| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1851 | Salmon River | NY | 7-8-0 | -4.15 | -2.3 | -67 |
| 1852 | Sierra Canyon | CA | 0-6-0 | -4.16 | 12.6 | -33 |
| 1853 | Middle Country | NY | 0-6-0 | -4.16 | 14.3 | -6 |
| 1854 | Solon | OH | 6-12-0 | -4.17 | 2.3 | -21 |
| 1855 | John Glenn | OH | 10-10-0 | -4.19 | -3.6 | -2 |
| 1856 | Chaparral | CO | 4-11-0 | -4.20 | 4.0 | -14 |
| 1857 | Westwood | NJ | 8-10-0 | -4.21 | -2.5 | -16 |
| 1858 | Seminole | FL | 6-11-0 | -4.24 | 1.0 | -13 |
| 1859 | Blind Brook | NY | 6-5-0 | -4.24 | -6.3 | -11 |
| 1860 | Vestal | NY | 0-8-0 | -4.24 | 13.4 | -91 |
| 1861 | Gaithersburg | MD | 8-5-0 | -4.24 | -6.0 | -9 |
| 1862 | Reagan | NC | 8-14-0 | -4.24 | 2.3 | -13 |
| 1863 | Mercersburg Academy | PA | 3-6-0 | -4.25 | 1.7 | -8 |
| 1864 | New Hope-Solebury | PA | 8-10-0 | -4.26 | -3.0 | +11 |
| 1865 | Johnson City | NY | 1-6-0 | -4.27 | 8.5 | -95 |
| 1866 | Godwin | VA | 3-12-0 | -4.27 | 8.2 | -34 |
| 1867 | Brockport | NY | 6-7-0 | -4.27 | -3.4 | +46 |
| 1868 | Crescenta Valley | CA | 11-9-0 | -4.28 | -4.0 | -5 |
| 1869 | Notre Dame | NY | 8-8-0 | -4.29 | -4.5 | -95 |
| 1870 | Big Walnut | OH | 5-12-0 | -4.33 | 3.9 | -5 |
| 1871 | Olympia | FL | 8-7-0 | -4.34 | -5.7 | -14 |
| 1872 | Highland | UT | 8-11-0 | -4.34 | 0.0 | -16 |
| 1873 | Latin | IL | 7-11-0 | -4.36 | 0.2 | +5 |
| 1874 | Walt Whitman | NY | 0-7-0 | -4.36 | 13.9 | -38 |
| 1875 | Connetquot | NY | 0-6-0 | -4.37 | 13.1 | -13 |