| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1851 | Millburn | NJ | 7-11-0 | -3.24 | 0.1 | +12 |
| 1852 | Francis Scott Key | MD | 4-9-0 | -3.27 | 6.0 | +58 |
| 1853 | Delmar | DE | 7-8-0 | -3.27 | -2.0 | -12 |
| 1854 | Columbus | NY | 6-5-0 | -3.27 | -5.7 | -275 |
| 1855 | Fryeburg | ME | 8-7-0 | -3.28 | -2.9 | +10 |
| 1856 | Southern Alamance | NC | 14-9-0 | -3.28 | -6.5 | +6 |
| 1857 | Riverdale Country | NY | 7-7-1 | -3.29 | -1.3 | +37 |
| 1858 | Eastlake | CA | 7-8-0 | -3.30 | -1.6 | +55 |
| 1859 | William Floyd | NY | 0-6-0 | -3.32 | 14.6 | +33 |
| 1860 | Cypress Lake | FL | 10-5-0 | -3.32 | -4.2 | -4 |
| 1861 | Blind Brook | NY | 6-5-0 | -3.34 | -5.3 | +54 |
| 1862 | N Nipmuc Regional | MA | 8-9-0 | -3.35 | -2.5 | +8 |
| 1863 | Turpin | OH | 10-9-0 | -3.37 | -2.9 | +3 |
| 1864 | Green Mountain | CO | 6-10-0 | -3.38 | 3.4 | -10 |
| 1865 | Brooks | MA | 1-7-0 | -3.38 | 10.9 | -254 |
| 1866 | Jackson-Reed | DC | 6-7-0 | -3.38 | -2.4 | +3 |
| 1867 | Grace | CA | 10-6-0 | -3.39 | -6.8 | +39 |
| 1868 | Dallastown | PA | 6-10-0 | -3.39 | 0.5 | +6 |
| 1869 | Sierra Canyon | CA | 0-6-0 | -3.41 | 13.4 | +92 |
| 1870 | La Salle Institute | NY | 4-13-0 | -3.43 | 6.1 | -17 |
| 1871 | Maple Mountain | UT | 5-11-0 | -3.45 | 5.1 | +10 |
| 1872 | Sussex Tech | DE | 6-9-0 | -3.48 | -0.1 | -30 |
| 1873 | Seneca Valley | MD | 8-5-0 | -3.49 | -5.1 | +32 |
| 1874 | Old Saybrook | CT | 8-7-0 | -3.51 | -2.1 | -96 |
| 1875 | Nutley | NJ | 10-10-0 | -3.51 | -2.8 | +9 |