Get Unlimited Access – for Free

See all the latest scores & stats from your favorite teams! Simply sign in or create your free MaxPreps account to unlock this page - it only takes a minute to join.

GarawaySandy Valley
Pirates
42
Cardinals
45

The Sandy Valley (Magnolia, OH) varsity basketball team won Tuesday's home conference game against Garaway (Sugarcreek, OH) in overtime by a score of 45-42.

Q1Q2Q3Q4OT1OT2OT3Final
Garaway9176522142
Sandy Valley5149922445
Final score provided by C. Minor.
  • Recap
  • Scoretracker
  • Matchup

Game Story

Ohio High School Basketball - Sandy Valley nips Garaway

January 23, 2024: Magnolia, OH 44643

Fans at Tuesday's league challenge between the Sandy Valley Cardinals (Magnolia, OH) and the visiting Garaway Pirates (Sugarcreek, OH), saw Sandy Valley's basketball squad hold off Garaway by a tally of 45-42.

With the victory, Sandy Valley improves its record to 10-3 on the campaign. The Cardinals travel to Ridgewood (West Lafayette, OH) to play the Generals in a Inter-Valley challenge on Friday, January 26. The Generals come into the challenge with a record of 4-11. Ridgewood lost 62-29 in their recent league challenge against Hiland (Berlin, OH)

Next up, the Pirates play the Tuscarawas Valley Trojans (Zoarville, OH) in a Inter-Valley challenge, on Friday, January 26. Garaway will attempt to improve on its 8-5 season record. The Trojans come into the challenge with a 5-7 record after their 44-41 league win over Claymont (Uhrichsville, OH).

Charles MinorPirates Reporter
  • All
  • Q1
  • Q2
  • Q3
  • Q4
  • OT
  • F

  1. Check In

    0 - 0 The scorer has checked in. Garaway 0, Sandy Valley 0
    Posted @ 6:36p

  2. Game Attendance

    Attendance Hundreds
    Posted @ 6:36p
  3. 0 - 0

    Game Start

    Garaway1st Quarter
    Garaway won the tip off.
    Posted @ 7:28p
  4. 3 - 0

    Score Alert

    Garaway1st Quarter
    Garaway - #24 Jenson Garber makes a 3pt Field Goal. Garaway 3, Sandy Valley 0
    Posted @ 7:28p
  5. 3 - 1

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley1st Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a Free Throw. Garaway 3, Sandy Valley 1
    Posted @ 7:30p
  6. 3 - 2

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley1st Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a Free Throw. Garaway 3, Sandy Valley 2
    Posted @ 7:30p
  7. 5 - 2

    Score Alert

    Garaway1st Quarter
    Garaway - #5 Blaine Raber makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 5, Sandy Valley 2
    Posted @ 7:31p
  8. 7 - 2

    Score Alert

    Garaway1st Quarter
    Garaway - #2 Wyatt Wallick makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 7, Sandy Valley 2
    Posted @ 7:34p
  9. 9 - 2

    Score Alert

    Garaway1st Quarter
    Garaway - #5 Blaine Raber makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 9, Sandy Valley 2
    Posted @ 7:36p
  10. 9 - 3

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley1st Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #1 Brodie Kelly makes a Free Throw. Garaway 9, Sandy Valley 3
    Posted @ 7:38p
  11. 9 - 5

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley1st Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #2 Trey Nicholson makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 9, Sandy Valley 5
    Posted @ 7:39p
  12. 9 - 5

    End of 1st Quarter

    2nd Quarter
    Garaway 9, Sandy Valley 5
    Posted @ 7:42p
  13. 11 - 5

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #14 Jackson Reifenschneider makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 11, Sandy Valley 5
    Posted @ 7:44p
  14. 13 - 5

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #10 Gabe Amicone makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 13, Sandy Valley 5
    Posted @ 7:46p
  15. 13 - 6

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a Free Throw. Garaway 13, Sandy Valley 6
    Posted @ 7:47p
  16. 13 - 7

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a Free Throw. Garaway 13, Sandy Valley 7
    Posted @ 7:47p
  17. 15 - 7

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #12 makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 15, Sandy Valley 7
    Posted @ 7:47p
  18. 15 - 9

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #11 makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 15, Sandy Valley 9
    Posted @ 7:48p
  19. 17 - 9

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #24 Jenson Garber makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 17, Sandy Valley 9
    Posted @ 7:48p
  20. 19 - 9

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #10 Gabe Amicone makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 19, Sandy Valley 9
    Posted @ 7:50p
  21. 19 - 11

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 19, Sandy Valley 11
    Posted @ 7:51p
  22. 22 - 11

