Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

Show LowPayson

Cougars
0
Longhorns
1

The Payson (AZ) varsity soccer team won Thursday's home non-conference match against Show Low (AZ) by a score of 1-0.

12Final
Show Low000
Payson--1
Final score provided by S. AIA.
  • Recap
  • Box Score
  • Awards
  • Matchup Info

Match Stats

Show Low (25-26)

Payson (25-26)

Field Stats

Show Low has not entered any field stats stats.
Payson

Field Stats

#Athlete NameMinGoalsAsstPtsStlsCK
Team Totals12
10Christina Otte (Jr)12

Show Low has not entered any field stats stats.
Payson

#Athlete NameGShotsSOGSOG %PKGPKAGWGYCRC
Team Totals1266.2
2A. Meredith (Sr)20.0
3Tatum McDowell (Sr)20.0
7A. Utterback (Sr)40.0
9K. Hanewinckel (So)40.0
10Christina Otte (Jr)152.4
15Morgan Cluff (Jr)31.3
24Anna Madrid (Jr)53.6
25Morgan Vold (Jr)10.0
Show Low

Goaltending

#Athlete NameG. MinOT MinOpp SOGGASavesSave %GAA
Team Totals10.0
27Naomi Tapia (Sr)10.0
Payson

Goaltending

#Athlete NameG. MinOT MinOpp SOGGASavesSave %GAA
Team Totals80771.00.000
00Ellie Klein (So)80771.00.000
Show Low

#Athlete NamePK SavesPKASOWinLossTie
Team Totals1
27Naomi Tapia (Sr)1
Payson

#Athlete NamePK SavesPKASOWinLossTie
Team Totals1
00Ellie Klein (So)1

Match Story

Arizona High School Soccer - Show Low nudged by Payson

September 4, 2025: Payson, AZ 85541

Payson Longhorns (Payson, AZ) boosters exited the stadium pleased Thursday as they witnessed their soccer team get by the visiting Show Low Cougars (Show Low, AZ), 1-0 in a non-league test.

With the triumph, Payson moves its record to 3-3 on the campaign. The Longhorns host Winslow (Winslow, AZ) to clash with the Bulldogs in a AIA Fall - Central outing on Tuesday, September 9. The Bulldogs go into the outing with a record of 0-1.

Next up, the Cougars confront the Chino Valley Cougars (Chino Valley, AZ) in a non-league outing, on Saturday, September 6. Show Low will attempt to improve on its 1-3 season record. The Cougars go into the outing with a 0-1 record after their 4-3 league loss to Camp Verde (Camp Verde, AZ).

Players of the Match

Show Low (25-26)

Show Low has not selected any Players of the Match.

Payson (25-26)

Congratulations to #00 Ellie Klein for being selected the Payson Girls Soccer Player of the Match.

Show Low @ Payson Soccer Match Info

Thu., Sep. 4, 2025 @ 6:30p
Rumsey Park
The Payson (AZ) varsity soccer team won Thursday's home non-conference match against Show Low (AZ) by a score of 1-0.

Rankings & Records

Show Low (25-26)

NationalAZDiv.
1,68966
OverallRegionHomeAwayNeutralWin %Region %GFGA
13-7-13-27-0-12-64-1.643.6008840

Payson (25-26)

NationalAZDiv.
1,34044
OverallRegionHomeAwayNeutralWin %Region %GFGA
14-85-09-35-40-1.6361.0009638

Team Scoring Averages

12OT1OT2FinalSO
Show Low		00--4.23.0
Payson		.21.001.04.4-

Head-to-Head

  • Payson won on 8/22/2025
    8/22 @ 9a12Final
    Show Low--1
    Payson--4

    The Show Low (AZ) varsity soccer team lost Friday's away tournament match against Payson (AZ) by a score of 4-1.

    Box score
  • Payson won on 9/4/2025
    9/4 @ 6:30p12Final
    Show Low000
    Payson--1

    The Show Low (AZ) varsity soccer team lost Thursday's away non-conference match against Payson (AZ) by a score of 1-0.

    Box score

Team Stat Comparison

Show LowPayson
89Goals101
79Assists66
-1Shots566
-Goals Against Average2.207

Team Leaders

Show LowPaysonNational Avg.
#6 Taylynn Butler20Goals#3 Tatum McDowell205
#13 Sofie Ellis23Assists#7 Amylynn Utterback113
#31 Serenity Lundstrom-1Shots#9 Kealli Hanewinckel10813
-
Goals Against Average#00 Ellie Klein2.0472.752

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Show Low11-5-1Payson9-7
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
8/19/25Show LowNorthland Prep Academy(L) 6-09/13/25PaysonNorthland Prep Academy(L) 4-2
9/26/25Northland Prep AcademyShow Low(T) 2-210/2/25Northland Prep AcademyPayson(W) 4-3
10/28/25Show LowNorthland Prep Academy(L) 4-0
8/21/25SnowflakeShow Low(L) 3-28/22/25SnowflakePayson(W) 5-3
8/26/25Show LowSnowflake(L) 6-010/22/25SnowflakePayson(L) 5-2
8/21/25WinslowShow Low(W) 4-19/9/25WinslowPayson(W) 12-1
10/15/25WinslowShow Low(W) 7-1
8/22/25Round ValleyShow Low(W) 5-08/19/25PaysonRound Valley(W) 9-1
9/23/25Round ValleyShow Low(W) 8-0
8/30/25Show LowSt. Johns(W) 1-18/26/25St. JohnsPayson(L) 1-0
9/16/25Show LowSt. Johns(L) 4-19/25/25PaysonSt. Johns(L) 4-3
10/30/25PaysonSt. Johns(L) 3-1
9/6/25Show LowChino Valley(W) 8-09/30/25Chino ValleyPayson(W) 6-0
10/14/25Chino ValleyShow Low(W) 7-0
9/29/25Red RockShow Low(W) 11-09/2/25PaysonRed Rock(W) 9-0
10/2/25Blue RidgeShow Low(W) 5-48/21/25Blue RidgePayson(L) 3-1
9/23/25Blue RidgePayson(W) 4-3
10/16/25PaysonBlue Ridge(L) 3-2
10/20/25Camp VerdeShow Low(W) 9-29/18/25PaysonCamp Verde(W) 6-0
10/23/25HolbrookShow Low(W) 9-09/16/25HolbrookPayson(W) 8-0

Record Breakdown

Show Low (25-26)

Payson (25-26)
13-7-1
Overall
14-8
3-2
League
5-0
5-2-1
Non-League
4-4
0-2
Head to Head
2-0
11-5-1
Common Opponent
9-7
7-0-1
Home
9-3
2-6
Away
5-4
4-1
Neutral
0-1
0-1
Playoff
0-1
11-7-1
In-State
11-7
2-0
Out-of-State
2-1