| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | Greater Garrett County | MD | 7-3-0 | -5.12 | -9.1 | -21 |
| 2002 | Middle Country | NY | 0-6-0 | -5.12 | 13.2 | -24 |
| 2003 | Clinton-Massie | OH | 11-3-0 | -5.15 | -13.7 | -24 |
| 2004 | Troy | MI | 4-10-0 | -5.17 | 2.1 | -16 |
| 2005 | Catholic Central | MI | 1-12-0 | -5.18 | 9.9 | -19 |
| 2006 | Archbishop Ryan | PA | 1-8-0 | -5.18 | 8.2 | +32 |
| 2007 | Goshen Central | NY | 7-9-0 | -5.20 | -3.1 | -18 |
| 2008 | Whitefield Academy | GA | 6-12-0 | -5.25 | 1.2 | -14 |
| 2009 | Brecksville-Broadview Heights | OH | 4-13-0 | -5.25 | 5.2 | -36 |
| 2010 | Academic Magnet | SC | 10-8-0 | -5.27 | -7.8 | -14 |
| 2011 | Johnstown-Monroe | OH | 10-8-0 | -5.27 | -8.2 | -24 |
| 2012 | Bloomington South | IN | 8-4-0 | -5.28 | -11.9 | -20 |
| 2013 | Morris Hills | NJ | 6-10-0 | -5.29 | -1.1 | -20 |
| 2014 | Smoky Hill | CO | 9-7-0 | -5.29 | -6.7 | -19 |
| 2015 | Steward | VA | 3-9-0 | -5.30 | 3.3 | -30 |
| 2016 | Arlington | NY | 3-9-0 | -5.31 | 3.1 | -16 |
| 2017 | Hamilton | WI | 1-3-0 | -5.32 | 3.8 | -27 |
| 2018 | Shelby County | KY | 13-6-0 | -5.32 | -12.2 | -21 |
| 2019 | Appoquinimink | DE | 6-8-0 | -5.36 | -1.7 | -21 |
| 2020 | Middletown North | NJ | 6-16-0 | -5.36 | 2.6 | -19 |
| 2021 | Stafford | VA | 9-8-0 | -5.38 | -6.9 | -16 |
| 2022 | Hammond | SC | 5-8-0 | -5.38 | -0.7 | -20 |
| 2023 | Godwin | VA | 3-12-0 | -5.42 | 7.0 | -182 |
| 2024 | Kings Park | NY | 0-7-0 | -5.42 | 12.7 | -20 |
| 2025 | Muskego | WI | 1-4-0 | -5.44 | 10.1 | -26 |