
7	Bree Rumschlag (Sr)	4	10	2.5	34.5	29	8	.069
9	Norah Sheets (So)	2	0	0.0	.0	1	1	-1.000
11	Gabby Miller (Sr)	4	0	0.0	.0	7	3	-.429
13	Delaynee King (Sr)	4	4	1.0	26.7	15	3	.067

Garrett

Attacking

#	Athlete Name	SP	K	K/S	Kill %	Att	E	Hit %
	Team Totals	4	51	12.8	38.3	133	18	.248
3	Kaylee Gaar (Fr)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0
4	P. Grindstaff (So)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0
7	Carlie Thomas (Fr)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0
8	Piper Ice (Fr)	4	4	1.0	50.0	8	2	.250
9	Rilyn Flotow (Jr)	4	2	0.5	33.3	6	0	.333
10	Kaelynn York (So)	4	15	3.8	53.6	28	5	.357
11	Sarah Depew (Sr)	4	14	3.5	29.2	48	7	.146
12	Hadley Flotow (So)	4	2	0.5	25.0	8	1	.125
14	McKenna Naglack (Fr)	2	1	0.5	12.5	8	1	.000
15	Amelia Kesterke (Jr)	4	13	3.3	48.1	27	2	.407

Columbia City

Serving

#	Athlete Name	SP	A	A/S	Ace %	SA	SE	Serv %	PTS
	Team Totals	4	7	1.8	8.3	84	9	89.3	54
1	Maddy Hiss (Jr)	4	0	0.0	.0	10	0	100.0	7
2	S. Wilkinson (Jr)	4	0	0.0	.0	14	2	85.7	8
3	Emme Carnahan (Sr)	4	1	0.3	8.3	12	2	83.3	7
4	S. Van buskirk (Sr)	4	3	0.8	15.8	19	4	78.9	14
5	M. Fraunfelder (Sr)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0		0
6	Ella Peppler (So)	4	2	0.5	12.5	16	0	100.0	9
7	Bree Rumschlag (Sr)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0		0
9	Norah Sheets (So)	2	0	0.0	.0	0	0		0
11	Gabby Miller (Sr)	4	1	0.3	7.7	13	1	92.3	9
13	Delaynee King (Sr)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0		0

Garrett

Serving

#	Athlete Name	SP	A	A/S	Ace %	SA	SE	Serv %	PTS
	Team Totals	4	12	3.0	12.0	100	15	85.0	49
3	Kaylee Gaar (Fr)	4	1	0.3	11.1	9	1	88.9	3
4	P. Grindstaff (So)	4	1	0.3	5.3	19	3	84.2	12
7	Carlie Thomas (Fr)	4	3	0.8	30.0	10	3	70.0	4
8	Piper Ice (Fr)	4	1	0.3	25.0	4	2	50.0	1
9	Rilyn Flotow (Jr)	4	3	0.8	12.5	24	1	95.8	14
10	Kaelynn York (So)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0		0
11	Sarah Depew (Sr)	4	0	0.0	.0	20	1	95.0	10
12	Hadley Flotow (So)	4	0	0.0	.0	0	0		0
14	McKenna Naglack (Fr)	2	0	0.0	.0	0	0		0
15	Amelia Kesterke (Jr)	4	3	0.8	21.4	14	4	71.4	5

Columbia City

Blocking

#	Athlete Name	SP	BS	BA	Tot Blks	B/S	BE
	Team Totals	4	2	4	4	1.0	9
1	Maddy Hiss (Jr)	4	0	0	0	0.0	1
2	S. Wilkinson (Jr)	4	0	0	0	0.0	0
3	Emme Carnahan (Sr)	4	0	0	0	0.0	0
4	S. Van buskirk (Sr)	4	0	0	0	0.0	1
5	M. Fraunfelder (Sr)	4	0	0	0	0.0	0
6	Ella Peppler (So)	4	0	1	1	0.3	0
7	Bree Rumschlag (Sr)	4	1	2	3	0.8	5
9	Norah Sheets (So)	2	0	0	0	0.0	0
11	Gabby Miller (Sr)	4	0	0	0	0.0	1
13	Delaynee King (Sr)	4	1	1	2	0.5	1

Garrett

Blocking

#	Athlete Name	SP	BS	BA	Tot Blks	B/S
	Team Totals	4	1	10	6	1.5
3	Kaylee Gaar (Fr)	4	0	0	0	0.0
4	P. Grindstaff (So)	4	0	0	0	0.0
7	Carlie Thomas (Fr)	4	0	0	0	0.0
8	Piper Ice (Fr)	4	0	5	5	1.3
9	Rilyn Flotow (Jr)	4	0	0	0	0.0
10	Kaelynn York (So)	4	0	0	0	0.0
11	Sarah Depew (Sr)	4	0	2	2	0.5
12	Hadley Flotow (So)	4	1	0	1	0.3
14	McKenna Naglack (Fr)	2	0	0	0	0.0
15	Amelia Kesterke (Jr)	4	0	3	3	0.8

