| # | Team | State | Ovr. | Rating | Str. | +/- |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | Iroquois West | IL | 3-2-0 | 1.55 | -2.1 | +8 |
| 2002 | Anderson Prep Academy | IN | 4-1-1 | 1.53 | -7.7 | -183 |
| 2003 | Moon Area | PA | 2-1-1 | 1.53 | -3.1 | -- |
| 2004 | South Point | OH | 2-1-0 | 1.52 | -7.6 | -383 |
| 2005 | Roeper | MI | 2-0-1 | 1.51 | -14.9 | -- |
| 2006 | Lyndhurst | NJ | 1-2-0 | 1.51 | 10.5 | -- |
| 2007 | Boston Latin | MA | 1-1-1 | 1.50 | 2.4 | -- |
| 2008 | Ashe County | NC | 3-2-0 | 1.50 | -4.5 | -291 |
| 2009 | Wisconsin Rapids Lincoln | WI | 2-1-1 | 1.49 | -2.9 | -531 |
| 2010 | Nashua North | NH | 1-2-1 | 1.49 | 8.7 | -76 |
| 2011 | Washington | WV | 2-3-0 | 1.49 | 6.9 | +196 |
| 2012 | West Carteret | NC | 3-3-0 | 1.48 | 2.1 | -409 |
| 2013 | Merrimack | NH | 2-1-0 | 1.48 | -5.8 | -- |
| 2014 | Pewaukee | WI | 2-0-2 | 1.48 | -7.5 | -34 |
| 2015 | Faith Christian | VA | 2-1-0 | 1.47 | -3.9 | -- |
| 2016 | Burlington | WI | 2-1-0 | 1.47 | -7.1 | -613 |
| 2017 | Memorial | OH | 3-1-0 | 1.46 | -10.5 | -386 |
| 2018 | Sunrise Mountain | NV | 2-1-1 | 1.45 | -3.1 | -338 |
| 2019 | Gramercy Christian | NC | 3-3-0 | 1.45 | 1.5 | -270 |
| 2020 | Brandywine | MI | 3-2-0 | 1.45 | -0.6 | -535 |
| 2021 | Highlands | NC | 2-1-0 | 1.44 | -3.7 | -336 |
| 2022 | New Mexico Military Institute | NM | 2-3-1 | 1.44 | 7.0 | +481 |
| 2023 | Belleville Mennonite | PA | 2-1-1 | 1.43 | -4.6 | -- |
| 2024 | Kettle Moraine | WI | 1-1-1 | 1.43 | 2.9 | -- |
| 2025 | Ozark | MO | 1-2-0 | 1.42 | 9.5 | -- |