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #10 Gabe Amicone makes a 3pt Field Goal. Garaway 22, Sandy Valley 11
    Posted @ 7:51p
  23. 22 - 13

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 22, Sandy Valley 13
    Posted @ 7:52p
  24. 23 - 13

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #15 makes a Free Throw. Garaway 23, Sandy Valley 13
    Posted @ 7:53p
  25. 24 - 13

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #15 makes a Free Throw. Garaway 24, Sandy Valley 13
    Posted @ 7:53p
  26. 24 - 15

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 24, Sandy Valley 15
    Posted @ 7:54p
  27. 24 - 16

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a Free Throw. Garaway 24, Sandy Valley 16
    Posted @ 7:55p
  28. 24 - 19

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #1 Brodie Kelly makes a 3pt Field Goal. Garaway 24, Sandy Valley 19
    Posted @ 7:57p
  29. 26 - 19

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Quarter
    Garaway - #15 makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 26, Sandy Valley 19
    Posted @ 7:57p
  30. 26 - 19

    Halftime

    Halftime
    Garaway 26, Sandy Valley 19
    We noticed it's halftime, please enjoy this video while you wait for the action to resume.
    Posted @ 7:58p
  31. 26 - 19

    Start of 3rd Quarter

    Sandy Valley3rd Quarter
    Sandy Valley's ball.
    Posted @ 8:09p
  32. 26 - 21

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley3rd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #2 Trey Nicholson makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 26, Sandy Valley 21
    Posted @ 8:11p
  33. 26 - 23

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley3rd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #2 Trey Nicholson makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 26, Sandy Valley 23
    Posted @ 8:12p
  34. 28 - 23

    Score Alert

    Garaway3rd Quarter
    Garaway - #12 makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 28, Sandy Valley 23
    Posted @ 8:14p
  35. 28 - 25

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley3rd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #1 Brodie Kelly makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 28, Sandy Valley 25
    Posted @ 8:14p
  36. 30 - 25

    Score Alert

    Garaway3rd Quarter
    Garaway - #10 Gabe Amicone makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 30, Sandy Valley 25
    Posted @ 8:16p
  37. 32 - 25

    Score Alert

    Garaway3rd Quarter
    Garaway - #10 Gabe Amicone makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 32, Sandy Valley 25
    Posted @ 8:18p
  38. 32 - 27

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley3rd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 32, Sandy Valley 27
    Posted @ 8:18p
  39. 32 - 28

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley3rd Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a Free Throw. Garaway 32, Sandy Valley 28
    Posted @ 8:20p
  40. 32 - 28

    End of 3rd Quarter

    4th Quarter
    Garaway 32, Sandy Valley 28
    Posted @ 8:22p
  41. 34 - 28

    Score Alert

    Garaway4th Quarter
    Garaway - #12 makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 34, Sandy Valley 28
    Posted @ 8:25p
  42. 34 - 30

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley4th Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #11 makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 34, Sandy Valley 30
    Posted @ 8:25p
  43. 36 - 30

    Score Alert

    Garaway4th Quarter
    Garaway - #5 Blaine Raber makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 36, Sandy Valley 30
    Posted @ 8:27p
  44. 36 - 32

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley4th Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 36, Sandy Valley 32
    Posted @ 8:28p
  45. 36 - 34

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley4th Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #2 Trey Nicholson makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 36, Sandy Valley 34
    Posted @ 8:29p
  46. 37 - 34

    Score Alert

    Garaway4th Quarter
    Garaway - #10 Gabe Amicone makes a Free Throw. Garaway 37, Sandy Valley 34
    Posted @ 8:37p
  47. 37 - 37

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley4th Quarter
    Sandy Valley - #3 Logan Leichtamer makes a 3pt Field Goal. Garaway 37, Sandy Valley 37
    Posted @ 8:38p
  48. 37 - 37

    End of Regulation

    Overtime
    Garaway 37, Sandy Valley 37
    Posted @ 8:40p
  49. 37 - 39

    Score Alert

    Sandy ValleyOvertime
    Sandy Valley - #2 Trey Nicholson makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 37, Sandy Valley 39
    Posted @ 8:46p
  50. 38 - 39

    Score Alert

    GarawayOvertime
    Garaway - #10 Gabe Amicone makes a Free Throw. Garaway 38, Sandy Valley 39
    Posted @ 8:49p
  51. 39 - 39

    Score Alert

    GarawayOvertime
    Garaway - #10 Gabe Amicone makes a Free Throw. Garaway 39, Sandy Valley 39
    Posted @ 8:50p
  52. 39 - 39