Columbia City

Digging

#	Athlete Name	SP	D	DE	D/S
	Team Totals	4	40	27	10.0
1	Maddy Hiss (Jr)	4	3	0	0.8
2	S. Wilkinson (Jr)	4	12	10	3.0
3	Emme Carnahan (Sr)	4	6	7	1.5
4	S. Van buskirk (Sr)	4	5	2	1.3
5	M. Fraunfelder (Sr)	4	7	1	1.8
6	Ella Peppler (So)	4	5	5	1.3
7	Bree Rumschlag (Sr)	4	0	1	0.0
9	Norah Sheets (So)	2	0	0	0.0
11	Gabby Miller (Sr)	4	1	1	0.3
13	Delaynee King (Sr)	4	1	0	0.3

Garrett

Digging

#	Athlete Name	SP	D	D/S
	Team Totals	4	63	15.8
3	Kaylee Gaar (Fr)	4	25	6.3
4	P. Grindstaff (So)	4	10	2.5
7	Carlie Thomas (Fr)	4	1	0.3
8	Piper Ice (Fr)	4	0	0.0
9	Rilyn Flotow (Jr)	4	7	1.8
10	Kaelynn York (So)	4	1	0.3
11	Sarah Depew (Sr)	4	9	2.3
12	Hadley Flotow (So)	4	2	0.5
14	McKenna Naglack (Fr)	2	0	0.0
15	Amelia Kesterke (Jr)	4	8	2.0

Columbia City

Ball Handling

#	Athlete Name	SP	Ast	Ast/S	BHA	BHE
	Team Totals	4	31	7.8	112	2
1	Maddy Hiss (Jr)	4	0	0.0	0	0
2	S. Wilkinson (Jr)	4	3	0.8	17	0
3	Emme Carnahan (Sr)	4	13	3.3	40	2
4	S. Van buskirk (Sr)	4	15	3.8	55	0
5	M. Fraunfelder (Sr)	4	0	0.0	0	0
6	Ella Peppler (So)	4	0	0.0	0	0
7	Bree Rumschlag (Sr)	4	0	0.0	0	0
9	Norah Sheets (So)	2	0	0.0	0	0
11	Gabby Miller (Sr)	4	0	0.0	0	0
13	Delaynee King (Sr)	4	0	0.0	0	0

Garrett

Ball Handling

#	Athlete Name	SP	Ast	Ast/S	BHA	BHE
	Team Totals	4	48	12.0	124	3
3	Kaylee Gaar (Fr)	4	5	1.3	11	0
4	P. Grindstaff (So)	4	1	0.3	4	0
7	Carlie Thomas (Fr)	4	0	0.0	0	0
8	Piper Ice (Fr)	4	0	0.0	0	0
9	Rilyn Flotow (Jr)	4	23	5.8	54	3
10	Kaelynn York (So)	4	0	0.0	1	0
11	Sarah Depew (Sr)	4	1	0.3	2	0
12	Hadley Flotow (So)	4	2	0.5	4	0
14	McKenna Naglack (Fr)	2	0	0.0	0	0
15	Amelia Kesterke (Jr)	4	16	4.0	48	0

Columbia City

Serve Receiving

#	Athlete Name	SP	R	RE	R/S
	Team Totals	4	67	12	16.8
1	Maddy Hiss (Jr)	4	2	0	0.5
2	S. Wilkinson (Jr)	4	23	4	5.8
3	Emme Carnahan (Sr)	4	0	0	0.0
4	S. Van buskirk (Sr)	4	3	1	0.8
5	M. Fraunfelder (Sr)	4	10	0	2.5
6	Ella Peppler (So)	4	19	6	4.8
7	Bree Rumschlag (Sr)	4	0	0	0.0
9	Norah Sheets (So)	2	8	0	4.0
11	Gabby Miller (Sr)	4	0	0	0.0
13	Delaynee King (Sr)	4	2	1	0.5

Garrett

Serve Receiving

#	Athlete Name	SP	R	RE	R/S
	Team Totals	4	66	7	16.5
3	Kaylee Gaar (Fr)	4	23	2	5.8
4	P. Grindstaff (So)	4	6	2	1.5
7	Carlie Thomas (Fr)	4	0	0	0.0
8	Piper Ice (Fr)	4	0	0	0.0
9	Rilyn Flotow (Jr)	4	0	0	0.0
10	Kaelynn York (So)	4	9	1	2.3
11	Sarah Depew (Sr)	4	27	2	6.8
12	Hadley Flotow (So)	4	0	0	0.0
14	McKenna Naglack (Fr)	2	1	0	0.5
15	Amelia Kesterke (Jr)	4	0	0	0.0

Match Story

Indiana High School Volleyball - Columbia City Garrett

August 26, 2025: Garrett, IN 46738

Garrett Railroaders (Garrett, IN) boosters left the game thrilled Tuesday as they saw their volleyball squad achieve victory over the visiting Columbia City Eagles (Columbia City, IN), 3-1 in a non-league test.

