Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

Payson St. Johns

Longhorns

Redskins

The St. Johns (AZ) varsity soccer team won Thursday's home non-conference match against Payson (AZ) by a score of 4-3.

	1	2	Final
Payson	-	-	3
St. Johns	-	-	4

Final score provided by S. AIA.

Recap
Box Score
Matchup Info

Match Stats

St. Johns (25-26)

Payson

Field Stats

#	Athlete Name	Goals	Asst	Pts
	Team Totals	3	1	7
3	Tatum McDowell (Sr)	2		4
7	A. Utterback (Sr)	1	1	3

St. Johns

Field Stats

#	Athlete Name	Goals	Asst	Pts
	Team Totals	4	3	11
26	Avalon Udall (Jr)	3		6
31	Lucy Sundahl (Jr)		1	1
33	A. Richardson (So)	1	2	4

Payson

#	Athlete Name	G	Shots	SOG	SOG %
	Team Totals	3	23	9	.4
2	A. Meredith (Sr)		4		.0
3	Tatum McDowell (Sr)	2	6	3	.5
7	A. Utterback (Sr)	1	6	3	.5
9	K. Hanewinckel (So)		3	1	.3
10	Christina Otte (Jr)		2	2	1.0
15	Morgan Cluff (Jr)		1		.0
24	Anna Madrid (Jr)		1		.0

St. Johns

#	Athlete Name	G
	Team Totals	4
26	Avalon Udall (Jr)	3
33	A. Richardson (So)	1

Payson

Goaltending

#	Athlete Name	G. Min	OT Min	Opp SOG	GA	Saves	Save %	GAA
	Team Totals	80		4	4	0	.0	4.000
00	Ellie Klein (So)	80		4	4	0	.0	4.000

Goaltending

St. Johns has not entered any goaltending stats.

Match Story

Arizona High School Soccer - Payson nudged by St. Johns

September 25, 2025: St. Johns, AZ 85936

St. Johns Redskins (St. Johns, AZ) fans went home happy Thursday as they saw their soccer squad hold off the visiting Payson Longhorns (Payson, AZ), 4-3 in a non-league outing.

The Redskins (8-1) will now prepare for their outing against Northland Prep Academy (Flagstaff, AZ). The Spartans enter the non-league test with a 12-1 record. In their last test, Northland Prep Academy Show Low (Show Low, AZ), 2-2, in a non-league test.

The Longhorns now sport a 11-5 record. They take the field next when they host Chino Valley for a AIA Fall - Central test on Tuesday, September 30. Payson will clash with a Cougars team coming off a 8-0 non-league win over Red Rock (Sedona, AZ). The Cougars record now stands at 4-3.

Payson @ St. Johns Soccer Match Info

Thu., Sep. 25, 2025 @ 6p

St. Johns Middle School

The St. Johns (AZ) varsity soccer team won Thursday's home non-conference match against Payson (AZ) by a score of 4-3.

Rankings & Records

Payson (25-26)

National	AZ	Div.
1,378	4	4

Overall	Region	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	Region %	GF	GA
14-8	5-0	9-3	5-4	0-1	.636	1.000	96	38

St. Johns (25-26)

National	AZ	Div.
668	1	1

Overall	Region	Home	Away	Neutral	Win %	Region %	GF	GA
18-2	6-0	10-1	8-0	0-1	.900	1.000	91	24

Team Scoring Averages

	1	2	OT1	OT2	OT3	Final	SO
Payson	.2	1.0	0	1.0	-	4.4	-
St. Johns	1.3	.8	1.0	0	4.0	4.6	2.0

Head-to-Head

St. Johns won on 8/26/2025

8/26 @ 6p 1 2 Final

St. Johns - - 1
Payson 0 0 0

The St. Johns (AZ) varsity soccer team won Tuesday's away non-conference match against Payson (AZ) by a score of 1-0.
Box score
St. Johns won on 9/25/2025

9/25 @ 6p 1 2 Final

Payson - - 3
St. Johns - - 4

The Payson (AZ) varsity soccer team lost Thursday's away non-conference match against St. Johns (AZ) by a score of 4-3.
Box score
St. Johns won on 10/30/2025

10/30 @ 6p 1 2 Final

Payson 0 1 1
St. Johns 3 0 3

The Payson (AZ) varsity soccer team lost Thursday's away playoff match against St. Johns (AZ) by a score of 3-1.
Box score

8/26 @ 6p	1	2	Final
St. Johns	-	-	1
Payson	0	0	0

10/30 @ 6p	1	2	Final
Payson	0	1	1
St. Johns	3	0	3

Team Stat Comparison

Payson		St. Johns
101	Goals	82
66	Assists	55
566	Shots	-
2.207	Goals Against Average	-

Team Leaders

Payson		St. Johns	National Avg.
#3 Tatum McDowell20	Goals	#26 Avalon Udall26	5
#7 Amylynn Utterback11	Assists	#26 Avalon Udall25	3
#9 Kealli Hanewinckel108	Shots	-	13
#00 Ellie Klein2.047	Goals Against Average	-	2.767

Common Opponents

School	Common Opp. Rec.		School	Common Opp. Rec.
Payson	11-4		St. Johns	14-2

Date	Away	Home	Result	Date	Away	Home	Result
8/19/25	Payson	Round Valley	(W) 9-1	9/3/25	St. Johns	Round Valley	(W) 4-1
				10/15/25	Round Valley	St. Johns	(W) 7-0
8/21/25	Blue Ridge	Payson	(L) 3-1	8/29/25	St. Johns	Blue Ridge	(W) 4-1
9/23/25	Blue Ridge	Payson	(W) 4-3	10/23/25	Blue Ridge	St. Johns	(W) 6-4
10/16/25	Payson	Blue Ridge	(L) 3-2
8/22/25	Show Low	Payson	(W) 4-1	8/30/25	Show Low	St. Johns	(L) 1-1
9/4/25	Show Low	Payson	(W) 1-0	9/16/25	Show Low	St. Johns	(W) 4-1
8/22/25	Snowflake	Payson	(W) 5-3	9/8/25	St. Johns	Snowflake	(W) 3-2
10/22/25	Snowflake	Payson	(L) 5-2
9/2/25	Payson	Red Rock	(W) 9-0	10/6/25	St. Johns	Red Rock	(W) 7-0
9/9/25	Winslow	Payson	(W) 12-1	9/23/25	St. Johns	Winslow	(W) 8-0
9/13/25	Payson	Northland Prep Academy	(L) 4-2	9/20/25	St. Johns	Northland Prep Academy	(L) 3-0
10/2/25	Northland Prep Academy	Payson	(W) 4-3	9/30/25	Northland Prep Academy	St. Johns	(W) 2-0
				11/1/25	Northland Prep Academy	St. Johns	(W) 6-5
9/16/25	Holbrook	Payson	(W) 8-0	9/10/25	St. Johns	Holbrook	(W) 8-0
9/18/25	Payson	Camp Verde	(W) 6-0	10/9/25	Camp Verde	St. Johns	(W) 8-0
9/30/25	Chino Valley	Payson	(W) 6-0	9/19/25	Chino Valley	St. Johns	(W) 7-0
				10/1/25	St. Johns	Chino Valley	(W) 2-0

Record Breakdown

Payson (25-26)		St. Johns (25-26)
14-8	Overall	18-2
5-0	League	6-0
4-4	Non-League	8-0
0-3	Head to Head	3-0
11-4	Common Opponent	14-2
9-3	Home	10-1
5-4	Away	8-0
0-1	Neutral	0-1
0-1	Playoff	2-0
11-7	In-State	17-2
2-1	Out-of-State	1-0