    End of Overtime 1

    2nd Overtime
    Garaway 39, Sandy Valley 39
    Posted @ 8:50p
  53. 41 - 39

    Score Alert

    Garaway2nd Overtime
    Garaway - #2 Wyatt Wallick makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 41, Sandy Valley 39
    Posted @ 8:53p
  54. 41 - 41

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley2nd Overtime
    Sandy Valley - #21 Dantae Faiello makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 41, Sandy Valley 41
    Posted @ 8:53p
  55. 41 - 41

    End of Overtime 2

    3rd Overtime
    Garaway 41, Sandy Valley 41
    Posted @ 9p
  56. 41 - 43

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley3rd Overtime
    Sandy Valley - #2 Trey Nicholson makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 41, Sandy Valley 43
    Posted @ 9:06p
  57. 41 - 45

    Score Alert

    Sandy Valley3rd Overtime
    Sandy Valley - #2 Trey Nicholson makes a 2pt Field Goal. Garaway 41, Sandy Valley 45
    Posted @ 9:08p
  58. 42 - 45

    Score Alert

    Garaway3rd Overtime
    Garaway - #14 Jackson Reifenschneider makes a Free Throw. Garaway 42, Sandy Valley 45
    Posted @ 9:17p
  59. 42 - 45

    End of Game

    Final
    Garaway 42, Sandy Valley 45
    Posted @ 9:19p

Scoretracker Providers

Charles MinorPirates Reporter

Rankings & Records

Garaway (23-24)

OHDiv.
26451
OverallConferenceHomeAwayNeutralWin %Conference %PFPA
13-97-66-36-61-0.591.5381,087965

Sandy Valley (23-24)

OHDiv.
22638
OverallConferenceHomeAwayWin %Conference %PFPA
16-79-59-47-3.696.6431,2691,055

Team Scoring Averages

Q1Q2Q3Q4OT1OT2OT3Final
Garaway		12.111.510.312.17.82.01.049.4
Sandy Valley		12.614.713.210.82.02.04.055.2

Garaway Videos

Sandy Valley Videos

Sandy Valley doesn't have any videos.

Head-to-Head

  • Sandy Valley won on 1/23/2024
    1/23 @ 7pQ1Q2Q3Q4OT1OT2OT3Final
    Garaway9176522142
    Sandy Valley5149922445

    The Garaway (Sugarcreek, OH) varsity basketball team lost Tuesday's away conference game against Sandy Valley (Magnolia, OH) in overtime by a score of 45-42.

    Box score
  • Garaway won on 2/6/2024
    2/6 @ 7:30pQ1Q2Q3Q4Final
    Sandy Valley1618141058
    Garaway1922111466

    The Sandy Valley (Magnolia, OH) varsity basketball team lost Tuesday's away conference game against Garaway (Sugarcreek, OH) by a score of 66-58.

    Box score

Common Opponents

SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.SchoolCommon Opp. Rec.
Garaway7-5Sandy Valley8-4
DateAwayHomeResultDateAwayHomeResult
12/12/23GarawayHiland(L) 41-3612/19/23Sandy ValleyHiland(L) 44-41
1/19/24HilandGaraway(W) 51-401/30/24HilandSandy Valley(L) 63-57
12/15/23Tuscarawas ValleyGaraway(L) 34-291/9/24Tuscarawas ValleySandy Valley(L) 59-46
1/26/24GarawayTuscarawas Valley(L) 41-392/13/24Sandy ValleyTuscarawas Valley(W) 45-30
12/19/23GarawayIndian Valley(L) 52-4412/12/23Sandy ValleyIndian Valley(W) 64-56
1/30/24Indian ValleyGaraway(L) 53-482/3/24Indian ValleySandy Valley(L) 60-48
12/22/23RidgewoodGaraway(W) 52-2912/15/23RidgewoodSandy Valley(W) 72-48
2/2/24GarawayRidgewood(W) 48-321/26/24Sandy ValleyRidgewood(W) 52-33
12/23/23CarrolltonGaraway(W) 52-4312/2/23CarrolltonSandy Valley(W) 55-49
1/5/24ClaymontGaraway(W) 55-4112/22/23ClaymontSandy Valley(W) 54-37
2/9/24GarawayClaymont(W) 55-452/2/24Sandy ValleyClaymont(W) 43-39
2/16/24GarawayFairless(W) 38-231/6/24FairlessSandy Valley(W) 54-45

Record Breakdown

Garaway (23-24)

Sandy Valley (23-24)
13-9
Overall
16-7
7-6
League
9-5
6-2
Non-League
6-1
1-1
Head to Head
1-1
7-5
Common Opponent
8-4
6-3
Home
9-4
6-6
Away
7-3
1-0
Neutral
0-0
0-0
Playoff
0-0
13-9
In-State
16-7
0-0
Out-of-State
0-0