With the win, Garrett improves its record to 5-0 on the season. The Railroaders travel to East Noble (Kendallville, IN) to encounter the Knights in a non-league test on Thursday, August 28. The Knights go into the test with a record of 4-5. East Noble won 3-0 in their recent non-league test against Fort Wayne North Side (Fort Wayne, IN)

The Eagles now own a 3-2 record. They put it on the line next when they host Fort Wayne South Side for a non-league test on Thursday, August 28. Columbia City will encounter a Archers squad coming off a 3-0 non-league loss to Fort Wayne Blackhawk Christian (Fort Wayne, IN). The Archers record now stands at 0-1.

Columbia City @ Garrett Volleyball Match Info

Tue., Aug. 26, 2025 @ 7p

The Garrett (IN) varsity volleyball team won Tuesday's home non-conference match against Columbia City (IN) by a score of 3-1.

Rankings & Records

Columbia City (25-26)

IN	Class
187	61

Overall	Conference	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	Conference %	SW	SL
10-19	2-5	3-5	5-9	2-5	.345	.286	40	57

Garrett (25-26)

IN	Class
107	39

Overall	Conference	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	Conference %	SW	SL
21-9	8-2	11-2	5-4	5-3	.700	.800	62	35

Team Scoring Averages

	S1	S2	S3	S4	S5	Wins
Columbia City	20.0	20.4	19.9	19.7	9.0	1.4
Garrett	22.8	23.3	20.9	22.8	14.0	2.1

Team Stat Comparison

Columbia City		Garrett
780	Kills	982
112	Total Blocks	92
209	Serving Aces	271
533	Digs	1365
667	Assists	921
1411	Receptions	1540

Team Leaders

Columbia City		Garrett	National Avg.
#8 Liz Blackburn239	Kills	#15 Amelia Kesterke264	53
#7 Bree Rumschlag56	Total Blocks	#15 Amelia Kesterke45	11
#4 Sophia Van buskirk56	Serving Aces	#9 Rilyn Flotow63	16
#2 Sydney Wilkinson177	Digs	#3 Kaylee Gaar484	84
#4 Sophia Van buskirk515	Assists	#9 Rilyn Flotow618	50
#2 Sydney Wilkinson483	Receptions	#3 Kaylee Gaar622	86

Common Opponents

School	Common Opp. Rec.		School	Common Opp. Rec.
Columbia City	5-9		Garrett	9-5

Date	Away	Home	Result	Date	Away	Home	Result
8/16/25	Angola	Columbia City	(L) 3-1	9/25/25	Garrett	Angola	(L) 3-0
				10/11/25	Angola	Garrett	(L) 2-0
8/19/25	Columbia City	Fort Wayne North Side	(W) 3-0	10/6/25	Fort Wayne North Side	Garrett	(W) 3-0
8/30/25	Columbia City	East Noble	(L) 2-0	8/28/25	Garrett	East Noble	(L) 3-1
10/2/25	Columbia City	East Noble	(L) 3-2
8/30/25	Columbia City	Lakeland	(L) 2-0	9/2/25	Lakeland	Garrett	(W) 3-0
9/2/25	Columbia City	Churubusco	(W) 3-1	8/21/25	Garrett	Churubusco	(W) 3-1
9/4/25	Columbia City	Fort Wayne Concordia Lutheran	(L) 3-1	10/18/25	Garrett	Fort Wayne Concordia Lutheran	(L) 3-0
9/9/25	Columbia City	Manchester	(L) 3-1	9/6/25	Manchester	Garrett	(L) 2-1
9/20/25	Columbia City	Wabash	(L) 2-1	9/20/25	Wabash	Garrett	(W) 2-0
9/20/25	Columbia City	Elkhart Christian Academy	(L) 2-1	9/20/25	Elkhart Christian Academy	Garrett	(W) 2-0
9/22/25	Columbia City	Fort Wayne Blackhawk Christian	(W) 3-1	8/16/25	Fort Wayne Blackhawk Christian	Garrett	(W) 3-2
9/25/25	New Haven	Columbia City	(W) 3-0	9/6/25	New Haven	Garrett	(W) 2-0
9/30/25	Columbia City	DeKalb	(W) 3-1	9/29/25	DeKalb	Garrett	(W) 3-0
10/7/25	Leo	Columbia City	(L) 3-0	10/14/25	Garrett	Leo	(W) 3-1

Record Breakdown

Columbia City (25-26)		Garrett (25-26)
10-19	Overall	21-9
2-5	League	9-4
6-8	Non-League	6-2
0-1	Head to Head	1-0
5-9	Common Opponent	9-5
3-5	Home	11-2
5-9	Away	5-4
2-5	Neutral	5-3
0-1	Playoff	1-1
10-19	In-State	21-9
0-0	Out-of-State	0-0